However, in most ways, the Mariners' wild and crushing 10-9 loss to the Los Angeles Angels fell on his shoulders. And he accepted every ounce of blame. Given eight runs of support and a 7-0 lead in the third inning, the Mariners' ace and former Cy Young winner couldn't make the rare run support hold up.
"I just blew the lead," he said. "It's all my fault, nobody else, just me."
In a season filled with losses that have been the equivalent of punches in the stomach, the loss to the Angels on Thursday might have been the most painful.
The Mariners finally scored runs, and plenty of them, and the guy they trust the most couldn't turn that unusual offensive performance into a victory.
"He just had a bad day," Mariners manager Eric Wedge said. "He's human. Every now and then again, you see that he is human. This is the big leagues and he just had a bad day."
And it's true. It's so odd seeing Hernandez seem hittable. But he was from almost the very beginning.
He was mediocre all night. He had little, if any, command with his fastball. It was up in the strike zone, and when it wasn't up, it was bouncing in front of the plate.
"When he is really good, he stays in his delivery, his arm slot is consistent and his release point is consistent. He was kind of all over the place with that today," Wedge said.
For once run support wasn't an issue. The Mariners scored eight runs in four innings. In their previous four games on the road trip, the Mariners scored a combined eight runs.
Seattle's offense got rolling from the very beginning. The Mariners scored three runs in the first inning as Endy Chavez led off the game with a double and Nick Franklin doubled him home moments later. Kyle Seager punctuated the inning by blasting a two-run homer to right field. It was his ninth home run of the season.
The Mariners chased Angels starter Tommy Hanson in the third inning, scoring four more runs off him with Kendrys Morales delivering a big RBI single.
After three innings, Hernandez had a 7-0 lead to work with. That should have been plenty for the Mariners' ace and former Cy Young winner. It wasn't.
He gave up what seemed like inconsequential run in the third inning, followed by another in the fourth, but still had an 8-2 lead.
His outing fell apart in the fifth inning. Peter Bourjos led off with solo homer to center. The Angels then collected six more hits and scored four more runs, highlighted by a three-run homer from Mark Trumbo that cut the lead to 8-7. Hernandez gave up a total of seven hits in the inning. It's the most hits he's ever given up in one inning in his career.
"No excuses," he said. "It's my fault."
He was done after the fifth inning.
Wedge was forced to go to his bullpen. They offered little relief.
The Angels tied the score in the sixth off of Danny Farquhar on an RBI single from Pujols.
Seattle showed a little moxie, retaking the lead in the eighth inning. Brendan Ryan drew a lead off walk and later scored on Seager's fourth hit of the night — a double to right. For the night, Seager finished 4-for-5 with a homer and two doubles.
The Mariners bullpen again gave up the lead.
Set-up man Carter Capps started the eighth inning and promptly gave up a lead-off single to Bourjos. The speedy Bourjos y stole second and then advanced to third on Henry Blanco's throwing error. He scored moments later on Erick Aybar's single to left. Mike Trout followed with a single — his fourth hit of the night — to put Aybar at third and end Capps' night.
Wedge called on Yoervis Medina to figure out a way out of the jam. Pujols hit a hard ground ball to a drawn-in infield. Nick Franklin made a heady play, firing to third to get Aybar caught in a run down and then tagged out.
With the runners moving up to second and third with one out, Wedge had Medina walk Trumbo to load the bases. The move almost paid off. Howie Kendrick hit a sharp grounder to the left side of the infield where shortstop Brendan Ryan made a diving stop and fired to home from his knees to get a force out on Trout.
It looked as though Medina might escape with the score tied, but he walked Alberto Callaspo on four pitches to force in what would be the game-winning run.
Angels closer Ernesto Frieri shut the Mariners down 1-2-3 in the ninth to save the improbable win.
More Sports Headlines
Hunting season outlook surprisingly good Pick of the Week: Seep Lakes Rookies Dewar, Skoleski have been impressive for Silvertips early in season Seahawks hoping Lynch can play versus Bengals Arrieta, Cubs silence Pirates 4-0 to win NL wild-card game AquaSox announce their 2016 schedule NFL approves more international games, some outside England Floods force LSU-South Carolina to be moved to Louisiana
Our new comment system is not supported in IE 7. Please upgrade your browser here.