Local News

<< Previous   of   Next >>   ADVERTISEMENT   CONTACT THE HERALD Robert Frank, City Editor frank@heraldnet.com   Published: Monday, October 26, 2009 It's a tough call for Edmonds on fire service The city may take the controversial step of farming out emergency services By Oscar Halpert Herald Writer EDMONDS — The future of this city’s fire department hangs on a City Council vote. Council members say they expect a final vote by Nov. 10 that will determine whether the city continues to run its own fire department or pays Snohomish County Fire District 1 to provide fire protection and emergency medical services. They plan to discuss the issue at a 7 p.m. public hearing Tuesday at City Hall. “To me it really boils down to public safety,” Councilman Strom Peterson said. “I think we’ll have a better fire department. I think our firefighters think we’ll have a better fire department. The icing on the cake is it’s also going to save the city money every year.” The discussions come at a tumultuous time for the city. Earlier this year, Edmonds issued staff furloughs and layoffs to bridge a $5.2 million budget shortfall. Facing the prospect of additional service and staff cuts, the council considered asking voters to lift a cap this fall on how much property tax the city can collect each year. Cities may only increase they property tax they collect each year by 1 percent. They must get voter approval to collect more. However, the council shelved the $3.75 million tax levy idea in July amidst concerns that it would be wrong to ask voters to cough up more taxes during a recession and because of uncertainties over Tim Eyman’s latest tax measure, Initiative 1033, which would force cities to cut property taxes as revenue increases. Monday, the council decided to hold off on a final decision on the fire district contract in order to give city staff, residents and the council at least another week to digest financial projections by interim finance director Lorenzo Hines. “We have to slow it down a little bit and make sure we understand the numbers,” council President D.J. Wilson said Wednesday. Mayor Gary Haakenson says having the fire district take over its 105-year-old fire department would save the city nearly $1 million a year through 2012. His proposal is supported by the city’s firefighters and by Fire Chief Thomas J. Tomberg, all of whom would become employees of the fire district. Under terms of the proposed agreement, the fire district would provide the city’s fire and emergency services beginning next January at a cost of $6.2 million a year. The district would buy Edmonds’ fire equipment, but the city would retain ownership of its fire stations and the land around them. Edmonds also provides fire service for residents of Esperance, a small patch of unincorporated county land surrounded by the city. Last week, the council agreed to narrow its choices from six to two: contracting with the fire district and keeping the fire stations, or going without a fire district contract. Haakenson in September proposed selling the city’s three fire stations as a way to plug a hole in next year’s budget. However, some council members balked at the idea. Some council members said they also liked what they heard in September testimony from the city of Mountlake Terrace, which in 2005 decided to contract with District 1 for fire protection and emergency medical services. Mountlake Terrace retained ownership of its fire station and continues to collect fees charged insurance carriers whenever someone is taken by ambulance to the hospital. Edmonds also would keep ambulance fees, which Haakenson said amount to at least $700,000 a year. Fire District 1 also provides service in Brier but it keeps the ambulance fees. In an interview, Haakenson agreed with critics of the proposal that such short-term savings won’t solve the city’s long-term financial problems and that the council likely will have to take another look at placing a tax levy on the ballot, perhaps as soon as February. “We’re going to have to ask citizens to pay for services,” he said. Oscar Halpert: 425-339-3429, ohalpert@heraldnet.com. READER COMMENTS Log in or register to post new comment | Log out What's so tough? Either we save money or we don't. My evaluation is the contract as proposed doesn't offer any significant savings. One of the root causes of the City of Edmonds current financial problem, Mayor Haakenson's previous negotitations with Snohomish County Fire District 1 and Town of Woodway. Edmonds has been providing Fire/Emergency Medical Services far below actual cost of service. Last year, Edmonds contracted to provide Fire/Emergency Medical Service to both Esperance and Woodway for $295,074 and $168,772, respectively. Sno. Co. Fire District collected over $1 million tax dollars from the Esperance area. Woodway's EMS Levy collected $215,777.80. Both jurisdictions profited on the Mayor's generousity. The Cost Model (Exhibit C) for Sno. Co. Fire District Proposal expressly demostrates the cost of service is significantly higher should the City contract with them. Fire District 1 proposes to provide the same level of service charging themselves $1 Million and Town of Woodway $698,000. Both Lynnwood and Mukilteo came to the same conclusion. Sno. Co. Fire District 1 service is expensive. Don't blame the Firefighters/Medics for wanting to jump Mayor Haakenson's financially sinking ship. Edmonds - Where's the Money, Mayor? www.edmonds-wa.blogspot.com Finis Tupper | Oct 26, 2009 7:58 am | 0 replies | View all | Post reply | Request removal

1. City of Everett, neighbor sued over lost trees, mudslide 2. Three-car accident closes Highway 9 3. Kennedy’s assassination remains a puzzling memory 4. Ways to Give: How you can help in your community 5. Take a look under your seat 6. Novice real estate investors can lose their shirts 7. Kwan never golden, but sometimes transcendant 8. Lotto ticket worth $6.5 million sold in Lake Stevens 9. Canceled credit cards come as a shock for some 10. Count drags on long after the election's over 2 - Top 10 Stories Most Talked about 3 - Top 10 Stories Most Emailed

• Eat local this Thanksgiving • Mavericks moving on • Canada's Great Big Sea rolls into Edmonds • A. Murphy finishes 2nd in volleyball • Art Walk features music, demonstrations • EAT LOCAL: Getting the goods • Lynnwood HS history teacher Vic Bennet dies • Wildcats head to semis • CSO Chamber annual show slated Nov. 23 • Boeing will build, flight test and deliver 787s in South Carolina to spe ... • Snohomish County EDC promoting job growth in key industry clusters • $4 million grant to advance brain tumor research has Everett links • Providence medical center construction tops off its 12-story steel frame ... • Tulalip affordable housing project to be financed by KeyBank, Raymond Ja ... • Arlington's Lak of Ink has a growing following for Luke Kooyman's creati ... • Bank of the Northwest formed • Cascade Bank earns $1.6 million