Court rejects claim over fatal goring in Olympic National Park

SEATTLE — A federal appeals court panel has rejected Port Angeles resident Susan Chadd’s lawsuit over her husband’s fatal goring by a mountain goat that had been threatening visitors for years in Olympic National Park.

However, in their ruling, two of the three 9th Circuit Court of Appeals judges suggested that Chadd should be allowed to pursue her claims.

“Because it’s not over yet, I’m not going to comment on a pending appeal,” one of Chadd’s lawyers, personal injury lawyer Stephen Bulzomi of Tacoma, told Peninsula Daily News on Tuesday.

“When the final decision in the case is made, I’ll have comment.”

Chadd sued the federal government after her husband, 63-year-old Robert Boardman, was gored in the leg Oct. 16, 2010, by the 370-pound animal nicknamed by park personnel as “Klahhane Billy.”

Boardman, a diabetes nurse and local musician, had tried to fend off the mountain goat with a walking stick while hiking with Chadd and friend Pat Willits on Switchback Trail on Klahhane Ridge in the park south of Port Angeles.

Negligence claim

Chadd argued that park officials were negligent in failing to kill or relocate the animal, which park officials knew was highly aggressive, before the fatal attack.

After the goring, the animal stood over Boardman, refusing to allow anyone to get close enough to render aid as the man bled to death from an injury to the femoral artery.

Park officials destroyed the mountain goat within hours.

U.S. District Court Judge Robert Bryan in Tacoma previously dismissed Chadd’s case, saying the federal government is immune from lawsuits when officials are exercising discretion in matters of policy.

The appeals court on Monday in Seattle agreed with Bryan in its 2-1 ruling that coincided with an unusual spate of bison attacks on tourists at Yellowstone National Park.

A Mississippi woman suffered minor injuries recently when a bison flipped her after she turned her back to pose for a self-photograph with the beast.

Judge’s decision

In the lead opinion in the Olympic National Park case, Judge Diarmuid O’Scannlain reasoned that park officials had discretion in deciding how to handle the problem goat.

But the other judge in the majority, Marsha Berzon, wrote that while she was bound by 9th Circuit precedent, she agreed with dissenting Judge Andrew Kleinfeld that “our jurisprudence in this area has gone off the rails” and needs to be reconsidered.

In his dissent, Kleinfeld said the case wasn’t a matter of discretion — just ordinary negligence.

“Letting an identified aggressive 370-pound goat threaten park visitors and rangers for years until it killed one amounted to a failure to implement the formally established park policy for managing dangerous animals,” Kleinfeld wrote.

“Written park policy provided a series of steps for dealing with animals dangerous to park visitors, from frightening the animal away to removing or killing it.”

In a late July email to state wildlife officials 10 weeks before Boardman’s death, park Chief Biologist Patti Happe noted that Klahhane Billy was not responding to attempts to stay away from humans, and Happe suggested more serious options such as relocation.

“The record does not show that the park did anything about the goat at all in the next 2½ months,” Kleinfeld said.

Boardman, Kleinfeld said, “was killed by a horned animal bigger than an NFL lineman, that had been the terror of the park for four years.”

Some legal scholars have long criticized the notion that the federal government is immune from lawsuits when officials exercise discretion, saying that virtually any action or inaction by a government official can be rationalized that way.

Another hearing

One of Chadd’s attorneys, James McCormick, said Tuesday he considered Berzon’s concurring opinion an invitation to ask the 9th Circuit to rehear the case with a larger panel of jurists — and to perhaps clarify the law.

“The intention of the law was to protect high level discretion of policy makers, not the day-to-day actions of people on the ground,” McCormick said.

“This is a case that deserves to get tried on the merits.”

Court spokesman David Madden said Chadd has 45 days from Monday’s decision to seek a rehearing.

Park spokeswoman Barb Maynes said Tuesday that park officials had not yet reviewed the ruling.

“We’re just going to be reading through it and monitoring it and awaiting the next word,” she said.

