By Michelle Dunlop Herald Writer
The National Transportation Safety Board made a recommendation Friday that all Boeing Co. 787 and 747-8 aircraft equipped with General Electric GEnx-1B and GEnx-2B engines undergo continual inspection.
The recommendation comes after a Boeing 787 spewed debris prior to a test flight, sparking a fire on the ground at the Charleston airport in July. An NTSB investigation found a midshaft fan fracture and crack.
On Aug. 13, a GEnx-1B engine that was installed on a 787-8, which had not flown yet, also was found to have a similar crack on the midshaft engine fan, the NTSB said.
Earlier this week, a 747 equipped with GE engines also suffered an engine failure, reported the Wall Street Journal.
The NTSB has no regulatory power — it can only recommend action. Only the FAA can make such inspections mandatory. Foreign regulators usually follow the FAA’s lead.
All in-service and spare GEnx-1B engines already have been examined by new ultrasound inspection equipment developed by GE, the NTSB said in a letter to the FAA. All GEnx-2B engines on passenger planes have been inspected, but 47 more have yet to be inspected, the agency said.
The NTSB urged repeat inspections at a “sufficiently short interval” on both GEnx-1B and GEnx-2B engines.
“The NTSB believes that repetitive inspections are necessary to ensure that, once an initial inspection has been performed, new or sub-detection-level cracks do not propagate and cause additional failures,” the agency wrote in its letter to the FAA.
In a statement, Boeing said it is working with the FAA, GE and customers on the next steps.
“Inspections have already been completed on 24 airplanes, including all 787 and all 747-8 passenger airplanes,” the company said in a statement. “We are working with GE to inspect the remaining nine 747-8 freighters on an expedited basis and expect those remaining initial inspections to be completed over the next few days.”
Boeing has delivered 787 jets to five customers. However, two of the five airlines operate 787s with Rolls-Royce engines. The three with GE engines are Japan Airlines, Ethiopian Airlines and Air India.
All 747-8s come equipped with GE engines. Operators of the freighter include Atlas Air, Cargolux, Cathay Pacific, Korean Air, Nippon Cargo and Air Bridge Cargo. Germany’s Lufthansa has passenger version, as do private customers.
Here’s the NTSB release, and we’ve attached a PDF of the entire letter.
The National Transportation Safety Board today issued two urgent safety recommendations to the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) regarding two recent occurrences in which the fan midshaft on General Electric GEnx-1B engines fractured or exhibited crack indications; and a GEnx -2B incident that appears similar in nature. The recommendations are: (1) Issue an airworthiness directive to require, before further flight, the immediate ultrasonic inspection of the fan midshaft in all GEnx-1B and -2B engines that have not undergone inspection, and (2) Require repetitive inspections of the fan midshaft at a sufficiently short interval that would permit multiple inspections and detection of a crack before it could reach critical length and the fan midshaft fractures.
On July 28, 2012, the NTSB initiated an investigation of an engine failure that occurred on a Boeing 787 during a pre-delivery taxi test in Charleston, South Carolina. This investigation is ongoing.
“The parties to our investigation — the FAA, GE and Boeing — have taken many important steps and additional efforts are in progress to ensure that the fleet is inspected properly,” said NTSB Chairman Deborah A.P. Hersman. “We are issuing this recommendation today because of the potential for multiple engine failures on a single aircraft and the urgent need for the FAA to act immediately.”
In addition, on August 31, 2012, a GEnx-1B engine installed on a Boeing 787 that had not yet flown was found to have an indication of a similar crack on the fan midshaft. The fan midshaft was removed from the engine for further inspection and examination. As a result of the investigative work to date, the NTSB has determined that the fan midshafts on the GEnx engines fractured or cracked at the forward end of the shaft where the retaining nut is installed.
GE developed a field ultrasonic inspection method to inspect the fan midshaft in the area where the fracture and crack occurred that can be accomplished with the engine still installed on the airplane. To date, all in-service and spare GEnx-1B engines have been inspected. In addition, all GEnx-2B engines on passenger airplanes have been inspected. However, the NTSB is aware of approximately 43 GEnx-2B engines on 747-8F cargo airplanes that have not yet been inspected and is concerned that they are potentially susceptible to a fan midshaft failure.
More recently, a Boeing 747-8F cargo flight, operated by Air Bridge Cargo, equipped with General Electric GEnx-2B turbofan engines, experienced a loss of power in one of the engines during the takeoff roll in Shanghai, China. The airplane had accelerated through 50 knots when the engine’s low pressure rotor speed dropped. The pilot rejected the takeoff and returned to the ramp. Photographs of the low pressure turbine show damage similar to the GEnx-1B engine from the Charleston incident. The NTSB will continue to coordinate with our investigative counterparts in China.