In China's ongoing dispute with Japan over territory and the right to be respected as Asia's dominant power, history is used more as a cudgel. Japanese leaders themselves have handed Beijing the weapon, with their highly provocative visits to the Yasukuni Shrine, which honors Japan's war dead (including 14 Class-A war criminals), as well as their determined efforts to finesse Japan's wartime conduct in school textbooks.
For Chinese officials, these acts are affronts, as well as opportunities to lower Japan's standing in the international community.
So it goes, over and over: history used to stake a claim on the present.
In China, these repeated references to history are so common, and so easy to ignore, that they become most noticeable when they're suddenly absent. Think of someone who falls asleep in front of a noisy television, only to be awakened by the silence left when someone else shuts it off. That's how it feels to be in China during the annual period of paranoia that occurs around the anniversary of the June 4, 1989 Tiananmen Square massacre. Suddenly, the history is gone, and you're left wondering what exactly happened.
This year marks the 25th anniversary of the massacre, and - in perverse commemoration - the Chinese leadership has been hell-bent on rounding up anyone who might want to discuss the history of what happened, and why.
Hypocrisy is the least of the problems associated with this selective use of history. As Louisa Lim, a former China correspondent for National Public Radio, puts it in her recently published book “The People's Republic of Amnesia,” the real problem is what happens when a poorly kept secret isn't one anymore:
Memory is dangerous in a country that was built to function on national amnesia. A single act of remembrance might expose the frailty of the state's carefully constructed edifice of accepted history, scaffolded into place over a generation and kept aloft by a brittle structure of strict censorship, blatant falsehood and willful forgetting.
Lim and others point out that among young Chinese, what happened in Tiananmen isn't a memory, much less a point on a timeline. But how long can these same young, educated and Internet-savvy people be kept from a history that the rest of the world already knows, but which is denied to them?
If history is any guide, the answer to that question won't come from those who try to shape and censor it.
Adam Minter is an American writer based in Asia, where he covers politics, culture, and business.
More Commentary Headlines
Similarities of France, U.S. can strengthen both Justices’ ruling ignores election BNSF takes accident prevention, preparation seriously Elementary music programs offer range of benefits to kids Taking next steps in Iraq, Syria Decision followed a lot of work, protests Democrat, Republican offer a campaign finance fix Align U.S. cannabis law with state laws
Our new comment system is not supported in IE 7. Please upgrade your browser here.