Christians are abandoning Bethlehem
Once the town was 90 percent Christian; now just a few remain
Majdi Mohammed / Associated Press
A Palestinian child dressed as Santa Claus holds a Palestinian flag while standing in front of Israeli border policemen during a demonstration against Israel's separation barrier in the West Bank village of Al-Masara, near Bethlehem, on Friday.
Orthodox Christians pray during a mass at the Church of the Nativity in Bethlehem on Friday.
For years, Palestinian Christians have been quietly abandoning the place where Jesus is said to have been born in a manger. Middle-class residents here have packed their bags for less chaotic lives in Latin America, Europe and the United States.
Tourism ground to a halt more than a decade ago, during the second Palestinian intifada, or uprising, and is now experiencing a comeback.
But Palestinians say major challenges remain: the Israeli military checkpoints and security barrier that separates Bethlehem from Jerusalem, a 10-minute drive away; the shuttered homes and shops that are symbols of a stagnant economy; and the Israeli settlements that are growing around Bethlehem on land claimed by the Palestinians for a future state.
A Christian mayor
Vera Baboun, Bethlehem's first female mayor, wants to make her city open to all, especially to Christian pilgrims -- and those Palestinians who have left. A Christian whose late husband spent three years in an Israel jail during the first intifada, Baboun wants to lure back former residents and roll out the red carpet to encourage Christian pilgrims to extend their stays.
Borrowing a tactic from American retailers, the mayor lit the Christmas tree in Manger Square two weeks earlier than usual this year, added singers and dancers to the daily festivities and kept the crafts market open for eight days instead of one.
She is expediting permits for five boutique hotels that will add 300 rooms to the existing supply of 3,700, which are filled during Christmas week but often sit empty the rest of the year. Efforts are under way to improve handicapped accessibility to the town for aging visitors and to renovate the Church of the Nativity, which UNESCO says is the oldest Christian church still in daily use.
"This is the place where the message of peace was born with Jesus Christ," Baboun said. "When they talk about reviving the message, you need to revive the city."
Churches empty out
Clergy say the outmigration eventually could reduce Bethlehem's historic churches to mere tourist attractions -- a body without a beating heart. "It's not enough to come and see the ancient stones," said Father Shomali, a parish priest. "You need the living stones."
Bethlehem was engulfed by fighting during the second intifada, including a 39-day standoff between Israeli soldiers and Palestinian militants who hid inside the Church of the Nativity. A new film titled "Bethlehem," debuting in U.S. theaters in February, recalls those tumultuous days, telling the fictional story of an Israeli intelligence agent and his young Palestinian informant.
But with the violence long over, and U.S.-brokered peace talks again under way, Baboun is ready to focus on the future.
Tourist visits are up this year, to about 1.6 million visitors, Palestinians officials say. Most visitors come by charter bus, however, and linger just long enough to peer into the grotto at the Church of the Nativity where Jesus is said to have been born. Few stop to buy a string of rosary beads, or enjoy a plate of hummus. Almost all spend the night at hotels inside Israel, which competes with Bethlehem for tourism dollars.
"We don't benefit from the buying power of these tourists," said Fayrouz Khoury, deputy director of the Chamber of Commerce.
Hard to get to
Taxis from Jerusalem often refuse to take travelers into Bethlehem, and Jewish Israelis are warned against entering the city, according to the Israeli Defense Forces. Detailed Google navigational maps end at the Israeli military checkpoints.
"We cannot improve the tourism sector under occupation," Palestinian Tourism Minister Rula Ma'aya said.
Efforts to stem Christian emigration have gone even more slowly. During the Ottoman era, a century ago, Bethlehem was 90 percent Christian. Today the city of 22,000 is more than two-thirds Muslim, thanks to an exodus of Christians, an influx of Palestinian Muslims and a higher Muslim birth rate.
Christian leaders arrange meetings with tourism and economic development officials with visiting emigres, who show up "with a lot of enthusiasm to invest and create jobs," Khoury said. "But when they see the conditions aren't so encouraging, they leave again."
Khoury estimated Bethlehem's unemployment rate at more than 23 percent -- among the highest in the West Bank.
Vivien Sansour, a writer and producer in her early 30s, returned to her shuttered family home from Los Angeles three years ago to write about Palestinian farmers. She has childhood memories of singers and drummers parading with church patriarchs and townspeople between Bethlehem and Jerusalem -- an event that ended with the building of the security barrier.
"I don't have much to offer my children here," Sansour said. "What I have is this dream of the past that my children will never know. But this is my home."
Rami Nuseir, executive director of the New York-based United Christian Communities, said Palestinian expatriates "have the skills, they have the money" to make a difference in Bethlehem. His organization works to "halt the flight of Christians from the Holy Land," according to its website, and "to encourage those who have left to return."
Some older Bethlehem Christians point to an ongoing Christian exodus from Iraq, Syria, Lebanon and Egypt as another threatening sign. But in the West Bank, "the narrative that we're leaving because the Muslim community treats us badly is a lie," said Fadi Kattan, a Paris-educated returnee. "Christians have left because they have the means. The old business families have all left."
Kattan is fixing up a house his family owns in Bethlehem's Old City and trying to launch a career in tourism. It isn't easy, he said, sipping an espresso in the lobby cafe of the Ottoman-era Jacir Palace. His great-grandmother, a member of the Jacir family, was raised here. Now it is a luxury hotel, part of the InterContinental chain.
One sign of international support for Bethlehem's rejuvenation is a new billboard in Manger Square touting a "gift from the American people to the Palestinian people" -- a U.S. Agency for International Development-funded road improvement project, part of a $100 million West Bank infrastructure package.
"We'll better connect people with jobs and better connect tourists and pilgrims to this holy place," Secretary of State John Kerry said during a visit here last month. "This is a road not just worth building here, but it's a road worth traveling on, all of us."
Our new comment system is not supported in IE 7. Please upgrade your browser here.