None of it suggested any dramatic turnarounds. His close embrace of Israel angered some Palestinians. But things looked different when he left, and Obama appeared to have had a successful first trip abroad in his second term.
After days of talks with leaders in one of the most fractious regions of the world, Obama appeared content to let someone else do the talking Saturday at Petra. He walked down the dusty stone corridor between steep red rock, listening as his private tour guide pointed out the features of Petra, Jordan's most popular tourist attraction.
"This is pretty spectacular," he said as he looked at Al-Khazneh, or The Treasury, a facade carved into a limestone cliff and the best preserved of all the facades and carvings in Petra. It is believed to have been carved as a tomb for a king in the century before Christ.
White House officials billed the visit — the last stop on a tour that took him to Israel and the West Bank before Jordan — as recognition of the "importance of Petra to Jordan and the ancient history of the Middle East." Many of the facades in the city were carved into sheer mountain rock face by the Nabataeans, who made Petra an important junction for trade routes linking China, India and southern Arabia with Egypt, Syria, Greece and Rome.
A University of Jordan tourism professor led Obama on a tour down the narrow gorge called The Siq, delivering a steady stream of details about Petra and rarely stopping to take a breath. Obama, casual in a navy windbreaker, khaki pants and sunglasses, nodded, and took in the scenery.
He paused for a time to marvel at The Treasury, which got its name from the Bedouins because they believed — inaccurately — that the urns sculpted on top contained great treasure. Instead, a recent excavation found evidence of a grave site.
White House officials appeared buoyed by the trip — Obama's first to the region since the Arab Spring.
His most notable achievement was brokering the start of a reconciliation between Israel and Turkey. After months of prodding, Obama watched as Netanyahu apologized to Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan for a 2010 Israeli attack on a ship nearing Gaza that killed nine Turkish nationals.
The phone call, made from a trailer on an Israeli airport tarmac as Obama was about to leave Israel, started to repair relations between the Israel and a major Muslim country, both U.S. allies.
Obama also pushed for Israelis and Palestinians to work anew toward peace. He offered no U.S. blueprint, but dropped his insistence that Israel stop building housing settlements in the West Bank as a precondition to talks. Kerry was holding meetings Saturday evening with Netanyahu and Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas.
While the trip made progress, only time will tell if the White House will pursue peace talks, said Aaron David Miller, a vice president at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars and a former adviser to Democratic and Republican secretaries of state.
"The fact that he's succeeded does not suggest in any way, shape or form that he's hooked or committed and he has decided to make the Israeli-Palestinian conflict the central issue of his presidency," Miller said. "Given his other priorities, is he prepared to spend the time and energy and plow through the kind of friction that invariably will accompany any serious American initiative? The answer is no, unless he has a sense that this thing could work."
Still, Miller said Obama realized a number of outright successes, including neutralizing Republican attacks that he's not sufficiently pro-Israel. He also turned a "soap opera, rollercoaster relationship" with Netanyahu into one that could be highly productive, particularly when it comes to dealing with the nuclear threat posed by Iran, Miller said.
Palestinians were angered by Obama's decision to soften his language on Israeli settlements in the Palestinian territory. But Khaled Elgindy, a former adviser to Palestinian peace negotiators and a fellow at the Brookings Institution, said Obama cast the trip as a chance to win over the Israeli public.
"They were careful to keep expectations low because then you can't lose," he said.
Obama was likely to have been pressed on Syria, by Israel and Jordan, who are increasingly alarmed by the prospect of a failed state on their border. He's resisted military intervention, though Andrew Tabler, a senior fellow in the program on Arab politics at The Washington Institute who focuses on Syria said allies want the U.S. to lead a coalition to oust the regime.
"I think he got an earful from everyone in the region about what to do, but whether that leads to action or not we'll have to wait and see," said Tabler said. "They want leadership and they don't feel like they're getting it."
More Nation & World Headlines
Big balloons, heavy security for NYC Thanksgiving parade Farm recalls produce used in Costco salad linked to E. coli Turkey-Russia spat over downed Russian warplane escalates Hollande and Putin agree on closer anti-IS coordination Where’s death penalty in Obama’s push for criminal justice overhaul? Holiday shoppers get a head start on Thanksgiving Pope says ‘catastrophic’ if interests derail climate talks Trump denies mocking disabled reporter, demands apology
Our new comment system is not supported in IE 7. Please upgrade your browser here.