The closing hour was a series of blunders at PGA National, particularly by Rory McIlroy, who lost a two-shot lead by closing with a 74.
Henley was in position to win in regulation until he chunked a wedge and had to scramble for par on the par-5 18th. In the playoff, he was only player to reach the green in two and two-putted for birdie and the win.
Russell Knox, Ryan Palmer and McIlroy all made par in the playoff.
Henley, who closed with a 72, won for the second time and qualified for the Masters.
Tiger Woods withdrew after 13 holes, citing a lower back injury.
More Sports Headlines
Mallonee is first member of Junior Silvertips AAA program to reach WHL Warriors coach Steve Kerr to take leave of absence 3:20 p.m. Former Storm coach resigns as coach of WNBA’s Sun 1:15 p.m. NCAA women’s basketball tournament returns to Saturday start 1:08 p.m. Plenty of crab remaining as late season opens Mariners shut down Hernandez for rest of season Bullpen blows lead as Astros rally to beat Mariners 7-6 Cardinals rout Pirates, clinch 3rd straight NL Central title
Our new comment system is not supported in IE 7. Please upgrade your browser here.