The pair of fortysomethings who have spent less than a decade in Washington will help shape the Republican legislative agenda alongside Speaker John Boehner, R-Ohio, and steer the often rancorous GOP caucus through an intense period of legislative work on several spending matters leading up to November's midterm elections.
McCarthy, 49, and Scalise, 48, were chosen Thursday in an unusual snap election caused by the primary defeat of outgoing Majority Leader Eric Cantor, R-Va.
McCarthy is serving his fourth term in Congress and his win makes him the fastest-rising majority leader in American history. A genial Californian, he is a strong fundraiser credited for his tireless work ethic, and has been cast as the candidate of the party's establishment.
Scalise currently leads the Republican Study Committee, a caucus of conservative Republicans, and has been in office since 2008. A lifelong Louisianan, he has sparred frequently in recent years with Boehner, Cantor and McCarthy over spending matters.
Rep. Steve Scalise, R-La., said he won a three-way race for majority whip because his coalition was united, and says his election is “a win for America.”
McCarthy clinched the race during a closed-door election over his lone competitor, Rep. Raul Labrador, R-Idaho, who found it difficult to get votes beyond a small group of conservatives who helped him mount a failed coup against Boehner last year.
Scalise defeated two opponents — the current chief deputy whip, Rep. Peter Roskam, R-Ill., and Indiana conservative Rep. Marlin Stutzman — and prevailed on the first ballot, a bold demonstration of how he quickly consolidated support in the past nine days.
He successfully rallied members of the RSC, most of whom are southern conservative Republicans whose numbers have swelled in recent tea party-fueled congressional elections. In a nod to his Cajun roots, Scalise distributed “Geaux Scalise” t-shirts and stickers that reminded colleagues of his ties to the Deep South.
“We built a strong team that was representative of our entire conference,” Scalise said after the vote, adding later: “This is a win for America, because we're going to be a united team moving forward.”
But Scalise's election hardly calms the fear of many conservatives that the House leadership remains a more centrist group than the base of the party.
At 4 p.m., immediately following the leadership elections, Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, sent an email to a large group of conservative House Republicans, inviting them to meet with him on June 24 for an “off the record gathering” and “an evening of discussion and fellowship.”
Cruz, who was a player in last year's federal government shutdown, has previously worked with several House members and urged them to pressure Boehner and Cantor to push a hardline conservative agenda.
McCarthy had moved quickly to lock up his win after Cantor's loss by relying on his network of deputy whips and relationships he's cultivated with colleagues, many of whom he recruited to run for office. With his victory locked up days ago, attention had shifted to replacing him as whip. The position is the third-highest in House leadership, responsible for counting votes and ensuring passage of Republican-backed legislation.
Several rank-and-filed Republicans emerged from the vote to say they were pleased.
“I think we're going to see some new energy in the Republican leadership,” said Rep. Joe Barton, R-Texas.
But Rep. Justin Amash, R-Mich., who clashes frequently with GOP leaders and supported Labrador, expressed disappointment, saying that “the best chance for a change in leadership was today.”
Some conservatives criticized McCarthy and Scalise's success and played down Scalise's reputation as a voice for the House's right flank.
“The bad news is that the two winning candidates, McCarthy and Scalise, are business-as-usual, go-along-to-get-along Washington insiders,” said Richard Viguerie, a longtime conservative activist. “The gap between the leadership of the Republican Party and the base of the party continues to widen.”
Results of the votes were not publicly released, but in a gesture of respect, Labrador asked that the vote for McCarthy be declared unanimous. According to lawmakers in the room, colleagues yelled out their approval.
The process of electing new leaders mirrored the secrecy of a papal election and began with nominating and seconding speeches for McCarthy and Labrador, followed by the counting of ballots from the House Republicans. Scalise, Roskam and Stutzman were then nominated by their supporters. Scalise won quickly.
Cantor plans to relinquish his duties as majority leader on July 31, but will keep his House seat until the end of his term in January. McCarthy and Scalise are expected to spend the next six weeks hiring staff and preparing for the transition.
They will need to work quickly with Boehner on measures to replenish the nation's highway construction fund; to reauthorize the Export-Import Bank; to revamp the troubled Department of Veterans Affairs; and to fund the federal government during the new fiscal year that begins in October.
Boehner provided few details on the pending legislation during his weekly news conference Thursday, but he conceded that the new highway bill will not mirror the ambitious, long-term agreement he has sought in the past. And he said he doubts that the cost of the bill to shore up the VA will be within current spending limits, meaning that several fiscally conservative Republicans might oppose the legislation.
Cantor lost his primary race to little-known economist Dave Brat last week, a result that many lawmakers and political observers see as among the most stunning in U.S. political history.
McCarthy, shocked by the results and pained for his good friend Cantor, quickly recalibrated and used his deep network of supporters and some old-school vote-counting techniques to seal the deal as other contenders were still mulling whether to join the fray.
When two well-known Texas conservatives, Reps. Pete Sessions and Jeb Hensarling, took a pass on challenging McCarthy for leader, Labrador launched a campaign, casting his candidacy as a necessary conduit for right-wing frustration with McCarthy's otherwise uncontested rise in the wake of Cantor's fall.
More Nation & World Headlines
Federal deficit forecast to hit lowest level of Obama presidency Islamic State accused of using mustard gas in Syria attack White House: Obama’s ‘crazies’ reference a ‘little too flip’ Court: Second Amendment also covers those in US illegally Prosecutors review evidence in fatal crash involving Jenner Senator Murray backs Iran deal as Obama needs 5 more 4 dead in France shooting, including policeman, baby Judge orders temporary halt to Mississippi executions
Our new comment system is not supported in IE 7. Please upgrade your browser here.