Heraldnet.com
SUNDAY, NOVEMBER 8, 2009 4:50 am
LocalNorthwestNation & WorldPoliticsSpecial ReportsPhotosColumnistsMultimedia 
Blog
Andy Rathbun
Videos: Weezer teams up with Kenny G, plus Artic Monkeys' great single
Blog
Theresa Goffredo
What it really takes for your 5 year old to be a success in kindergarten
 
WEEK IN REVIEW
Saturday
More snow expected at mountain passes
Suspect identified in Seattle police killing
Thousands honor slain Seattle police officer Ti...
Friday


Officer Timothy Brenton. Gone, but not forgotten
Person sought in officer's killing is shot in head
Thousands to pay respects to slain Seattle poli...
Thursday


Tale of 1916 Everett Massacre retold in style o...
Reservist survived Iraq but not his return to c...
Swine flu suspected in infant’s death
Wednesday


‘Everything but marriage' law close to vi...
Library levy winning by 51% to 49%
Incumbents looking strong in Snohomish County C...
Tuesday


Delayed financial aid forcing college students ...
Slaying of officer reminds police of dangers of...
Edmonds turns over firefighting duties to Fire ...
Monday


Question isn't 'if' but 'how bad' for floods
Slain Seattle Police officer lived in Marysville
Rubatino Refuse allows recycling of food scraps...
Sunday


Signs were clear Boeing isn't tied to location
Swine flu shots draw crowds in Snohomish County
The Boeing buzz in South Carolina
 

ADVERTISEMENT

Entertainment   Print This Article  Email This Page  Subscribe Now! facebook digg reddit del.icio.us fark stumble

(click to enlarge)
Associated Press/New Line Cinema, Sidney Baldwin Sara Fitzgerald (Cameron Diaz) and her daughter Kate (Sofia Vassilieva), who has leukemia, in “My Sister's Keeper.”
 
ADVERTISEMENT

 
 
CONTACT THE HERALD
Melanie Munk, Features Editor
munk@heraldnet.com
 
Published: Friday, June 26, 2009

Tighter focus would have improved 'My Sister's Keeper'

"My Sister's Keeper," an adaptation of the novel by Jodi Picoult, has to do with emancipation, a theme that the movie itself unwittingly plays into.

Within this structurally baggy weepie, at least two perfectly good movies fight to break free, one a provocative legal thriller, the other a melodrama.

If director Nick Cassavetes had decided to make just one of those films, "My Sister's Keeper" would have provided a nifty piece of counterprogramming to the fare on most screens. He did succeed in creating an adaptation that, although departing dramatically from such key elements as the book's ending, will please fans.

Anna (Abigail Breslin) is an 11-year-old conceived by her parents (Cameron Diaz and Jason Patric) in order to harvest umbilical-cord blood, bone marrow and various organs for their daughter Kate (Sofia Vassilieva), who has leukemia.

Anna has hired an attorney (Alec Baldwin), demanding to be "medically emancipated" from her parents -- she doesn't want to donate the kidney she was bred to give up.

As long as the movie stays with that issue, it toggles smoothly between intellectual arguments and rank emotionalism. But then the focus turns to Kate's story, when she meets a fellow patient and falls in love. It's an undeniably affecting sequence, but it represents one of several tonal shifts that make the film an ever-widening shaggy dog story.

Breslin and Vassilieva acquit themselves beautifully. Diaz plays their mom with a careworn absence of vanity.

Perhaps a moment of silence is in order to recognize the fact that one of Hollywood's most delectable pop tarts is playing the mother of teenagers (meaning I must be 100 years old).

READER COMMENTS
Be the first to comment.
You must be a registered user and verify your e-mail address to post comments to blogs or articles on HeraldNet.

To register, click here. To read other terms and conditions, click hereLog out

1. Shot ends search for man sought in killing of Seattle police officer
2. Thousands honor slain Seattle police officer Timothy Brenton
3. No charge will be filed in death of Everett pedestrian
4. Rain, thunderstorms forecast for lowlands
5. Bothell steamrolls Stanwood
6. PREP FOOTBALL/SWIMMING ROUNDUP: Halfback pass for touchdown sparks Sultan win
7. More jibba-jabba
8. Obama OK's homebuyer tax credit
9. Suspect identified in Seattle police killing
10. Dana nibbles into Somers’ lead
Enterprise Newspaper Snohomish County Business Journal
Gough on track to keep job
Jazz vocalist headlines NPAC
Mountlake Terrace makes football history
Tax revenue sagging, city budgets lagging
‘Touch of Magic' show opens at Gallery North
Jackson repeats as South champs
Holiday Bazaars Calendar
Meadowdale storms back to grab title
Edmonds moves to Fire District 1
The Enterprise Online Newspaper


FREE Appetizer with any
purchase daily 2-6pm

15% Off Your
First Time Purchase

$2 OFF
at Box Office

Come and Relax
Monthly Specials

20% Off Dinner
Up to $75 Value!

Buffet Dining
Tulalip Resort

FREE Appetizer w/
purchase of 2 entrees

Great Food
24 Hours a Day

$5 OFF
Lunch or Dinner

50% off 2nd Pizza
Special Click Here!

$1 off French Dip
$4.99 Burger Basket

Family Night Free Sundae
$9.99 Prime Rib

Oil - Snohomish County
Low Prices - Fill Now!

$5 Off
Stylecut

QuadraFire Save $250
Free Smart-Stat

Free Garlic Bread/Free Soda
Click here for details!

25% off Bath & Groom
New Customers

20% off Click Here*
Buy 1 Offer Click Here*

Free Dessert!
Click here!

Pacific Northwest
Fresh Cuisine

Island Flavors with
Finest NW Ingredients

All you can Eat Buffets
Angel of the Winds

Lube, Oil & Filter
Buy 1 - Get 1 FREE

Free Garlic Bread/Free Soda
Click here for details!
Major League Pizza
TODAY'S TOP JOBS
 View All Top Jobs 
Top Cars
Top Homes

ADVERTISEMENT