Mukilteo seeks others in fight against Paine Field flights

  • Tue Dec 18th, 2012 7:08pm
  • News

By Bill Sheets Herald Writer

Mukilteo has made official its plan to appeal a decision by the federal government to allow regular passenger flights at Paine Field — and other cities could join their fight.

The Mukilteo City Council voted 7-0 on Monday to file an appeal in federal court.

“There really wasn’t much discussion,” City Council President Richard Emery said. “I think all the council members are pretty well aware of what this could mean to Mukilteo.”

Allegiant Air in 2008 proposed offering four flights per week from Paine Field and increase to 20 over five years. Horizon Air of Seattle asked to offer 140 commuter flights per week from the airport. Altogether, this would amount to 23 flights per day, starting in 2018, at the earliest.

The Federal Aviation Administration determined Dec. 4 that this number of flights would not significantly increase noise, traffic or pollution in nearby communities.

Mukilteo and other opponents contend that even a small number of flights would open the door to many more, a scenario not addressed in the FAA study.

Supporters of flights, including the city of Everett and members of the Snohomish County business community, say flights would help the local economy and provide convenience for travelers.

Anyone who wants to appeal the FAA’s decision has until Feb. 2 to take its paperwork to court. Mukilteo won’t file its appeal right away, Mayor Joe Marine said.

He said he’s talked to mayors in south Snohomish County about adding their cities’ names to the appeal. City councils in Edmonds, Lynnwood and Mountlake Terrace have in the past approved motions opposing regular passenger service at the airport.

In Edmonds, any decision on joining the lawsuit will have to be made by the council, Mayor Dave Earling said.

He said he won’t make a recommendation to the council one way or the other.

“I think I’ll leave it in the council’s hands,” Earling said. “The city has spoken strongly before. We have a resolution in place.”

Lynnwood Mayor Don Gough and Mountlake Terrace Mayor Jerry Smith could not be reached for comment.

Marine said Mukilteo is not necessarily looking for financial help with the suit, “but we wouldn’t turn it down,” he said.

Mukilteo has set aside $150,000 for fighting commercial flights at the airport, Emery said. He said he expects this to cover legal expenses for the appeal, adding that circumstances could change.

The city has hired attorney Barbara Lichman of Irvine, Calif. As a resident of nearby Newport Beach — a well-to-do coastline city not unlike Mukilteo and Edmonds — Lichman battled nearby John Wayne Airport over noise issues for several years. She parlayed that experience into a career in aviation law.

Meanwhile, Snohomish County, owner and operator of Paine Field, must conduct its own environmental study under state guidelines. The primary remaining issue to address is the building of a small terminal.

The county plans to hire a consultant to run that study but probably won’t begin the process until January, said Peter Camp, an executive director for the county.

Once the study begins it will take about six months, he estimated. The study may proceed concurrently with any legal action, Camp said.

Bill Sheets: 425-339-3439; sheets@heraldnet.com.