Police: Rapture letdown led to accidental drowning
God would help him reach the other side of the 80-acre reservoir, he told his older brother. The brother was also "chosen," so Frasno pulled him into the frigid water, too.
After a chaotic hour or so at the sprawling Contra Loma Regional Park, battling with his brother and sister-in-law in and out of the frigid water, Frasno drowned.
Authorities pulled his body from the lake at 11:20 p.m. Friday, 20 minutes after a series of world-ending earthquakes was supposed to begin, according to radio evangelist's Judgment Day prediction.
The world did not end, but investigators believe the highly publicized Rapture proclamation — with more than 5,000 billboards worldwide and a caravan of believers spreading the word — helped push Frasno over the edge.
"I believe it probably had something to do with the Rapture, because this wasn't his normal behavior," said Detective Holly Sontag, who investigated the drowning for the East Bay Regional Park District police which oversees the park.
The sad tale began late last year when the devout Frasno temporarily moved from Florida to the San Francisco Bay Area. He spent weekdays with his sister in San Francisco, Sontag said, and weekends with his brother in Antioch, northeast of San Francisco. He had no work and was to return to Florida at the end of the month.
Last Friday, as Family Radio President Harold Camping continued to insist the end was near and the Rapture became a Facebook one-liner, Frasno, his 27-year-old Antioch brother and his brother's wife went to Contra Loma park, sat on some rocks and spoke about religion, family and life.
"He started talking about God profoundly, but nothing abnormal at that point," Sontag said.
Later that evening, Frasno's behavior deteriorated. As he sat in his brother's apartment, Frasno began watching UFO videos and quoting Scripture from the book of Ezekiel, Sontag said.
Frasno insisted on returning to the Antioch park. His brother and sister-in-law, who were not identified, went with him, worried for his safety. The trio walked along the trail adjacent to the reservoir, and his religious rants continued, Sontag said.
"He told his family that he now understood the Bible and that God was going to come to see him," she said.
Frasno told the couple that God was across the reservoir and that he needed to swim there. Then he dove into the dark water.
His brother and sister-in-law, the only one of the three who could swim, jumped in to rescue him.
As he screamed Scripture verses, Frasno told his brother they were both "chosen" and needed to speak to God.
"A brief struggle ensued, but they all managed to get out of the water," Sontag said. "At that point it became a tug-of-war" as Frasno's sister-in-law tried to keep him from taking her husband into the water.
The brother told his wife to run for help while he calmed Frasno, the detective said. The hysterical wife ran to a softball field and found help, as the brothers calmly continued walking along the trail toward the swimming lagoon where Frasno believed God waited.
"The brother said, 'Let's just walk there and see if God is there,' " Sontag said.
Suddenly, Frasno said, "The trail ends here," and threw both of them back into the water, according to Sontag. As the brothers struggled in deep water, the detective said, Frasno yelled: "Climb on my back, God has given me the strength to go across."
The brother managed to wriggle out of his shirt and out of Frasno's grasp, clambered back on shore and ran for help, Sontag said. He last saw Frasno quoting the Bible and flailing in the water about 15 yards from the shore.
Frasno's relatives were unavailable for comment Wednesday, but Sontag said they were despondent.
"It's a very sad situation," she said.
No alcohol was involved, she said, and investigators are waiting for drug test results. Frasno was not on any prescription medication and had no mental illness history, she said.
Frasno was a "very religious individual," but the family knew of no direct ties to Family Radio, she said.
All the evidence, particularly the timing, led investigators to tie his drowning to the Judgment Day movement.
"The family never said anything related to Rapture, but our sense is that was probably what happened," Sontag said.
A call to Family Radio headquarters went directly to voice mail with a message alerting media that questions about the May 21 Judgment Day prediction would be addressed only during its radio and television programs.
E-mails sent to a Family Radio spokesman bounced back to the sender, and Camping's home phone number was no longer in service.
- Preacher resets the Rapture clock to Oct. 21 5/23/11
- In the end, rapture believers weren't going anywhere 5/21/11
- Rapture: The world has to end on a Saturday? 5/20/11
- Inside Everett: Pre-rapture plant sale in Everett 5/20/11
- Evangelicals that predict end of the world are raking in the cash 5/18/11
Our new comment system is not supported in IE 7. Please upgrade your browser here.