There is a lot at stake in Harvard admissions lawsuit

  • By Wire Service
  • Saturday, October 20, 2018 1:30am
  • Business

The trial of the civil lawsuit against Harvard University began this week in Boston’s Federal District Court. It is not a jury trial but will be heard and decided by a judge.

What’s at stake is control of admissions policies that determine what an incoming freshman class will look like — who gets the “big envelope” acceptance and who gets a brief “regrets” letter and is rejected.

What is also at stake is whether admission practices at a private university should be treated differently from those at a public one. A parallel suit has been filed against the University of North Carolina.

Applicants to Harvard face daunting statistics, starting with the fact that fewer than one in 20 are accepted. It is without doubt the most sought-after, and most selective, university in the United States. It is also the most financially independent; the size of its endowment provides a considerable amount of insulation from the financial constraints that burden other colleges and universities. As an institution it is older than our nation, founded 140 years before the Declaration of Independence.

Essentially, the plaintiffs claim that the university uses racial quotas in its admissions policy and is discriminating against Asian-Americans who otherwise would be admitted. The university responds that it uses race as a factor in admissions — which the U.S. Supreme Court said is legal, in order to ensure diversity.

This portion of the lawsuit raises two questions. The first is what the proper role of standardized tests, such as the SATs and the ACT? And how does that matter in an institution like Harvard, for which virtually all applicants have very high scores on these tests?

Harvard apparently uses its admissions policy to select students who will excel at their studies, and while they will have to defend the specifics of that fact is that SAT or ACT scores are a better indicator of “can” rather than “will” and are an unreliable predictor of actual college performance.

Of course, the university’s admissions policy has not been consistent or foolproof in this regard, either. It has notoriously admitted some real losers, some with criminal records. And the appalling amount of Harvard’s undergraduate resources devoted to remedial work has made headlines.

The court may have to weigh in on the weights assigned each factor used in the admissions policy. The plaintiffs argue that that Harvard already uses quotas to maintain something of a rural-urban balance in the student body. That doesn’t seem like a bad thing, but it might seem so in the context of this case.

Underneath this surface simplicity lurk several complicating questions. Each of them is important and relevant, but it is not clear whether they will play a role in this lawsuit.

The first is, basically, “Who’s in charge?” Who should determine college admissions, the federal government or the college? Should the college be free to admit anyone they want, or do applicants have to pass federal muster of some sort?

The question will undoubtedly come up if the judge in the Harvard case allows a broad argument that includes “legacy” admissions. At Harvard and many other elite schools, an applicant’s relationship to the school matters. If, say, a parent is a graduate, that would be a significant factor in the acceptance decision. Also appended to this category are the offspring of particularly generous donors. Their applications would receive similar treatment.

None of these admissions decisions is inherently evil. They are simply common sense. A college or university naturally wants to reserve space for the children of alumni. Building alumni loyalty is one of the foundations of an institution’s economic health.

Another question is a logical conundrum. A university cannot set a number for admissions that is discriminatory on the basis of race. But once you have decided on admissions you have a number. So, which came first in this chicken-egg situation? The plaintiffs in this case argue that the recent incoming freshman classes at Harvard look so similar that it indicates quotas are being used. Whether the lack of significant year-to-year differences is evidence of a chicken or an egg will be up to the judge.

The central issue of the case, though, remains control, not the mechanics of sorting through 42,942 applications (for the class of 2022). Control of admissions means control of a university’s character and destiny. We need no better example of this than New York City’s “open admissions” policy, which nearly destroyed the academic credibility of its tuition-free higher education system.

There is a lot at stake in this case; more than just Harvard, it will affect the future of higher education.

James McCusker is a Bothell economist, educator and consultant.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Business

Lynnwood
New Jersey company acquires Lynnwood Land Rover dealership

Land Rover Seattle, now Land Rover Lynnwood, has been purchased by Holman, a 100-year-old company.

Szabella Psaztor is an Emerging Leader. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Szabella Pasztor: Change begins at a grassroots level

As development director at Farmer Frog, Pasztor supports social justice, equity and community empowerment.

Owner and founder of Moe's Coffee in Arlington Kaitlyn Davis poses for a photo at the Everett Herald on March 22, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Kaitlyn Davis: Bringing economic vitality to Arlington

More than just coffee, Davis has created community gathering spaces where all can feel welcome.

Simreet Dhaliwal is an Emerging Leader. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Simreet Dhaliwal: A deep-seated commitment to justice

The Snohomish County tourism and economic specialist is determined to steer change and make a meaningful impact.

Emerging Leader John Michael Graves. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
John Michael Graves: Champion for diversity and inclusion

Graves leads training sessions on Israel, Jewish history and the Holocaust and identifying antisemitic hate crimes.

Gracelynn Shibayama, the events coordinator at the Edmonds Center for the Arts, is an Emerging Leader. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Gracelynn Shibayama: Connecting people through the arts and culture

The Edmonds Center for the Arts coordinator strives to create a more connected and empathetic community.

Eric Jimenez, a supervisor at Cocoon House, is an Emerging Leader. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Eric Jimenez: Team player and advocate for youth

As an advocate for the Latino community, sharing and preserving its traditions is central to Jimenez’ identity.

Nathanael Engen, founder of Black Forest Mushrooms, an Everett gourmet mushroom growing operation is an Emerging Leader. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Nathanael Engen: Growing and sharing gourmet mushrooms

More than just providing nutritious food, the owner of Black Forest Mushrooms aims to uplift and educate the community.

Molbak's Garden + Home in Woodinville, Washington closed on Jan. 28 2024. (Photo courtesy of Molbak's)
Molbak’s, former Woodinville garden store, hopes for a comeback

Molbak’s wants to create a “hub” for retailers and community groups at its former Woodinville store. But first it must raise $2.5 million.

DJ Lockwood, a Unit Director at the Arlington Boys & Girls Club, is an Emerging Leader. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
DJ Lockwood: Helping the community care for its kids

As director of the Arlington Boys & Girls Club, Lockwood has extended the club’s programs to more locations and more kids.

Alex Tadio, the admissions director at WSU Everett, is an Emerging Leader. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Alex Tadio: A passion for education and equality

As admissions director at WSU Everett, he hopes to give more local students the chance to attend college.

Dr. Baljinder Gill and Lavleen Samra-Gill are the recipients of a new Emerging Business award. Together they run Symmetria Integrative Medical. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Emerging Business: The new category honors Symmetria Integrative Medical

Run by a husband and wife team, the chiropractic and rehabilitation clinic has locations in Arlington, Marysville and Lake Stevens.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.