Shannon Boxx and Abby Wambach also scored for the Americans, who are seeking their ninth title in 18 appearances in the event.
Iceland nearly scored first with a header from inside the penalty area in the 19th minute, but goalkeeper Jillian Loyden made the save.
Buehlers opened the scoring off a corner by Lauren Cheney corner in the 48th, and Boxx doubled the lead when she headed in Christie Rampone's cross in the 63rd.
Wambach scored her 154th career goal off an assist by Alex Morgan in the 86th, putting her four goals away from tying Mia Hamm's team record.
More Sports Headlines
Sounders deal with significant international issues Ex-Bills' RB Jackson meets, takes physical with Seahawks Morrison's pinch homer lifts Mariners to 7-5 win over Astros AquaSox fall 7-6 to Spokane in 10 innings Steady in face of Kyrgios' 'antics,' Murray wins at U.S. Open M's notebook: Quartet added from Triple-A Hasselbeck lobbying to start Colts' preseason finale Clippers center Jordan parts ways with his agents
Our new comment system is not supported in IE 7. Please upgrade your browser here.