Just how realistic is TNT’s ‘Proof’?

  • By Kristal Brent Zook Special to The Washington Post
  • Wednesday, July 29, 2015 4:40pm
  • Life

How realistic is your favorite paranormal TV drama? Fans didn’t seem to waste much time wondering how realistic the smoke monster of “Lost” was — or quibbling that parallel universes never really collide quite the way they did on “Fringe.”

But “Proof,” a new summer series that airs at 10 p.m. Tuesdays on TNT, practically invites that kind of analysis. The drama, which debuted last month to decent ratings, stars Jennifer Beals as a brilliant cardiothoracic surgeon recruited by a billionaire to investigate near-death experiences, while still reeling from a personal brush with mortality that brought eerie visions of her late son.

You may or may not believe in such phenomena, but there are serious researchers exploring this realm. The show’s executive producers say they looked for inspiration from the academic work of the University of Virginia’s Division of Perceptual Studies — one of only two university-affiliated labs in the country still doing parapsychology research.

“Can consciousness exist outside the body?” asks creator Rob Bragin, who executive-produced the series with Tom Jacobson. “Just being able to ask the question is a good thing.”

So how realistic does “Proof” seem to real-life near-death researchers?

Take the scenario presented in the season premiere: A child dies and has an out-of-body experience while clinically dead. Somehow, after being resuscitated, she’s able to describe the exact running shoes Beals’s character wore in the operating room and draw a picture of her father punching a vending machine in the next room — events that she should have no knowledge of.

It sounded familiar to Jim Tucker, director of U.Va.’s perceptual studies lab and an associate professor of psychiatry and neurobehavioral sciences.

“Patients who’ve died for a time have accurately reported conversations that took place outside of their hospital rooms, or even down the hall,” he said. “Some have reported seeing deceased relatives that at the time they didn’t know were deceased.”

Sam Parnia, who has done similar work at Stony Brook University School of Medicine, tried to test the phenomenon by placing specific images on the ceilings of operating rooms to see if patients resuscitated after full cardiac arrest could recall them — part of a long-term study at 15 hospitals in the United States, United Kingdom and Austria. Getting sufficient data was challenging, he acknowledged.

“Most people who die don’t come back, only about 10 percent,” he said, and those that do generally suffer memory loss. Still, about 1.5 percent of surviving patients in the study, he said, had “explicit recall” of events going on in the room that they shouldn’t have been aware of. One was a patient who was fully gone — but could remember the exact phrase his defibrillator machine uttered (“shock advised”) and the number of times he was shocked (twice).

Another episode of “Proof” showed a more distressing side of a near-death experience: A hardened criminal flat-lines and is tormented by visions of the victims he has killed. Melodramatic? Sure, but it also rang true to Tucker. As many as 20 percent of people reporting near-death experiences describe it as a distressing occurrence, he said. They talk of “hellish landscapes,” feelings of an “eternal void” and a sense of “nonexistence,” rather than the stereotypical white light and visions of loved ones.

But it’s also true that some — like the woman with the green scarf, a recurring character on “Proof” — are so profoundly changed by their brush with death that they never fully return to their worldly reality.

“Having a near-death experience opens many people to having repeated exceptional experiences, such as subsequent out-of-body and visionary experiences,” said Bruce Greyson, a professor emeritus and former director of U.Va.’s perceptual studies lab.

But the researchers give a thumbs-down to the show’s treatment of reincarnation studies.

“Seems a little unrealistic,” said Tucker, after watching an episode where a patient undergoes hypnosis and suddenly remembers a past life. Tucker and his colleagues “don’t place much stock in the idea of hypnotic regression of adults in order to remember past lives.”

The Virginia lab has extensively explored the potential of past-life memories, he said — but with an exclusive focus on very young children who, in their early years of talking, have spontaneously reported what seem to be accounts of previous lives, no hypnosis involved. (By age 7 or 8, he said, the children stop sharing such stories.)

Another reincarnation-themed episode gave more cause for quibble. In it, an 8-year-old boy sees a piano for the first time and instantly starts playing Mozart. As the plot unfolds, it turns out he shares striking similarities with a child prodigy who died of a rare heart defect 10 months before the 8-year-old was born, and the coincidences pile up — same blood types, phobias, physical traits.

