The Traina family was offered $10,000 for damages to the place they've called home for 43 years, the couple told the New York Post last week. Then the home was used in an Allstate advertisement about how it takes care of its policyholders.
"We have continued to reach out to the Trainas to discuss their concerns and are committed to resolving the matter in accordance with the policy they purchased from our company," Allstate spokeswoman Laura Strykowski told the Chicago Tribune on Monday.
Much will hinge on whether the damage was caused by wind or water.
Traditional homeowners' policies, such as those written by Allstate, don't cover losses from flooding. For that, homeowners may buy coverage from the U.S. government's National Flood Insurance Program.
"It is our understanding that the Trainas chose to drop their flood insurance policy before Sandy struck," Strykowski said. "We encourage our customers to consider flood insurance to protect themselves in ways that would not be covered under a homeowner's policy."
The Trainas, who heeded evacuation warnings, told the Post that neighbors who stayed behind told them that wind gusts tore off their roof and toppled walls before the area was flooded.
Allstate's Strykowski said that the TV ad in question showed general images of Sandy's destruction, including a "partial image" of the Trainas' home.
"It does not reference them as customers or in any way imply they are satisfied with the status of their claim," she said. "We regret any concern this advertisement may have caused the Trainas and images of their home will not be included in Allstate's advertising."
Allstate has paid out almost $1.1 billion in Sandy-related claims payments.
MORE HBJ HEADLINES
Brexit vote slams world, U.S. financial markets 3:08 p.m. Yellenís Fed to play long game dealing with Brexit fallout House Speaker Ryan proposes simpler tax code Maine governorís wife gets waitressing job 3:30 p.m. Global markets in tailspin after British vote to exit EU Stocks crash as UK vote to quit EU shocks investors