Cast some light on investing’s dark pools

  • By Noah Feldman Bloomberg View
  • Thursday, November 19, 2015 3:06pm
  • Business

Louis Brandeis, the father of market regulation in the U.S., famously called sunlight “the best of disinfectants.” The Securities and Exchange Commission announced Wednesday that it would apply his dictum to dark pools, the electronic alternative trading systems where the size and price of orders are hidden from other market participants. The proposed SEC rules, now open for 60 days of public comment, are aimed at revealing potential conflicts of interest between the trading systems and those who use them, and clarifying some aspects of order routing in the dark pools.

The proposed rules raise an intriguing question: Do we need more regulation for markets that are used overwhelmingly by extremely sophisticated traders, and that are themselves in competition with one another? Put another way, shouldn’t the market for alternative trading systems (the market for markets, if you will) be sufficient to ensure that they operate fairly and efficiently?

The question is, of course, a variant on the more general question that we should always ask whenever regulations are proposed: Given that all regulations impose costs, are the costs worth the benefits?

Dark-pool trading is big business. By volume, it may account for about a third of equity trading in the U.S. (Bloomberg Tradebook, an alternative trading system, is owned by Bloomberg LP, the parent of Bloomberg News).

You can imagine the basic arguments for and against them, which aren’t my primary concern here: Large investors especially like to be able to hide their trading strategies, while critics worry about anything happening outside the view of the ordinary investor.

The best answer to the dark pools’ critics has been that no one is forced to trade in those venues. Participants know what they’re doing, and are well-placed to understand and measure whatever distinctive risks they run in using them.

Taken to its logical conclusion, this defense of dark pools would militate in favor of nonregulation. Sure, there’s some information asymmetry between a trader and the trading system, an asymmetry that’s probably inherent to a system that matches anonymous actors.

But sophisticated investors can compare the results across a range of roughly 45 alternative trading systems, with several different ownership structures. They should thus be able to figure out which ones are right for them.

If they think they’re being misled or manipulated, they can opt out or use the leverage of their participation to demand reform. In this sense, sophisticated traders are the very model of people who don’t need the protection of regulators: They can look out for themselves. This would suggest that the costs of new regulation may outweigh the benefits.

In practice, however, there are strong reasons to think that disclosure-based regulation is desirable for dark pools, despite the sophistication of their users. The most important has to do with what markets are capable of doing on their own.

In any market with repeat players, it becomes increasingly difficult to get away with dirty tricks. Yet we nevertheless generally require market participants to engage in basic disclosures.

That’s because the basic human tendency to promote self-interest is constantly creeping into any business transaction. We play our iterated games with one another, cooperating in a virtuous circle. Yet at certain points the temptation and incentive will become great to deviate from cooperation, defecting from the cooperative norm to take a big profit. When we think that profit will be unnoticed, the temptation is still greater.

The operators of dark pools are no exception to this rather basic human impulse. Cloaked in nondisclosure, they will try to get away with giving themselves (and their favorite customers) advantages when it’s sufficiently attractive and the odds of detection are low.

Markets do a pretty good job of enabling sophisticated actors to monitor one another. But markets alone aren’t sufficient to solve the problem of ensuring the legitimacy of markets. Markets aren’t a perpetual motion machine of self-assurance.

That’s why we need governance — and government. Even the most extreme libertarian has to acknowledge that you can’t run a market absent some basic guarantees of property rights. Those rights are guaranteed by the institutions of the state. As for anarchists, they usually don’t care much for property rights in the first place.

The reason for requiring dark pools to engage in disclosure, then, isn’t a moral worry about equal treatment of all market participants, the kind you might have in an ordinary regulated securities market. Rather, it’s pragmatic: The markets should be able to function more efficiently if the way they operate is better understood by their participants.

Otherwise, in practical terms, you’d expect the dark pools to operate in cycles of trust followed by distrust. Yes, they should in theory compete with one another to disclose more, obviating the need for mandated disclosure. In the real world, the differential power of both the dark pools and their participants makes it very difficult to overcome the collective-action problem of voluntary disclosure.

Again, that’s a key reason we have government: to provide public goods that we want as individuals but that we would otherwise have trouble coordinating ourselves to produce. The transparency of the market’s operation is a public good — and sometimes someone needs to coordinate the public to provide it.

