Heraldnet.com
SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 14, 2009 11:24 am
LocalNorthwestNation & WorldPoliticsSpecial ReportsPhotosColumnistsMultimedia 
Herald Editorial Board

Bob Bolerjack,
Opinion Editor
bolerjack@heraldnet.com

Carol MacPherson,
Editorial Writer
cmacpherson@
heraldnet.com


Allen Funk,
Herald Publisher
funk@heraldnet.com

Kim Heltne,
Assistant to the Publisher
heltne@heraldnet.com

Send letters to the editor by e-mail to letters@heraldnet.com, by fax to 425-339-3458 or mail to The Herald - Letters, P.O. Box 930, Everett, WA 98206.

 
WEEK IN REVIEW
Friday
No serious injuries in crash involving Arlingto...
Salish Sea: Huge body of water now has common n...
Cost of dispute falls on Monroe
Thursday


Nursed to health by volunteers in Lynnwood, sea...
Everett boy left with brain damage; father face...
Monroe must fill $290,000 gap in budget
Wednesday


81 veterans' names, 81 meaningful lives honored...
USO singer's voice still charms them in Edmonds
Monroe honking case makes it to state Supreme C...
Tuesday


Fire destroys Emory's restaurant
Peggy Pritchard Olson always put Edmonds first
Camano Island burglaries spike: Is Colton back?
Monday


Tree clearing, mud slide angers Everett neighbor
Later start for school day unlikely in Marysville
Hopes for Snohomish excursion train may hinge o...
Sunday


Glacier Peak freshman overcomes jitters to win ...
Gay marriage issue can wait, say Referendum 71 ...
Cities across south Snohomish County see tax re...
Saturday


Thousands honor slain Seattle police officer Ti...
Suspect identified in Seattle police killing
Mountlake Terrace thrilled by high school's fir...
 

ADVERTISEMENT

Opinion Columnists   Print This Article  Email This Page  Subscribe Now! facebook digg reddit del.icio.us fark stumble

 
ADVERTISEMENT

 
HAVE YOUR SAY
Feel strongly about something? Share it with the community by writing a letter to the editor.
You’ll need to include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) We reserve the right to edit letters, but if you keep yours to 250 words or less, we won’t ask you to shorten it. If your letter is published, please wait 30 days before submitting another.
Send it to:
E-mail: letters@heraldnet.com
Mail: Letters section
The Herald
P.O. Box 930
Everett, WA 98206
Fax: 425-339-3458
Have a question about letters? Contact Carol MacPherson (cmacpherson@heraldnet.com or 425-339-3472).
 
Published: Wednesday, July 1, 2009

Public option backers have a bigger goal

Health care reformers have found a new defining issue, something they call the "public option." Simply -- and devastatingly -- they want Congress to establish a government-run health insurance plan to compete with the hundreds of private plans currently in the marketplace.

You can almost hear the plan's architects' chortling, "Let's give them a dose of their own medicine. They want competitive markets. Fine. We're in."

But the so-called "public option" will not be an option for long. If established, the public plan would soon be the only game in town. The government's advantages in any faux market competition are clear: Governments dictate the prices they pay providers and regulate their competitors.

Joining most Democrats in the congressional delegation in support of the measure are some 30 Washington legislators, prominently including state Sen. Karen Keiser, D-Kent, the chair of the Senate health care committee.

Although details are still under discussion, there's no question that it will be priced significantly below most private plans and quickly claim market share. In a widely cited study, the Lewin Group estimates that a public option mirroring Medicare payment levels and open to all employers would draw 119 million people from private carriers. That's a two-thirds reduction in the number of people with private coverage.

Eventually, says Lewin Group vice president John Sheils, "The private industry might just fizzle out altogether."

Over the weekend, New York Times columnist Paul Krugman, a strong advocate for single-payer, government-run health care, argued that the public plan must be part of any reform package. Favorably citing the Medicare experience, Krugman wrote that the public plan "would help keep costs down through a combination of low overhead and bargaining power." No mention of Medicare's inadequate provider reimbursements and looming deficit.

Three years ago Krugman and his colleague Robin Wells took a stronger stand in an article in the New York Review of Books.

