Be fair, objective when reviewing a service provider online

  • By Angie Hicks
  • Tuesday, June 17, 2014 2:33pm
  • Life

Online sites that allow consumers to describe or rate their experiences with contractors and other service providers are a fact of modern life.

But there are those who try to prevent consumers from putting reviews on sites like Angie’s List. You can imagine that, as founder, I bristle when I hear about members and other consumers being asked to sign a contract that includes what’s legally known as a “non-disparagement clause.” I would call it a gag order, pure and simple.

I believe service providers should never ask customers to surrender the right to free speech. This became an issue for me a few years ago, when my team learned that a few doctors were asking patients to waive the right to post online reviews about their experiences with the physician.

Negative reviews are a legitimate concern for companies. But a reputable contractor shouldn’t fear hearing the truth about what customers’ experience. On the other hand, I don’t think customers should consider a company’s periodic negative review to be a deal-breaker. Nobody’s perfect, and what matters most, in my opinion, is how a company responds to customer feedback.

It’s also important that consumers play fair when posting reviews or comments. Here are my cardinal rules:

  • Keep it honest.
  • Keep it objective.
  • Keep it polite.

If you’re describing a negative experience, provide constructive criticism when possible. Don’t negatively label someone. It’s one thing to say that someone showed up late and did sloppy work. It’s quite another to call him a crook.

Keep in mind that review sites are not equal. Many allow anonymous reviews; ours does not. In addition, we allow service providers to respond to reviews.

I take seriously the right of consumers to freely communicate about their service experiences. If my team learns that a company is requesting speech restrictions, we contact them. If the behavior continues, we won’t allow the company to remain available to searches of our site.

Online reviews can play a part in improving the overall experience that consumers have with their local service providers. Positive reviews tell a business what’s working. Negative ones give them a chance to make things better.

Angie Hicks is the founder of Angie’s List, a resource for local consumer reviews at www.angieslist.com.

More in Life

Expo in Stanwood can help you get ready for the country

The Country Living Expo and Cattlemen’s Winterschool is set for Jan. 27 at the high school.

Curries continues home-cooked Indian cuisine at new location

The restaurant, now located on Evergreen Way, also puts an Indian spin on Northwest cooking.

Want to buy a house this year? Here’s how to start saving up

Here are five ways to help you put 10 percent of your income per year toward buying a house.

Long rocking bench with strange fence is for protecting baby

The settee is a furniture form that dates to the 1810s. It’s a lengthened Windsor or Hitchcock chair.

Beer of the Week: Scuttlebutt’s Night Circus

The Everett brewery’s head brewer had nightmares trying to dial in its new coffee and coconut ale.

A visit to the nursery helps put you in the mood to garden

Not ready to get back into gardening? January is still a fun time to poke around a garden center.

Plant of Merit: Hybrid oriental hellebores, Lenten rose

What: Oriental hybrid hellebores, with the common name Lenten rose, are a… Continue reading

Home and Garden calendar for Snohomish County and beyond

“The Promise of Spring”: Plant sale and workshops by Northwest Perennial Alliance,… Continue reading

‘Portlandia’ ending after eight seasons of lampooning hipsters

The sketch comedy series launched its final season this week.

Most Read