The Eagles, in their second season of being eligible for Division I postseason, became just the seventh No. 15 seed to beat a No. 2.
FGCU (25-10) plays the winner of the game between seventh-seeded San Diego State and No. 10 Oklahoma in the third round on Sunday.
A night after America's oldest university, Harvard, pulled off a major upset over third-seeded New Mexico, one of its youngest -- FGCU's first student was admitted in 1997 -- got one that was even bigger.
The Eagles took control with a 21-2 run that gave them a 52-33 lead with 12:28 to play, though the Hoyas used a furious rally to get within 72-68 with 52 seconds left.
It was another disappointing NCAA exit for the Hoyas (25-7), who have lost to a double-digit seed in their past four appearances.
Markel Starks scored 23 points for the Hoyas.
More Sports Headlines
Snohomish mixed martial artist returns to her first love Why Seahawks teammates and even coaches support Chancellor's holdout Smith blows save in M’s 3-2 loss to Twins Seahawks, LB Wagner agree to 4-year contract extension Seahawks notebook: Tempers flare on Day 2 AquaSox outlast Volcanoes for 11-7 win Rousey knocks out Correia to defend UFC title Blaney wins Xfinity race at Iowa Speedway
Our new comment system is not supported in IE 7. Please upgrade your browser here.