Scherf’s lawyers again request judge step down

EVERETT — For a third time, lawyers for an inmate accused of killing a Monroe corrections officer are asking for a new judge.

Byron Scherf’s attorneys again are questioning whether Snohomish County Superior Court Judge Thomas Wynne can give the defendant a fair trial.

The lawyers are basing their latest argument on statements Wynne made in February, the second time he declined to step down. In his ruling last month, Wynne concluded that the defense attorneys had made false allegations against him and, in doing so, also violated ethical standards.

In asking for a new judge, the lawyers alleged that Wynne had operated under a flawed understanding of the law and had ceded his authority in the past to prosecuting attorney Mark Roe.

In that motion, they accused Wynne of entering a “wink-and-nod” agreement with Roe in the 2006 trial of convicted child killer Richard Clark.

Wynne called the defense’s allegations a “bold-faced fabrication.”

He said that if they were attempting to intimidate him, it wasn’t working. He declined to step down, saying he wouldn’t allow the defense’s ethical lapse to affect his rulings.

The latest motion by the defense argues that because Wynne “publicly passed judgement on Mr. Scherf’s attorneys, labeled them unethical liars, and thereby created a situation where it is no longer possible for him to preside over the trial with the appearance of impartiality.”

The defendant is either being represented by liars, or heading into a death penalty case where the judge is mistakenly convinced his attorneys are liars, according to the motion.

Defense attorneys Jon Scott and Karen Halverson deny that they fabricated anything. They said they acted in good faith and have an ethical obligation to their client to make motions that they believe have merit, even if it offends the judge.

The latest motion was filed by Seattle attorney James Lobsenz, one of the state’s most experienced attorneys on death penalty appeals. He’s joined Scherf’s defense for the limited purpose of arguing that Wynne should step down and a new judge be assigned the case.

In 1994, Lobsenz attempted to halt the execution of convicted killer Charles Campbell. A jury had sentenced Campbell to die for the 1982 murders of a woman, her 8-year-old daughter and the woman’s neighbor in Clearview. Campbell was executed May 27, 1994.

Lobsenz has been recognized for his work by the Washington Coalition Against the Death Penalty.

Wynne is expected to take up the latest motion Friday morning.

Prosecutors asked Wynne to strike the hearing. They argue that the defense’s motion is without merit and seems to be “little more than an effort at judicial baiting.”

The defense is attempting to use the rejection of a baseless motion as grounds for the judge to recuse himself, prosecutors wrote. Additionally, the prosecutors argue that the defense didn’t simply say that they disagreed with Wynne’s ruling, they asserted that the judge had dishonest motives, the prosecutors wrote.

Scherf’s lawyers have brought cases before Wynne for more than 11 years and records show they never have sought to have him removed before, the prosecutors said.

Wynne has twice said that he will give Scherf a fair trial.

Scherf, 53, is accused of strangling corrections officer Jayme Biendl in the chapel at the Washington State Reformatory. He allegedly told detectives that he was upset over something Biendl said earlier in the night. Scherf was serving a life sentence without the chance of release for violent crimes against women.

Diana Hefley: 425-339-3463;

More in Local News

A customer walks away after buying a hot dog from a vendor on 33rd St and Smith Street near the Everett Station on Friday. The Everett Station District Alliance pictures the area east of Broadway and south of Hewitt Avenue as a future neighborhood and transit hub that could absorb expected population growth. (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
How can Everett Station become a vibrant part of city?

A neighborhood alliance focused on long-term revitalization will update the public Tuesday.

Man arrested after police find van full of drugs, cash and guns

An officer on patrol noticed a vehicle by itself in the middle of a WinCo parking lot at 2 a.m.

After work to address issues, Lynnwood gets clean audit

The city has benefited from increased revenues from sales tax.

Bolshevik replaces BS in Eyman’s voters pamphlet statement

The initiative promoter also lost a bid to include a hyperlink to online coverage of the battle.

Man with shotgun confronts man on toilet about missing phone

Police say the victim was doing his business when the suspect barged in and threatened him.

Detectives seek suspect in woman’s homicide

Alisha Michelle Canales-McGuire was shot to death Wednesday at a home south of Paine Field.

Car crashes near Everett after State Patrol pursuit

The driver and a second person in the car suffered injuries.

Smith Island habitat restoration cost to rise $1.2 million

The project is intended to increase survival rates for juvenile chinook salmon.

Jim Mathis, the Vietnam veteran whose Marysville garden was recently featured in The Herald, died Wednesday. Mathis, who suffered from PTSD and cancer, found solace in his beautiful garden. (Dan Bates / The Herald)
Vietnam veteran Jim Mathis found peace in his garden

The Marysville man who served two tours died Wednesday after suffering from cancer and PTSD.

Most Read