Heraldnet.com
TUESDAY, OCTOBER 7, 2008 4:40 am
LocalNorthwestNation & WorldPoliticsSpecial ReportsPhotosColumnistsMultimedia 
Blog
Eco Geek
Wal-Mart changes its ways
Blog
Scream Queen
'The Midnight Meat Train' (2008)
Your town news
Support Groups
Dr. Smoots
Columnist Elizabeth Smoots' advice and recommendations for your health.
•Latest: People with asthma need flu vaccine
Judyrae Kruse
Reader recipes and more from Food columnist Judyrae Kruse.
•Latest: The Forum: Another tip on oven-bake stew
Sharon Wootton
Sharon Wootton writes about outdoor activities.
•Latest: Call ahead, check parking situation at trail heads
 
WEEK IN REVIEW
Monday
Dog may have saved man in morning fire
Delays on Edmonds-Kingston ferry run
Snohomish County schools that aren't up to stan...
Sunday


Recycling a house: Everett home goes to make ne...
A year after plane crash, pain still fresh for ...
Bart knows his fight is tough
Saturday


Will the bailout help?
Comcast Arena -- 5 years later
County to pay $1 million in slaying
Friday


Young couple leave Everett for worldwide trip
1 in 5 Snohomish County mobile homes could be u...
Cascade High class grades the debaters
Thursday


Victims of Snohomish fire sought a fresh start
Craigslist ad linked to Brinks heist in Monroe
County financial report worsens
Wednesday


Fire too fast to save four in Snohomish
Robber may have fled by floating
Assisted suicide foes find ally in Martin Sheen
Tuesday
Congressmen Inslee, Larsen split on bailout bill
Everett man gets 26-year prison term for pimping
Gloomy picture for Snohomish County finances
 

ADVERTISEMENT

Living   Print This Article  Email This Page  Subscribe Now! facebook digg reddit del.icio.us fark stumble

Associated Press  (click to enlarge)
Scarlett Johansson
(click to enlarge)
Courtesy Sub Pop Records
 
ADVERTISEMENT

 
 
 
CONTACT THE HERALD
Melanie Munk, Features Editor
munk@heraldnet.com
 
Published: Monday, May 19, 2008

Scarlett Johansson's debut album: Yep, it's pretty bad

This Tuesday, actress Scarlett Johansson plans to release her debut album, along with new music from Islands and Mudhoney. Here's a look at each.

Scarlett Johansson, "Anywhere I Lay My Head"(ATCO Records)

After listening to Scarlett Johansson's collection of Tom Waits covers, a question keeps running through my head: Why?

Why would this talented actress want to put out an album in the first place, joining the ranks of Russell Crowe and Juliette Lewis?

And why would she choose to cover Waits -- a brilliant songwriter, but also a difficult one to nail?

The only reason I can find seems to be, why not?

Johansson teamed with David Sitek, of TV on the Radio fame, to produce the album. Sitek described the duo's sound as "Tinkerbell on cough syrup."

Intrigued? Don't be. "Anywhere I Lay My Head" is closer to elevator music for hipsters.

The main problem is Johansson. Her deep, throaty voice sounds as dull as tap water, the exact opposite of her wry on-screen persona. Sitek does her few favors, surrounding her with cold sounds that remove the gothic vibrancy of Waits' urban folk.

Now don't get me wrong. I didn't expect these remakes to be as interesting as Waits' originals. And after all, Waits has been covered fairly well by dozens of other artists, including Rod Stewart, the Eagles and Sarah McLachlan. I have no problem with someone taking a shot at his songs. Sitek and Johansson just don't do it very well.

The album includes songs from 30 years of Waits career, including "Falling Down," "I Don't Wanna Grow Up" and the title track. The duo also tosses on one original, "Song for Jo."

That track blends into its surroundings, almost passing for one of the Waits' own. It doesn't accomplish that feat because Sitek and Johansson wrote a track as good as Waits, however. No, it slips by because elsewhere, Waits' music has been taken down to their level.

Mudhoney, "The Lucky Ones" (Sub Pop Records)

I know, I know, Mudhoney are icons, among the first bands signed to Sub Pop Records, one of a select handful of acts featured in the critically acclaimed book "Our Band Could Be Your Life."

I don't care. And I don't care about the group's new album, "The Lucky Ones," or, for that matter, the re-release of "Superfuzz Bigmuff: Deluxe Edition," also out Tuesday.

Some wonder why Mudhoney didn't break big when all their Seattle compadres -- Nirvana, Soundgarden, Pearl Jam, Alice in Chains -- exploded. I'd chalk it up to singer Mark Arm. His scruffy wail lacks the memorable character of those other groups' scruffy wailers.

On the new album, Arm starts by warning us that the "past makes no sense, the future looks tense," over the jab of a piano. It's a raucous introduction to an album that unfortunately never pauses for breath.

While I've got no problem with raw fuzz, by the end of Mudhoney's latest, I felt bludgeoned to death by a guitar.

Islands, "Arm's Way" (Anti- Records)

Nick Thorburn has been giving the Grim Reaper cute little winks ever since 2003, when Unicorns put out its debut album, "Who Will Cut Our Hair When We're Gone?"

On Islands' latest release, the mostly fantastic "Arm's Way," Thorburn goes back to the graveyard with a light step.

One moment, he's singing about a home invasion that ends in a stabbing. The next, he belts out a song like "Abominable Snow," playfully mentioning he may have "spotted a Yeti, yet I didn't die."

Thorburn, who formed Islands after Unicorns broke up about 2005, drapes "Arm's Way" in his most Baroque arrangements to date. Almost every song on this feverish album -- some of which was recorded in Woodinville -- gets a symphonic swoop.

Islands, now a sextet, ends up sounding like the teenage offspring of Electric Light Orchestra and fellow Canucks Arcade Fire.

Most of these songs are exciting, particularly the sleek dance number "Creeper." Signs of bloat, however, appear by the album's end, as tracks stretch into infinity and the overblown orchestration begins to bog songs down.

Still, it's hard to imagine anyone else singing about death with so much life.


Columnist Andy Rathbun: 425-339-3455 or arathbun@heraldnet.com


1. Boeing, Machinists divided over 'survivor plan'
2. Snohomish County schools that aren't up to standard lose kids
3. Second Boeing strike looming? SPEEA gears up for negotiations -- updated
4. Richard Larsen, longtime public servant, dies at 73
5. Dog may have saved man in morning fire
6. First significant snow in North Cascades
7. Fairgoers catch toddler dropped from ride
8. Energy aid is going unclaimed despite need, PUD says
9. Turn that frown upside down
10. Will young woman from Mount Vernon become Paris Hilton's new BFF?
Enterprise Newspaper Snohomish County Business Journal
Cedarcrest's running game, defense stop King's
Shorewood beats Glacier Peak in conference opener
Fernandez named Archbishop boys soccer coach
Team Peggy comes out in force at ALS walk
King's girls poised for threepeat in Pasco
A lifetime together in Lynnwood
The battle over Cascade's student paper
Mill Creek celebrates 25th anniversary
Public hearings scheduled on school closures
The Enterprise Online Newspaper

TODAY'S TOP JOBS
 View All Top Jobs 
Top Cars
Top Homes

ADVERTISEMENT