Troubling 'Blackfish' exposes problems of orca captivity
That was good. The problem was, everybody saw how the trainable and lovable animals could be used to make money. And that has led to a decades-long controversy that ought to have been settled by now.
"Blackfish" should be the final word on the subject, even if it probably won't be. This relentless documentary circles around the 2010 death of Dawn Brancheau, a supremely experienced SeaWorld trainer who was killed in a performing tank by Tilikum, a 12,000-pound whale.
But that death is the starting point for a film that makes a couple of general thrusts: Killer whales should not be kept in captivity, and the sea parks that own them have done a suspiciously incomplete job of informing their trainers and the public about how they operate their businesses.
The argument is devastating, enough so that SeaWorld has issued a statement denouncing the movie.
Interviews with former SeaWorld trainers paint a sad picture of a happy-face culture that sugarcoated the containment of giant wild animals; because of the expert spin in the industry, the trainers themselves would hear only vague rumors about injuries occurring in marine parks (SeaWorld isn't the only player, but is the most prominent).
Director Gabriela Cowperthwaite looks into fatal incidents at Victoria's Sealand of the Pacific and Tenerife's Loro Parque; the Victoria incident also involved Tilikum, and brought about the sale of the unfortunate whale to SeaWorld, for whom he has been a steady performer and sperm donor.
"Blackfish" frequently visits the Puget Sound, for interviews with local experts as well as visions of healthy killer whales plowing through their fenceless natural habitat.
Cowperthwaite charts the development in our understanding of the mammals, from the scare-mongering "Jaws" ripoff "Orca" (released in 1977) to today's evidence about their highly developed brains. No mention of "Free Willy," oddly.
As if all this weren't difficult enough to watch, "Blackfish" has an unpleasant undertone of voyeurism -- I began cringing every time we went to newsreel footage, wondering how much horror we were going to see in this particular example of whale-on-human violence.
I'm not sure how you make this film without showing those things, but it's worth noting that an exploitation movie like "Orca" creates a similar kind of tawdry suspense.
Still: If "Blackfish" outrages people, fine. The case is closed, and whales and dolphins are too high on the evolutionary scale to keep captive. We learned a lot from Namu and his followers, and now we know better.
"Blackfish" (3 stars)
A relentless documentary that exposes the problems in keeping marine mammals in captivity, with an emphasis (sometimes uneasy) on the deaths of trainers who work with killer whales. The movie doesn't pull any punches, and it's hard to watch at times, but it should be a game-changer for this controversial subject.
Rated: PG-13 for violence, subject matter.
Showing: Seven Gables.
Our new comment system is not supported in IE 7. Please upgrade your browser here.