Air France should have refunded cancellation under European law

Question: In late December, my Air France flight from Paris to Strasbourg was delayed because of an electrical problem.

We returned to the terminal 2 1/2 hours later only to find ourselves stuck in a mess of weather delays and cancellations — with having to wait in a two-hour-long line multiple times — only to have each subsequent flight canceled.

After being scheduled for a flight the next day, we returned to the airport only to find our new flight delayed three more hours. We then opted to take advantage of a deal Air France was offering to travelers to cancel their tickets for a full refund.

We wound up taking a train to Strasbourg.

I sent an e-mail to Air France in late January, detailing the above events and requesting a refund for the tickets, as well as reimbursement for the one night of lodging in Strasbourg that I had to forfeit due to the mechanical failure of the plane.

I received an autoresponder, but nothing else. A month later, I emailed again — same answer.

Today I received a form-letter reply from Air France that said my flight was canceled because of weather and that it isn’t responsible for my expenses.

They didn’t even bother to read my letter. Can you help me with this refund?

David Ludt, Shrewsbury, Mass.

Answer: Air France should have refunded your ticket promptly. When a flight is canceled — no matter what the reason — the airline owes you either a full refund or a new flight of its choosing.

Unfortunately, the airline isn’t required to refund you for any expenses incurred because of the delay, including the lost night in a Stasbourg hotel.

Under EU law, however, you’re owed cash compensation for your mechanical delay. The airline also should have paid for a hotel in Paris, as well as offered you meal vouchers.

Air France appears to have cleverly dodged EU law by labeling this as a weather delay, which is half true.

Your flight was originally delayed because of a mechanical problem but then canceled because of weather, by your account.

Had Air France designated the flight a mechanical delay, then it would have owed its passengers very generous compensation.

Having access to a copy of EU 261 at the time of your delay may have made a difference. Politely confronting a ticket agent with the information that your flight was delayed for mechanical reasons and that the law required it to compensate you might have given your story a happier end.

When your airline doesn’t listen to you — as it appears Air France did — then you can also appeal your case to a manager. I list several on my wiki (onyoursi.de/wiki/travel/airline/air-france/).

I contacted the airline on your behalf. Air France apologized and refunded your ticket.

Christopher Elliott is the ombudsman for National Geographic Traveler magazine. He’s

also the author of “Scammed: How to Save Your Money and Find Better Service in a World of Schemes, Swindles, and Shady Deals.” You can read more travel tips on his blog, www.elliott.org or email him at celliott@ngs.org.

&Copy; 2012 Christopher Elliott/Tribune Media Services, Inc.

More in Life

New documentary chronicles Obama’s last year in White House

“The Final Year” doesn’t paint the administration in rosy colors, but it isn’t too critical either.

‘Forever My Girl’ takes a page from the Nicholas Sparks genre

The film based on a novel by Heidi McLaughlin is a well-worn tale of lost love and redemption.

Curries continues home-cooked Indian cuisine at new location

The restaurant, now located on Evergreen Way, also puts an Indian spin on Northwest cooking.

International guitar tour led by Lulo Reinhardt stops in Edmonds

International Guitar Night, now in its 18th year, is Jan. 24 at the Edmonds Center for the Arts.

New Cascadia Art Museum exhibit showcases mid-century designs

The exhibition includes ceramics, furniture, clothing, sculpture and jewelry from 1948 to 1966.

This beefy ex-cop has a delicate hobby: intricate paper-cut art

You can see Tom Sacco’s creations at the upcoming Everett Art Walk.

Slow-roasted vegetables make sumptuous sauce for pasta

Make the basic but good spaghetti with red sauce blissfully better with this recipe.

Mocking meatloaf: One man’s loaf is another man’s poison

Some don’t like it and some do. Here are six meatloaf recipes to try.

Roasted Brussels sprouts can be the apple of picky eater’s eye

Toasted sesame seeds and diced apple add flavors that compliment the sprouts’ earthiness.

Most Read