Supreme Court finds Florida’s capital punishment process unconstitutional

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court found Florida’s unique system of imposing a death sentence unconstitutional on Tuesday, saying it gives power to judges that is rightfully reserved for juries.

The decision united the court’s liberals and conservatives, who voted 8 to 1 against the system employed by a state that’s among the leaders in imposing capital punishment. Florida has nearly 400 inmates on death row.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor said Florida’s process reduces the jury’s role to an advisory one and leaves the work of finding the special circumstances that render a murderer eligible for the death penalty up to a judge.

That is the reverse of what the court in 2002 said was required, she wrote.

The Constitution means for “a jury, not a judge, to find each fact necessary to impose a sentence of death,” Sotomayor wrote. “A jury’s mere recommendation is not enough.”

Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. was the lone dissenter.

It seems likely that the ruling will have limited impact outside of Florida, because no other state has exactly the same procedure. Alabama, another state with a higher-than-average history of imposing the death penalty, allows a judge to overrule a jury’s findings about whether the convicted should be put to death.

Sotomayor acknowledged that the Supreme Court had twice upheld Florida’s death penalty process. But the court’s ruling Tuesday overturned those decisions and said they did not square with the court’s more recent rulings.

In a 2002 decision in an Arizona death penalty case, the court said the constitutional right to a “speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury” meant that a jury must find the facts necessary to sentence a defendant to death.

The Florida case was brought by Timothy Lee Hurst, who was convicted of the 1998 murder of Cynthia Lee Harrison, his co-worker at a Popeyes fast-food restaurant in Pensacola.

As in other places, Florida requires a jury in the sentencing phase of a trial to consider aggravating circumstances that would make a defendant eligible for the death penalty — in Hurst’s case, that the crime was committed during a robbery, and that it was particularly “heinous, atrocious or cruel” — along with mitigating circumstances, such as a defendant’s low IQ or childhood abuse.

But the state does not require the jury to be unanimous in recommending death. In Hurst’s case, the jury recommended death on a vote of 7 to 5, citing the two aggravating circumstances. But it is unclear whether all seven agreed on both, or, for instance, whether four agreed on one and three on the other.

The Florida jury was also told that its recommendation was not binding and that it was up to the judge to make a final decision. And the judge could consider evidence that the jury did not.

The decision to sentence Hurst to death must be based “on a jury’s verdict, not a judge’s fact-finding,” Sotomayor wrote. “Florida’s sentencing scheme, which required the judge alone to find the existence of an aggravating circumstance, is therefore unconstitutional.”

Conservative justices Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas were part of the court’s 2002 decision about Arizona’s sentencing system.

In his dissent, Alito questioned the ruling and said Florida’s system gave the jury enough of a role.

“The trial court performs what amounts, in practical terms, to a reviewing function,” wrote Alito, who has emerged as the justice least sympathetic to criminal defendants.

He said it “defies belief” that the jury would not have found the murder of Harrison heinous. He said her stabbing death probably took 15 minutes and noted that the judge wrote that “the utter terror and pain that Ms. Harrison likely experienced during the incident is unfathomable.”

The court’s decision returns Hurst’s case to lower courts. It is unclear what effect it will have on other death row inmates. Generally, the court’s rulings are prospective rather than guaranteeing new sentencing for those already convicted.

Leaders of the Florida legislature, who gathered in Tallahassee for their annual session, said they will quickly change state law to meet the high court’s specifications.

“The Supreme Court has impeccable timing,” House Speaker Steve Crisafulli said.

The case is Hurst v. Florida.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

A firefighter stands in silence before a panel bearing the names of L. John Regelbrugge and Kris Regelbrugge during the ten-year remembrance of the Oso landslide on Friday, March 22, 2024, at the Oso Landslide Memorial in Oso, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
‘Flood of emotions’ as Oso Landslide Memorial opens on 10th anniversary

Friends, family and first responders held a moment of silence at 10:37 a.m. at the new 2-acre memorial off Highway 530.

Julie Petersen poses for a photo with images of her sister Christina Jefferds and Jefferds’ grand daughter Sanoah Violet Huestis next to a memorial for Sanoah at her home on March 20, 2024 in Arlington, Washington. Peterson wears her sister’s favorite color and one of her bangles. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
‘It just all came down’: An oral history of the Oso mudslide

Ten years later, The Daily Herald spoke with dozens of people — first responders, family, survivors — touched by the deadliest slide in U.S. history.

Victims of the Oso mudslide on March 22, 2014. (Courtesy photos)
Remembering the 43 lives lost in the Oso mudslide

The slide wiped out a neighborhood along Highway 530 in 2014. “Even though you feel like you’re alone in your grief, you’re really not.”

Director Lucia Schmit, right, and Deputy Director Dara Salmon inside the Snohomish County Department of Emergency Management on Friday, March 8, 2024, in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
How Oso slide changed local emergency response ‘on virtually every level’

“In a decade, we have just really, really advanced,” through hard-earned lessons applied to the pandemic, floods and opioids.

Ron and Gail Thompson at their home on Monday, March 4, 2024 in Oso, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
In shadow of scarred Oso hillside, mudslide’s wounds still feel fresh

Locals reflected on living with grief and finding meaning in the wake of a catastrophe “nothing like you can ever imagine” in 2014.

Everett mall renderings from Brixton Capital. (Photo provided by the City of Everett)
Topgolf at the Everett Mall? Mayor’s hint still unconfirmed

After Cassie Franklin’s annual address, rumors circled about what “top” entertainment tenant could be landing at Everett Mall.

Everett
Everett man sentenced to 3 years of probation for mutilating animals

In 2022, neighbors reported Blayne Perez, 35, was shooting and torturing wildlife in north Everett.

Dorothy Crossman rides up on her bike to turn in her ballot  on Tuesday, Aug. 1, 2023 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Everett leaders plan to ask voters for property tax increase

City officials will spend weeks hammering out details of a ballot measure, as Everett faces a $12.6 million deficit.

Starbucks employee Zach Gabelein outside of the Mill Creek location where he works on Friday, Feb. 23, 2024 in Mill Creek, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Mill Creek Starbucks votes 21-1 to form union

“We obviously are kind of on the high of that win,” store bargaining delegate Zach Gabelein said.

Lynnwood police respond to a collision on highway 99 at 176 street SW. (Photo provided by Lynnwood Police)
Police: Teen in stolen car flees cops, causes crash in Lynnwood

The crash blocked traffic for over an hour at 176th Street SW. The boy, 16, was arrested on felony warrants.

The view of Mountain Loop Mine out the window of a second floor classroom at Fairmount Elementary on Wednesday, Jan. 10, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
County: Everett mining yard violated order to halt work next to school

At least 10 reports accused OMA Construction of violating a stop-work order next to Fairmount Elementary. A judge will hear the case.

Imagine Children's Museum's incoming CEO, Elizabeth "Elee" Wood. (Photo provided by Imagine Children's Museum)
Imagine Children’s Museum in Everett to welcome new CEO

Nancy Johnson, who has led Imagine Children’s Museum in Everett for 25 years, will retire in June.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.