Scherf’s lawyers again request judge step down

EVERETT — For a third time, lawyers for an inmate accused of killing a Monroe corrections officer are asking for a new judge.

Byron Scherf’s attorneys again are questioning whether Snohomish County Superior Court Judge Thomas Wynne can give the defendant a fair trial.

The lawyers are basing their latest argument on statements Wynne made in February, the second time he declined to step down. In his ruling last month, Wynne concluded that the defense attorneys had made false allegations against him and, in doing so, also violated ethical standards.

In asking for a new judge, the lawyers alleged that Wynne had operated under a flawed understanding of the law and had ceded his authority in the past to prosecuting attorney Mark Roe.

In that motion, they accused Wynne of entering a “wink-and-nod” agreement with Roe in the 2006 trial of convicted child killer Richard Clark.

Wynne called the defense’s allegations a “bold-faced fabrication.”

He said that if they were attempting to intimidate him, it wasn’t working. He declined to step down, saying he wouldn’t allow the defense’s ethical lapse to affect his rulings.

The latest motion by the defense argues that because Wynne “publicly passed judgement on Mr. Scherf’s attorneys, labeled them unethical liars, and thereby created a situation where it is no longer possible for him to preside over the trial with the appearance of impartiality.”

The defendant is either being represented by liars, or heading into a death penalty case where the judge is mistakenly convinced his attorneys are liars, according to the motion.

Defense attorneys Jon Scott and Karen Halverson deny that they fabricated anything. They said they acted in good faith and have an ethical obligation to their client to make motions that they believe have merit, even if it offends the judge.

The latest motion was filed by Seattle attorney James Lobsenz, one of the state’s most experienced attorneys on death penalty appeals. He’s joined Scherf’s defense for the limited purpose of arguing that Wynne should step down and a new judge be assigned the case.

In 1994, Lobsenz attempted to halt the execution of convicted killer Charles Campbell. A jury had sentenced Campbell to die for the 1982 murders of a woman, her 8-year-old daughter and the woman’s neighbor in Clearview. Campbell was executed May 27, 1994.

Lobsenz has been recognized for his work by the Washington Coalition Against the Death Penalty.

Wynne is expected to take up the latest motion Friday morning.

Prosecutors asked Wynne to strike the hearing. They argue that the defense’s motion is without merit and seems to be “little more than an effort at judicial baiting.”

The defense is attempting to use the rejection of a baseless motion as grounds for the judge to recuse himself, prosecutors wrote. Additionally, the prosecutors argue that the defense didn’t simply say that they disagreed with Wynne’s ruling, they asserted that the judge had dishonest motives, the prosecutors wrote.

Scherf’s lawyers have brought cases before Wynne for more than 11 years and records show they never have sought to have him removed before, the prosecutors said.

Wynne has twice said that he will give Scherf a fair trial.

Scherf, 53, is accused of strangling corrections officer Jayme Biendl in the chapel at the Washington State Reformatory. He allegedly told detectives that he was upset over something Biendl said earlier in the night. Scherf was serving a life sentence without the chance of release for violent crimes against women.

Diana Hefley: 425-339-3463;

More in Local News

Bicycle tour raises money for dialysis patients

Volunteers also shared health information and put together care packages for homeless women.

Elderly couple escape serious injuries in crash with train

The driver drove down tracks instead of a road, hitting a slow-moving train near Stanwood.

Boeing reaches out to schools

Company employees helped Everett students at recent reading and Manufacturing Day events.

5-vehicle collision sends school bus into ditch; no injuries

No students were hurt when a school bus crashed into… Continue reading

Fire crew returns early from wildfires in Northern California

Four Everett firefighters returned from battling California wildfires late Thursday… Continue reading

Theft lands former insurance salesman 50 days in jail

A former insurance salesman is expected to report to jail… Continue reading

Pair of intrepid musicians climb N. Cascades summits to play

Rose Freeman and Anastasia Allison pack their instruments up mountains for high-altitude recitals.

Expect river levels to keep rising, though sun is on the way

Some could crest above minor and moderate flood levels.

Oregon senator punished over alleged inappropriate touching

Democratic Sen. Sara Gelser didn’t identify anyone by name.

Most Read