Monroe city officials to review future of red-light cameras

MONROE — City officials expect to go behind closed doors Tuesday to talk with their lawyers about a recent ruling that appears to clear a path for another advisory vote on red-light cameras.

Snohomish County Superior Court Judge George Bowden last week wrote a letter holding that Monroe officials erred last year when they rejected outright an initiative that would have forced a vote on the future of traffic-enforcement cameras in the city.

Bowden also found that the city’s decision to sue the initiative’s sponsors, including Mukilteo activist Tim Eyman and the Monroe-area group Seeds of Liberty, ran afoul of state prohibitions on using litigation to thwart public participation.

While Bowden found that most of Proposition 1 was legally flawed, the portion calling for annual advisory votes on cameras in Monroe was valid.

“Having secured enough valid signatures to place (that part of the initiative) on the ballot, the city’s lawsuit burdens the initiative sponsors with having to defend the right of the voters to express their opinions and weigh in on a matter that will directly affect them,” Bowden wrote.

He said the city will have to pay Seeds of Liberty’s legal expenses. A $10,000 fine also is provided for under state law.

Monroe Mayor Robert Zimmerman on Monday declined to comment until after City Council members discuss the ruling.

Council members are expected to review the ruling at Tuesday night’s meeting, Zimmerman said.

They likely will need to meet with the city attorney before taking any action or making any statements, he said.

“We are going to have some deliberation, most likely in executive session,” Zimmerman said.

Monroe voters in November lined up solidly against continuing with traffic-enforcement cameras after the city’s contract with Arizona-based Redflex, Inc., expires in 2013.

The City Council asked for the advisory vote after Seeds of Liberty and Eyman submitted their initiative, which called for the cameras to be removed until approved by voters, tickets to be reduced and advisory votes held each year.

Bowden ruled that only the advisory provision of the initiative was legal.

“We’re thrilled that the court has ruled that the citizens of Monroe will be allowed to vote and the court has sent a clear message that cities should not be using unnecessary lawsuits to deprive people of the fundamental right to vote,” said Richard Stephens, a Bellevue attorney who represented Seeds of Liberty.

Eyman was jubilant Friday when he got word of the ruling. By Monday, he already was discussing with Snohomish County election officials the steps needed to get a vote on cameras before Monroe voters in April.

At the same time, Eyman said he is hopeful that Monroe officials will consider turning the city’s legal muscle toward removing enforcement cameras from the community.

“Why don’t we just save people a lot of work and just take the cameras down now?” he asked.

Eyman believes that the city’s contract with the camera company would allow Monroe legally to reduce fines to the point that “stop loss” provisions would be triggered. Under his reading of the contract, the camera company would be on the hook to keep the program from costing the city money — meaning it would have to subsidize the undertaking.

City officials, however, say it is more complicated.

The city’s agreement with Redflex names only a few reasons the city could terminate the program and avoid breach of contract. Those mostly address what would happen if new state laws or court rulings “prohibit or substantially change” the program.

In other states, traffic-enforcement camera companies have launched multi-million dollar lawsuits against cities that ended their contracts prematurely.

More in Local News

Shock from WSU suicide ripples through Snohomish County

Roughly 1 in 10 seniors, sophomores and 8th-graders said they had attempted to take their own lives.

$1,000 reward for info on who killed an eagle near Snohomish

After being shot, the raptor was treated at the Sarvey Wildlife Center but died overnight.

Woman confronts man leaving house with stolen item

“He swung at her with a crowbar, missing her.”

Police seek suspect in Wells Fargo bank robbery

He was described as white, in his 30s, heavyset, with blonde hair and a maroon sweatshirt.

Possible bobcat sighting keeps Snohomish students inside

The creature was spotted on the campus of Valley View Middle School around noon.

Stabbing in Everett follows dispute between brothers-in-law

The victim, 54, was hospitalized. The suspect, 29, had not been apprehended Thursday.

New leaders coming to county, state political parties

Hillary Moralez of Bothell takes over as chair for the Snohomish County Democratic Party.

Mom and brother turn in suspect in Stanwood robberies

The man is suspected of robbing the same gas station twice, and apologizing to the clerk afterward.

Derrick “Wiz” Crawford, 22, is a suspect in the homicide of his roommate. (Edmonds Police Department)
Roommate suspected in Edmonds killing found hiding in closet

Police had been searching for him for 10 days before locating him at a house in Everett.

Most Read