Judge in Apple-Samsung case hits ‘pause’ on Galaxy sales

SAN JOSE, Calif. — A federal judge on Tuesday handed Apple a major legal win in its patent war with rival Samsung, blocking the Korean tech giant from selling its Galaxy 10.1 tablet in the United States.

In a ruling fueled in part by legal direction from a federal appeals court, U.S. District Judge Lucy Koh granted Apple’s request for a preliminary injunction that prevents Samsung from selling the tablet as their court battle unfolds. The Galaxy tab, which operates on Google’s Android operating system, is considered a chief competitor to Apple’s iPad.

Within hours of the judge’s decision, Samsung filed court papers late Tuesday night saying it would ask a federal appeals court to put the order on hold.

Samsung released a statement saying it was “disappointed” in Koh’s ruling and “will take necessary legal steps.” The company added that the ruling should not have “a significant impact on our business operations, as we possess a diverse range of Galaxy tab products.”

Koh had previously denied a request for an injunction to block the Galaxy tab, but the Federal U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Washington, D.C., which reviews patent cases, ordered the judge to take another look at the case and suggested an injunction in Apple’s favor may be warranted. Koh agreed in the decision she released late Tuesday.

“Although Samsung has a right to compete, it does not have a right to compete unfairly, by flooding the market with infringing products,” Koh wrote in her decision.

The judge said Apple had presented “a strong case on the merits” that the Galaxy 10.1 device infringes on Apple’s patents. Koh ordered Apple to post more than $2 million bond in the event Samsung later proves that its tablet does not infringe on Apple’s patents.

The decision comes as the two companies are preparing for a trial in late July in Apple’s broader challenge to Samsung, which alleges that the company “slavishly copied” its iPhone and iPad devices. Koh is expected to rule soon on whether to issue a preliminary injunction that would also block Samsung from continuing to sell one of its Galaxy line of smartphones.

Apple has been waging an international patent war in the courts to protect its iTurf. Just last week a federal judge in Chicago rejected a bid by apple to block Motorola from selling its smartphones based on alleged patent violations.


&Copy;2012 San Jose Mercury News (San Jose, Calif.)

Visit the San Jose Mercury News (San Jose, Calif.) at www.mercurynews.com

Distributed by MCT Information Services

More in Herald Business Journal

Best foot forward: Ferndale company to make custom shoes easy

Long specializing in insoles, Superfeet is putting 3-D machines in stores to make customized shoes.

Port of Everett CEO Les Reardanz has been called up and will be spending much of the year away from his office. He is going to Afghanistan. (Dan Bates / The Herald)
Port of Everett CEO reporting for duty — in Afghanistan

Les Reardanz has been called to active duty with the Navy for an eight-month deployment.

Alaska Airlines to announce Paine Field destinations Tuesday

The Snohomish County airport’s passenger terminal is slated to see flights this fall.

Early boarding pass: Everett’s rising passenger terminal

Here’s what to expect when two airlines begin passenger service at Paine Field later this year.

Closing of 63 Sam’s Club stores impacts small business

The retailer has historically prided itself on the services it has provided small business members.

Ford goes ‘all in’ on electric cars with $11 billion investment

That’s up from the $4.5 billion that Ford said in late 2015 it would invest through the end of the decade.

New pickups from Ram, Chevy heat up big-truck competition

Big pickup truck sales are important to automakers, which make huge profits on them.

Intel underfoot: Floor sensors rise as retail data source

The sensors can also be used in office buildings to reduce energy costs and nursing homes for falls.

Most Read