_________

Senior staff writer Paul Gottlieb of The Peninsula Daily News and Associated Press writer Gene Johnson contributed to this report.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

A firefighter stands in silence before a panel bearing the names of L. John Regelbrugge and Kris Regelbrugge during the ten-year remembrance of the Oso landslide on Friday, March 22, 2024, at the Oso Landslide Memorial in Oso, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
‘Flood of emotions’ as Oso Landslide Memorial opens on 10th anniversary

Friends, family and first responders held a moment of silence at 10:37 a.m. at the new 2-acre memorial off Highway 530.

Julie Petersen poses for a photo with images of her sister Christina Jefferds and Jefferds’ grand daughter Sanoah Violet Huestis next to a memorial for Sanoah at her home on March 20, 2024 in Arlington, Washington. Peterson wears her sister’s favorite color and one of her bangles. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
‘It just all came down’: An oral history of the Oso mudslide

Ten years later, The Daily Herald spoke with dozens of people — first responders, family, survivors — touched by the deadliest slide in U.S. history.

Victims of the Oso mudslide on March 22, 2014. (Courtesy photos)
Remembering the 43 lives lost in the Oso mudslide

The slide wiped out a neighborhood along Highway 530 in 2014. “Even though you feel like you’re alone in your grief, you’re really not.”

Director Lucia Schmit, right, and Deputy Director Dara Salmon inside the Snohomish County Department of Emergency Management on Friday, March 8, 2024, in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
How Oso slide changed local emergency response ‘on virtually every level’

“In a decade, we have just really, really advanced,” through hard-earned lessons applied to the pandemic, floods and opioids.

Ron and Gail Thompson at their home on Monday, March 4, 2024 in Oso, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
In shadow of scarred Oso hillside, mudslide’s wounds still feel fresh

Locals reflected on living with grief and finding meaning in the wake of a catastrophe “nothing like you can ever imagine” in 2014.

The view of Mountain Loop Mine out the window of a second floor classroom at Fairmount Elementary on Wednesday, Jan. 10, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
County: Everett mining yard violated order to halt work next to school

At least 10 reports accused OMA Construction of violating a stop-work order next to Fairmount Elementary. A judge will hear the case.

Imagine Children's Museum's incoming CEO, Elizabeth "Elee" Wood. (Photo provided by Imagine Children's Museum)
Imagine Children’s Museum in Everett will welcome new CEO in June

Nancy Johnson, who has led Imagine Children’s Museum in Everett for 25 years, will retire in June.

Kelli Littlejohn, who was 11 when her older sister Melissa Lee was murdered, speaks to a group of investigators and deputies to thank them for bringing closure to her family after over 30 years on Thursday, March 28, 2024, at Snohomish County Superior Court in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
‘She can rest in peace’: Jury convicts Bothell man in 1993 killing

Even after police arrested Alan Dean in 2020, it was unclear if he would stand trial. He was convicted Thursday in the murder of Melissa Lee, 15.

Ariel Garcia, 4, was last seen Wednesday morning in an apartment in the 4800 block of Vesper Dr. (Photo provided by Everett Police)
Everett police searching for missing child, 4

Ariel Garcia was last seen Wednesday at an apartment in the 4800 block of Vesper Drive. The child was missing under “suspicious circumstances.”

The rezoned property, seen here from the Hillside Vista luxury development, is surrounded on two sides by modern neighborhoods Monday, March 25, 2024, in Lake Stevens, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Despite petition, Lake Stevens OKs rezone for new 96-home development

The change faced resistance from some residents, who worried about the effects of more density in the neighborhood.

Rep. Suzan DelBene, left, introduces Xichitl Torres Small, center, Undersecretary for Rural Development with the U.S. Department of Agriculture during a talk at Thomas Family Farms on Monday, April 3, 2023, in Snohomish, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Under new federal program, Washingtonians can file taxes for free

At a press conference Wednesday, U.S. Rep. Suzan DelBene called the Direct File program safe, easy and secure.

Former Snohomish County sheriff’s deputy Jeremie Zeller appears in court for sentencing on multiple counts of misdemeanor theft Wednesday, March 27, 2024, at Snohomish County Superior Court in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Ex-sheriff’s deputy sentenced to 1 week of jail time for hardware theft

Jeremie Zeller, 47, stole merchandise from Home Depot in south Everett, where he worked overtime as a security guard.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.