Former New York Times journalist challenges paper’s series on nail salons

Few recent investigative articles have landed with the sledgehammer force of the New York Times’ two-part exposé in May about working conditions at nail salons across New York City and the state. Within hours of the first article’s publication, New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo ordered an investigation of the industry and later signed a law providing greater protections for workers.

But the stories’ conclusions – including “rampant” wage theft and exploitation of the mostly immigrant workforce – have been called into question by an unusually placed critic: a former New York Times journalist who co-owns two salons in Manhattan.

Writing in the New York Review of Books on Saturday, Richard Bernstein blasted Sarah Maslin Nir’s portrait of Dickensian conditions in the salon business, a series that some journalists have suggested could be an early contender for a Pulitzer Prize.

“This depiction of the business didn’t correspond with what we have experienced (as salon owners) over the past 12 years,” wrote Bernstein, a former Times foreign correspondent and China bureau chief for Time magazine. “But far more troubling, as we discovered when we began to look into the story’s claims and check its sources, was the flimsy and sometimes wholly inaccurate information on which those sweeping conclusions were based.”

Bernstein didn’t take issue with the contention that some workers are abused; he instead questioned how widespread it is. He challenged the Times’ conclusion that there is “rampant exploitation” of “a vast majority” of the tens of thousands of manicurists and other salon workers, and that abuse can be found, as the Times put it, in “almost any salon” in the state.

He accused the paper of drawing broad conclusions based on “a pool of mostly undocumented, untrained, or unlicensed workers … ignoring clear evidence that tens of thousands of salon workers do not fall into this category.”

Times’ editors began a vigorous defense of the series on social media Saturday. In an email exchange Sunday morning, Times executive editor Dean Baquet said, “This was a great piece of journalism and Richard is speaking for the industry. I don’t think he should be treated as a journalist taking down a story on this one.”

Times Metro editor Wendell Jamieson emailed: “The story is rock rock rock solid.”

But Times deputy Metro editor Michael Luo, who edited Nir’s articles, struck a somewhat softer tone in an interview Sunday. “Could we have done more to have acknowledged that there are good actors in the industry? Yes, theoretically we could have. But I don’t want to back away from the findings of the story that the vast majority of workers are not paid the proper wage.”

The first story in the Times series described manicurists being paid below minimum wage and sometimes no wages at all by employers who preyed on their uncertain immigration status. Nir based her findings on interviews with more than 150 workers and owners, in four languages, plus a review of help-wanted ads, state records and lawsuits filed by workers.

But Bernstein, who co-owns salons with his wife and sister-in-law, took issue with the article’s claim that Chinese-language papers in New York are “rife” with ads that offer salon positions for as little as $10 per day. Bernstein and his wife, who both speak Chinese, said they reviewed every ad for manicurists in one Chinese-language newspaper, the World Journal, for three months prior to the story’s publication. “We found not a single one fitting the description of the ads that the Times asserts the papers to be full of.”

Instead, he wrote, he found ads offering from $70 to $120 a day, plus tips and commissions and free transportation from the Chinatown section of Flushing in Queens. (Bernstein did not respond to requests for comment Sunday).

As a follow-up, Bernstein’s wife posed as a job applicant and asked salon owners about starting wages. The lowest salary she found was $70 a day, plus tips and commissions, he wrote. He concluded, “The classified ads, clearly and unambiguously, reveal the opposite of what the Times claims they do.”

Nir said Sunday that she found “illegally low wages advertised in plain sight” over the course of her 13-month investigation. “ ‘Rife’ is a subjective word. “It doesn’t have a numerical value. But I saw (such ads) all the time and I would use that word again.”

She added, “When I set out to do this story, I didn’t set out to find the most exploited and abused people. I went to the bus stop and asked people at random to tell my their story. I didn’t select for it. (Exploitation) was, and is, the landscape of this industry.”

Bernstein also took exception to the Times’ assertion that state inspections of salons is lax, citing 5,174 inspections of male and female “appearance enhancement” businesses by the New York Department of State between May 2014 and 2015. The inspections resulted in 78 fines for operating without a license, figures he said the Times did not include in its stories.