"If U.S. politicians could be persuaded of the advantages of a public health insurance system," they wrote with a candor now in short supply, "the next step would be to convince them of the virtues, in at least some cases, of honest-to-God socialized medicine, in which government employees provide the care as well as the money."

Some critics fault the president and Congress for not pushing single-payer aggressively. Physicians for a National Health Program, for example, charges that the president is "caving in to corporate health care interests." The industry should be so lucky.

Support for the public option does not represent a strategic shift from proponents' long-term goal -- universal coverage through a single-payer, government-run plan. Rather, it's a tactical adjustment designed to advance the goal without inciting public resistance.

Less than a year ago, candidate Obama said, "If I were designing a system from scratch, I would probably go ahead with a single-payer system." He went on to explain what he saw as the obstacles, including HMO and insurance industry employment and the complex of health care institutions.

The public option finesses all that.

Jacob Hacker, a political science professor at the University of California at Berkeley, came up with the public option after analyzing the failed Clinton reform in the early 1990s.

In 2006, Hacker warned, "Alas, the left is…biting off too much" with its "Medicare for All" single-payer plan.

"There's much to be said for a single-payer system," he wrote in Slate magazine. But many Americans "remain stubbornly attached to employment-based health insurance, and proposing to abolish it entirely is likely to stir up fear as well as gratitude." That stubborn attachment shows up in polls demonstrating that most Americans are satisfied with their current coverage and oppose a government takeover.

With his plan, Hacker says, "… you can at least make the claim that there is a competitive system between the public and private sector." The apparent choice blunts the fear. Appeasing another source of opposition, the option may also preserve union-negotiated Cadillac health care plans.

But his allegedly competitive system is unsustainable. As the government plan crowds out private competitors, it ineluctably leads to single payer. That's why its backers are pushing so hard for the public option. It's their only politically viable path to government-run health care.



Richard S. Davis writes on public policy, economics and politics. His e-mail address is richardsdavis@gmail.com.

READER COMMENTS
Be the first to comment.
You must be a registered user and verify your e-mail address to post comments to blogs or articles on HeraldNet.

To register, click here. To read other terms and conditions, click hereLog out

1. Lawsuit blames county and weed inspector in man’s death
2. Cost of dispute falls on Monroe
3. Salish Sea: Huge body of water now has common name
4. Mind if I smoke?
5. Boeing says 787 fixes are done
6. Worker dies after falling 4 stories from Lynnwood building
7. FOOTBALL FORECAST: Battle of unbeatens highlights first week of state-playoff action
8. Granite Falls-area fire chief placed on paid leave
9. Everett dentist travels world to help
10. Benefit to help injured soldier, his family
Enterprise Newspaper Snohomish County Business Journal
Memorial for Peggy Pritchard Olson set
Bazaar Fever
Hawks proud of historic season
Olson always put Edmonds first
Honoring student veterans
‘Wheedle' author comes to Lynnwood bookshop
Mavs build early lead en route to easy win
Prep football games of the week (state playoffs)
Tears of laughter, tears of grief
The Enterprise Online Newspaper


50% off 2nd Pizza
Special Click Here!

Free Garlic Bread/Free Soda
Click here for details!

$2 OFF
at Box Office

Pacific Northwest
Fresh Cuisine

Lube, Oil & Filter
Buy 1 - Get 1 FREE

$1 off French Dip
$4.99 Burger Basket

$5 Off
Stylecut

FREE Appetizer w/
purchase of 2 entrees

FREE Appetizer with any
purchase daily 2-6pm

Oil - Snohomish County
Low Prices - Fill Now!

25% off Bath & Groom
New Customers

$5 OFF
Lunch or Dinner

20% Off Dinner
Up to $75 Value!

Great Food
24 Hours a Day

Come and Relax
Monthly Specials

15% Off Your
First Time Purchase

Island Flavors with
Finest NW Ingredients

Free Dessert!
Click here!

All you can Eat Buffets
Angel of the Winds

Buffet Dining
Tulalip Resort

20% off Click Here*
Buy 1 Offer Click Here*

FREE 6 lb. Pad w/
30yd Carpet Purchase

QuadraFire Save $250
Free Smart-Stat

Family Night Free Sundae
$9.99 Prime Rib
TODAY'S TOP JOBS
 View All Top Jobs 
Top Cars
Top Homes

ADVERTISEMENT