Skip the dollar store duds

Dollar stores are either a place to snatch up bargains, or a money-waster.

It’s all in your perspective and your self-control. Common sense tells us not to fill a cart with stuff we don’t need. But there are deals to be had.

Who can resist a Jif Peanut Butter to Go three-pack for $1, when it’s $3.99 elsewhere? What about Scrub Buddies, a two-pack but slightly smaller knockoff of Mr. Clean’s Magic Erasers, which go for $2.49?

“Every time I come here with a budget, I always go over it,” said Anthony Allen of Lake Worth, Fla., while recently shopping at Dollar Tree in West Palm Beach, Fla.

Allen, who works for another retailer, was eyeing the scads of Christmas decorations. He plans to buy the $1 ornaments to make his own wreath, rather than pay $34 and up for a pre-decorated wreath.

Seasonal decorations and party supplies are among the most popular items in dollar stores.

Pay attention to quality, check labels and stick with national brands. What Dollar Tree calls its “million-dollar brands” include Ultra Laundry Detergent, Ajax dishwashing liquid, Renuzit air fresheners, Lady Speed Stick deodorant, VO5 shampoo, Campbell’s soup and many others.

Watch out for products with labels that mimic name brands, but aren’t, such as Enregin brand cleansers with the same colors and label style as Neutrogena’s products.

Consumers browse for items they typically buy at a regular grocery store, and save money, a study by The Hartman Group Inc. of Bellevue found. While 42 percent of shoppers go to dollar stores more than once a month, consumers are more likely to buy food and beverages elsewhere.

Hartman’s definition of dollar stores includes Dollar General and Family Dollar, which have merchandise that’s more than $1.

David Wright, Hartman’s senior manager, marketing, said those two retailers and Dollar Tree are planning to open more than 1,500 new stores in the U.S. in the next year and remodel many existing stores.

“The channel is growing because shoppers are interested in discount shopping, which now includes a growing assortment of foods and beverages, ‘the treasure hunt’ that they believe such stores provide, and because the stores can be located in diverse locations ranging from urban to suburban and rural,” Wright said.

Convenience, with stores small enough to zip through quickly and parking usually right outside the door, as well as low prices draw customers of all income levels.

About half of people with household incomes of $150,000 a year or more say they shop at dollar stores, a recent survey of 2,000 adults by Chicago-based Mintel found.

Trinkets for party favors are another favorite of dollar-store shoppers.

“I come here for treasure box toys, and party favors,” said Dayree Gonzalez, a West Palm Beach mother of two. She especially likes the coloring books and flash cards.

Liesette Heyden of Lake Worth loves the cleaning supplies, shampoo and soap, and finds the holiday decorations a lot of value packed into $1 each.

What about those name brands? Is the Crest toothpaste sold at Dollar Tree really Crest? A Procter &Gamble representative said yes, it is, and if not specified otherwise, it is made in the U.S. Anything made in a foreign country must be stamped with that information.

Candy is another big draw. Some people buy it before heading for the movies, where it costs much more.

Some items are less than a dollar. For example, the greeting cards are two for $1 and the Libby’s canned vegetables are 79 cents for a 15-ounce can.

The gift bags, similar to those that cost as much as $5 in other stores, come in a wide variety of sizes, styles and colors.

To buy or not to buy?

Which dollar store items are the best buys and which are a waste of money?

Here’s a brief list compiled by the Palm Beach Post:

$1 hits

•Betty Crocker brand silicone spatula, as much as $5 on Amazon.com and eBay

•8.4 oz. bottle of Martinelli’s Sparkling Red Grape Juice that sells for $3.47 elsewhere

•Party supplies are among the most popular items

•20 hair elastics, $2-$3 at drug stores

•80 cotton cosmetic rounds, $2-$3 at drug stores

$1 misses

•The Sunbeam batteries have terrible consumer reviews, with many people reporting they don’t last long. They are made in China. Stick with made-in-the-U.S. brands such as Energizer, Duracell and Rayovac.

•Lil’ Bear Honey Flavored Syrup, 8 oz. We hate to say it, but this made-in-the-USA product is deceptive. It’s packaged in a honey bear-shaped bottle. Here are the ingredients: corn syrup, high fructose corn syrup, honey, honey flavor, natural and artificial color. It would be easy for someone to mistakenly grab this bottle, thinking it is honey. Buy the real thing somewhere else.

•The holiday-themed solar lights are cute, but the light they provide is insignificant. If you need a solar light, get something bigger — unless you are an ant.

•The four-piece manicure set is basically a joke, with scissors that won’t cut fingernails. Don’t waste your money.

•Jumbo crayons made in Thailand. There’s a reason why Crayola has been around since 1903. These crayons don’t do the job.

More in Herald Business Journal

Amazon begins leasing a warehouse in south Everett

Amazon has started leasing a 92,000-square-foot warehouse in south Everett… Continue reading

Health-care consumers need to take the lead, so get smart

David Russian, CEO of Western Washington Medical Group, writes our third essay about fixing health care.

JCPenney partners with EvCC, WSU to assist students

Earlier this month, JCPenney partnered with the Career Service Centers at Everett… Continue reading

Re/Max Elite adds two agents in Lynnwood

Jenelle Dent and Lori DaSilva have joined Re/Max Elite as agents at… Continue reading

Register for Marysville Tulalip Business Before Hours event

The Greater Marysville Tulalip Chamber of Commerce holds its next Business Before… Continue reading

Wells Fargo donates $2,500 to Edmonds Center for the Arts

Edmonds Center for the Arts has received a grant of $2,500 from… Continue reading

More business, more competition for Everett kidney dialysis center

Nonprofit Puget Sound Kidney Centers sees large for-profit competitors enter state market.

Molina Medical holds fall carnival for families in Everett

Molina Medical is hosting a free event for families in the Everett… Continue reading

Leadership Snohomish County celebrates 20 years of service

Leadership Snohomish County is celebrating its 20th anniversary. The organization was launched… Continue reading

Most Read