Local News

<< Previous   of   Next >>   ADVERTISEMENT   ADDITIONAL ITEMS • Prosecutor's brief arguing against motion for new trial ( PDF) • Excerpt from trial testimony about underwear ( PDF)   CONTACT THE HERALD Robert Frank, City Editor frank@heraldnet.com   Published: Wednesday, March 26, 2008 Underwear test by a juror puts murder verdict in doubt By Jim Haley, Herald Writer EVERETT -- The "Fruit of the Loom" defense didn't work for an accused murderer in January, but attorneys are taking another shot at it after learning a Snohomish County juror experimented with his own underwear during the trial. In a rare move, a judge on Tuesday said she will order all 12 members of the panel back to court April 9 to get to the bottom of things by asking a few questions. She'll then decide if any juror misconduct warrants a new trial for Daniel Jay Perez, 21. Perez was convicted of second-degree murder for using the drawstring from his sweatpants to strangle his cellmate at the Monroe Reformatory in the Monroe Prison Complex. Perez confessed after the body of Cory Garzina, 24, was found in their cell, saying the marks on his hands came from the drawstring. At his January trial, Perez told a different story, saying the marks on his hands actually came from a unique suicide attempt. Perez testified that he was afraid of two other inmates who were the killers. So he tore the elastic waistband from his underwear and used it to try to strangle himself, causing the marks on his hands. During the trial, deputy prosecutor George Appel scoffed at Perez's story, asking if the jail-issued underwear had a waistband made of elastic or of steel cords, in order to cause the marks. They were "Fruit of the Loom," Perez responded. Jurors didn't buy what prosecutors called "The Fruit of the Loom" defense. In a conversation following the verdict, the jury foreman told prosecutors that at one point during the trial, another juror talked about going home and trying to rip the waistband off from his own underwear. From his experiment, the juror concluded that it would have been difficult for Perez to have entirely separated his underwear waistband from the rest of his drawers. When Perez's attorneys heard about the experiment, they asked for a new trial, alleging juror misconduct. Prosecutors argue that jurors are allowed to use knowledge within "a typical juror's general life experience," and that testing the durability of one's underwear waistband is just that. "It is highly likely that most of the jurors were wearing underwear throughout the trial," the prosecutors wrote in their legal briefs. "Therefore, pulling on the waistband of one's underwear is simply common experience." Public defender Caroline Mann told Judge Ellen Fair on Tuesday that there's not enough information to make a decision about what the juror did and said regarding his underwear test. Fair agreed. "I don't think the court has sufficient record to determine one way or the other," Fair said. Reporter Jim Haley: 425-339-3447 or jhaley@heraldnet.com.

1. Principal of Christian school in Arlington charged with child rape 2. 5 moms battle Lakewood Elementary School fire 3. Couple fight back against armed home invader 4. Traffic detoured around motorcycle accident in Lake Stevens 5. Teen burglar's own snapshot may help police catch him 6. Mill Creek teens robbed at gunpoint 7. More glory for former Snohomish High basketball coach 8. Local Briefly: Search-and-rescue teams look for hiker 9. Boeing stock plummets on analyst's downgrade 10. Transit driver has dangerous attitude 2 - Top 10 Stories Most Talked about 3 - Top 10 Stories Most Emailed

• Tour de Jour • Racing to help the helpless • It's coming: Make way for the new City Hall • They won't take it anymore • Meet the new Gateway principal • School activity buses could be restored • Mountlake Terrace hires new police chief • Council prefers a back seat in green movement • Students of the month • Arlington Fly-In marks 40th anniversary this year • Melody Biringer a wide-ranging entrepreneur • County home market offers low rates, lower prices, wide variety of prope ... • Good investments may be boring but profitable • Fryelands industrial park growing in Monroe • Out of the Blue Aviation expands flight training • Paul Allen’s rare Flying Heritage Collection becomes latest aviation att ... • Warbird's history keeper