Boeing: NW's fickle partner
The $8.7 billion tax package, the largest state tax break in U.S. history, was designed to secure production of the 777X and fabrication of its carbon-fiber wing. It was informed by mistakes made in 2003, when sweeteners to land the 787 Dreamliner avoided any mention of a second, out-of-state assembly line.
Enter Charleston, S.C.
This time, Olympia's proactive thank-you was minus a no-net-job loss provision.
The zeroing out of 1,000 Puget Sound-area engineering jobs throws that omission into relief.
“We as a state did not agree to $8.7 billion worth of tax breaks for these companies so that they could create minimum-wage manufacturing jobs, and move good-paying engineering jobs out of the state,” IAM District 751 Legislative Director Larry Brown told The Herald.
Northwesterners lampoon South Carolina as a Boeing toady, but lawmakers in Columbia were farsighted enough to incorporate job-specific numbers in exchange for public money. Section 2 (ii) of South Carolina's 2009 incentive package reads, “the taxpayer creates at least three thousand eight hundred full-time new jobs at the single manufacturing facility during that seven-year period.” There is no comparable job-number provision in Washington 2013 package.
Tax policy is a barometer of political influence. Those with the sharpest elbows and the most loot snare exemptions. If a state budget gives expression to public values — including support for K-12 education and health care — tax policy is the undertow, the force unseen.
As The Herald's Dan Catchpole and Jerry Cornfield report, the exodus of engineers, along with a sober aha that there may not be a net increase of Boeing jobs in the Pacific Northwest, is compelling a few lawmakers to revisit the package.
It's a noble, if quixotic mission, with a nanosecond half-life come next session.
Sen. Bob Hasegawa, D-Seattle, a veteran of the labor movement, pushed language to keep engineering and design jobs for the 777X based in Washington. As The Herald reports, Hasegawa was rebuffed. “We've got a very clean bill. We are going to keep it this way,” Sen. Andy Hill, R-Redmond, said at the time.
It was clean enough to blow a thousand engineering jobs through. Hasegawa was prescient.
If the bottom line drove decision-making, Washington still would have landed the 777X deal, tax package or no. An educated workforce, a sublime place to live and raise a family, an aerospace culture of integrity and performance.
Bluff calling requires backbone. In matters related to Boeing, political courage falls away.
Our new comment system is not supported in IE 7. Please upgrade your browser here.