Said Tucker: “I like that they mentioned that there are cases involving similar phobias and birthmarks, which is often true. The problem is that they left out the most important part, which is that the children we work with report actual memories of past lives. … I understand dramatic license. But I’d hope that people wouldn’t think that’s all there is to it with children and past-life memories.”

Overall, the researchers harbor some fondness for their TV counterparts.

“It shows that there’s a range of phenomena that we can’t currently explain,” Greyson said, approvingly.

He also appreciated how the show portrayed the protagonist’s ambivalence about getting involved in the research. Parapsychology remains a lonely field, shunned by most of mainstream science. U-Va.’s center, founded in 1967 with a $1 million grant from a wealthy donor, is reliant on private funding for its operations.

Their only other complaint about “Proof,” then, is its name and driving concept. Neither Tucker nor Greyson are convinced that definitive proof of an afterlife is possible, or even desirable.

“We do have evidence,” Tucker said, “but it’s for people to decide how compelling that evidence is.”

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Life

Brandon Hailey of Cytrus, center, plays the saxophone during a headlining show at Madam Lou’s on Friday, Dec. 29, 2023 in Seattle, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Lynnwood-based funk octet Cytrus has the juice

Resilience and brotherhood take center stage with ‘friends-first’ band.

FILE - In this April 11, 2014 file photo, Neko Case performs at the Coachella Music and Arts Festival in Indio, Calif. Fire investigators are looking for the cause of a fire on Monday, Sept. 18, 2017, that heavily damaged Case’s 225-year-old Vermont home. There were no injuries, though a barn was destroyed. It took firefighters two hours to extinguish the blaze. (Photo by Scott Roth/Invision/AP, File)
Music, theater and more: What’s happening in Snohomish County

Singer-songwriter Neko Case, an indie music icon from Tacoma, performs Sunday in Edmonds.

Dominic Arizona Bonuccelli
Tangier’s market boasts piles of fruits, veggies, and olives, countless varieties of bread, and nonperishables, like clothing and electronics.
Rick Steves on the cultural kaleidoscope of Tangier in Morocco

Walking through the city, I think to myself, “How could anyone be in southern Spain — so close — and not hop over to experience this wonderland?”

chris elliott.
Vrbo promised to cover her rental bill in Hawaii, so why won’t it?

When Cheryl Mander’s Vrbo rental in Hawaii is uninhabitable, the rental platform agrees to cover her new accommodations. But then it backs out. What happened?

The Moonlight Swing Orchestra will play classic sounds of the Big Band Era on April 21 in Everett. (submitted photo)
Music, theater and more: What’s happening in Snohomish County

Relive the Big Band Era at the Port Gardner Music Society’s final concert of the season in Everett.

2024 Honda Ridgeline TrailSport AWD (Honda)
2024 Honda Ridgeline TrailSport AWD

Honda cedes big boy pickup trucks to the likes of Ford, Dodge… Continue reading

Would you want to give something as elaborate as this a name as mundane as “bread box”? A French Provincial piece practically demands the French name panetiere.
A panetiere isn’t your modern bread box. It’s a treasure of French culture

This elaborately carved French antique may be old, but it’s still capable of keeping its leavened contents perfectly fresh.

(Judy Newton / Great Plant Picks)
Great Plant Pick: Mouse plant

What: Arisarum proboscideum, also known as mouse plant, is an herbaceous woodland… Continue reading

Bright green Japanese maple leaves are illuminated by spring sunlight. (Getty Images)
Confessions of a ‘plantophile’: I’m a bit of a junky for Japanese maples

In fact, my addiction to these glorious, all-season specimens seems to be contagious. Fortunately, there’s no known cure.

2024 Hyundai IONIQ 6 Limited (Hyundai)
2024 Hyundai IONIQ 6 Limited

The 2024 Hyundai IONIQ 6 Limited is a sporty, all-electric, all-wheel drive sedan that will quickly win your heart.

The 2024 Dodge Hornet R/T hybrid’s face has the twin red lines signifying the brand’s focus on performance. (Dodge)
2024 Hornet R/T is first electrified performance vehicle from Dodge

The all-new compact SUV travels 32 miles on pure electric power, and up to 360 miles in hybrid mode.

Don’t blow a bundle on glass supposedly made by the Henry William Stiegel

Why? Faked signatures, reused molds and imitated styles can make it unclear who actually made any given piece of glass.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.