But Luo said the state’s Department of Labor is the relevant agency when it comes to wage issues and its records indicated that salon inspections have been rare.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

A firefighter stands in silence before a panel bearing the names of L. John Regelbrugge and Kris Regelbrugge during the ten-year remembrance of the Oso landslide on Friday, March 22, 2024, at the Oso Landslide Memorial in Oso, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
‘Flood of emotions’ as Oso Landslide Memorial opens on 10th anniversary

Friends, family and first responders held a moment of silence at 10:37 a.m. at the new 2-acre memorial off Highway 530.

Julie Petersen poses for a photo with images of her sister Christina Jefferds and Jefferds’ grand daughter Sanoah Violet Huestis next to a memorial for Sanoah at her home on March 20, 2024 in Arlington, Washington. Peterson wears her sister’s favorite color and one of her bangles. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
‘It just all came down’: An oral history of the Oso mudslide

Ten years later, The Daily Herald spoke with dozens of people — first responders, family, survivors — touched by the deadliest slide in U.S. history.

Victims of the Oso mudslide on March 22, 2014. (Courtesy photos)
Remembering the 43 lives lost in the Oso mudslide

The slide wiped out a neighborhood along Highway 530 in 2014. “Even though you feel like you’re alone in your grief, you’re really not.”

Director Lucia Schmit, right, and Deputy Director Dara Salmon inside the Snohomish County Department of Emergency Management on Friday, March 8, 2024, in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
How Oso slide changed local emergency response ‘on virtually every level’

“In a decade, we have just really, really advanced,” through hard-earned lessons applied to the pandemic, floods and opioids.

Ron and Gail Thompson at their home on Monday, March 4, 2024 in Oso, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
In shadow of scarred Oso hillside, mudslide’s wounds still feel fresh

Locals reflected on living with grief and finding meaning in the wake of a catastrophe “nothing like you can ever imagine” in 2014.

Lynnwood
Crash in Lynnwood blocks Highway 99 south

The crash, on Highway 99 at 176th Street SW, fully blocked southbound lanes. Traffic was diverted to 168th Street SW.

The view of Mountain Loop Mine out the window of a second floor classroom at Fairmount Elementary on Wednesday, Jan. 10, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
County: Everett mining yard violated order to halt work next to school

At least 10 reports accused OMA Construction of violating a stop-work order next to Fairmount Elementary. A judge will hear the case.

Imagine Children's Museum's incoming CEO, Elizabeth "Elee" Wood. (Photo provided by Imagine Children's Museum)
Imagine Children’s Museum in Everett will welcome new CEO in June

Nancy Johnson, who has led Imagine Children’s Museum in Everett for 25 years, will retire in June.

Kelli Littlejohn, who was 11 when her older sister Melissa Lee was murdered, speaks to a group of investigators and deputies to thank them for bringing closure to her family after over 30 years on Thursday, March 28, 2024, at Snohomish County Superior Court in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
‘She can rest in peace’: Jury convicts Bothell man in 1993 killing

Even after police arrested Alan Dean in 2020, it was unclear if he would stand trial. He was convicted Thursday in the murder of Melissa Lee, 15.

Ariel Garcia, 4, was last seen Wednesday morning in an apartment in the 4800 block of Vesper Dr. (Photo provided by Everett Police)
Search underway to find missing Everett child, 4

Ariel Garcia was last seen Wednesday morning at an apartment in the 4800 block of Vesper Drive.

The rezoned property, seen here from the Hillside Vista luxury development, is surrounded on two sides by modern neighborhoods Monday, March 25, 2024, in Lake Stevens, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Despite petition, Lake Stevens OKs rezone for new 96-home development

The change faced resistance from some residents, who worried about the effects of more density in the neighborhood.

Rep. Suzan DelBene, left, introduces Xichitl Torres Small, center, Undersecretary for Rural Development with the U.S. Department of Agriculture during a talk at Thomas Family Farms on Monday, April 3, 2023, in Snohomish, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Under new federal program, Washingtonians can file taxes for free

At a press conference Wednesday, U.S. Rep. Suzan DelBene called the Direct File program safe, easy and secure.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.