The closing hour was a series of blunders at PGA National, particularly by Rory McIlroy, who lost a two-shot lead by closing with a 74.
Henley was in position to win in regulation until he chunked a wedge and had to scramble for par on the par-5 18th. In the playoff, he was only player to reach the green in two and two-putted for birdie and the win.
Russell Knox, Ryan Palmer and McIlroy all made par in the playoff.
Henley, who closed with a 72, won for the second time and qualified for the Masters.
Tiger Woods withdrew after 13 holes, citing a lower back injury.
More Sports Headlines
Silvertips fall to Medicine Hat 2-1 Seahawks' Thomas overcoming struggles with ADHD Plenty on the line for Cougars against Colorado Needing two wins for bowl eligibility, Huskies visit hapless Beavers Martins repeats as Sounders’ MVP M's acquire infielder Sardinas, DFA Hultzen Cardinals' Palmer fined $11,576 by NFL for pelvic thrust Scott, Havlicek among college hoops Hall of Fame inductees
Our new comment system is not supported in IE 7. Please upgrade your browser here.