Noah Feldman, a Bloomberg View columnist, is a professor of constitutional and international law at Harvard.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Business

Black Press Media operates Sound Publishing, the largest community news organization in Washington State with dailies and community news outlets in Alaska.
Black Press Media concludes transition of ownership

Black Press Media, which operates Sound Publishing, completed its sale Monday (March 25), following the formerly announced corporate restructuring.

Maygen Hetherington, executive director of the Historic Downtown Snohomish Association, laughs during an interview in her office on Thursday, Feb. 15, 2024, in Snohomish, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Maygen Hetherington: tireless advocate for the city of Snohomish

Historic Downtown Snohomish Association receives the Opportunity Lives Here award from Economic Alliance.

FILE - Washington Secretary of State Steve Hobbs poses in front of photos of the 15 people who previously held the office on Nov. 22, 2021, after he was sworn in at the Capitol in Olympia, Wash. Hobbs faces several challengers as he runs for election to the office he was appointed to last fall. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File)
Secretary of State Steve Hobbs: ‘I wanted to serve my country’

Hobbs, a former Lake Stevens senator, is the recipient of the Henry M. Jackson Award from Economic Alliance Snohomish County.

Mark Duffy poses for a photo in his office at the Mountain Pacific Bank headquarters on Wednesday, Feb. 14, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Mark Duffy: Building a hometown bank; giving kids an opportunity

Mountain Pacific Bank’s founder is the recipient of the Fluke Award from Economic Alliance Snohomish County.

Barb Tolbert poses for a photo at Silver Scoop Ice Cream on Thursday, Feb. 29, 2024 in Arlington, Washington. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Barb Tolbert: Former mayor piloted Arlington out of economic brink

Tolbert won the Elson S. Floyd Award, honoring a leader who has “created lasting opportunities” for the underserved.

Photo provided by 
Economic Alliance
Economic Alliance presented one of the Washington Rising Stem Awards to Katie Larios, a senior at Mountlake Terrace High School.
Mountlake Terrace High School senior wins state STEM award

Katie Larios was honored at an Economic Alliance gathering: “A champion for other young women of color in STEM.”

The Westwood Rainier is one of the seven ships in the Westwood line. The ships serve ports in the Pacific Northwest and Northeast Asia. (Photo provided by Swire Shipping)
Westwood Shipping Lines, an Everett mainstay, has new name

The four green-hulled Westwood vessels will keep their names, but the ships will display the Swire Shipping flag.

A Keyport ship docked at Lake Union in Seattle in June 2018. The ship spends most of the year in Alaska harvesting Golden King crab in the Bering Sea. During the summer it ties up for maintenance and repairs at Lake Union. (Keyport LLC)
In crabbers’ turbulent moment, Edmonds seafood processor ‘saved our season’

When a processing plant in Alaska closed, Edmonds-based business Keyport stepped up to solve a “no-win situation.”

Angela Harris, Executive Director of the Port of Edmonds, stands at the port’s marina on Wednesday, Jan. 24, 2024, in Edmonds, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Leadership, love for the Port of Edmonds got exec the job

Shoring up an aging seawall is the first order of business for Angela Harris, the first woman to lead the Edmonds port.

The Cascade Warbirds fly over Naval Station Everett. (Sue Misao / The Herald file)
Bothell High School senior awarded $2,500 to keep on flying

Cascade Warbirds scholarship helps students 16-21 continue flight training and earn a private pilot’s certificate.

Rachel Gardner, the owner of Musicology Co., a new music boutique record store on Thursday, Jan. 18, 2024 in Edmonds, Washington. Musicology Co. will open in February, selling used and new vinyl, CDs and other music-related merchandise. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
New Edmonds record shop intends to be a ‘destination for every musician’

Rachel Gardner opened Musicology Co. this month, filling a record store gap in Edmonds.

MyMyToyStore.com owner Tom Harrison at his brick and mortar storefront on Tuesday, Sept. 6, 2022 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Burst pipe permanently closes downtown Everett toy store

After a pipe flooded the store, MyMyToystore in downtown Everett closed. Owner Tom Harrison is already on to his next venture.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.