Background checks do make sense

I am writing to point out the flawed logic and inaccuracies in a letter from a reader on the subject of background checks for firearm purchases. Mr. Todd Welch’s letter, “Hysteria isn’t common sense,” was a rambling juxtaposition of accusations and selective statistics that never really reached a conclusion, other than accusing those who advocate for common sense background checks, as your April 18 editorial did, to engaging in “emotional hysteria.”

Assuming his vaguely referenced statistics are correct, Mr. Welch’s brand of common sense goes something like this: since “only” about 14 percent of guns used in criminal acts came from outlets such as gun shows, pawn shops, flea markets or retail outlets, why bother making their firearms transactions subject to background checks?

Chief among his flawed assertions were his observation that states with the most stringent gun laws had the most gun-related murders. There’s a slight chicken and egg problem there. His logic also completely ignores the fact that firearms can very easily cross borders from states with less restrictive regulations to states with more stringent gun laws. His insinuation also happens to be false. A recent study by Boston Children’s Hospital and Harvard School of Public Health researchers (JAMA Internal Medicine, May 13, 2013) concluded that “a higher number of firearm laws in a state are associated with a lower rate of firearm fatalities in the state, overall and for suicides and homicides individually.”

Finally, as polls consistently show, most people think having someone mildly inconvenienced by a background check prior to purchasing a gun is reasonable, just as we ask someone who owns a car to take a test before allowing them to drive a car. The only people who take issue with that are the hysterical ones.

Larry Wechsler

Edmonds

More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Friday, Nov. 24

A sketchy look at the day in politics.… Continue reading

Editorial: Save some shopping for Small Business Saturday

Patronizing businesses in your hometown promotes the local economy and supports jobs. And it’s fun.

Ignatius: An art-world tool could provide more faith in facts

‘Digital provenance’ could provide a trail of evidence that would assure greater confidence in news.

Saunders: Political world wrestles with how to handle gropers

While corporations can quickly fire their bad boys, politics has muddied the fates of its accused.

RFA isn’t providing savings promised to Lynnwood taxpayers

The headline for the front-page article of the Nov. 18 Herald read… Continue reading

GOP tax bill’s trickle-down ethic goes against God’s word

While trickle-down tax policies may be of dubious merit even on purely… Continue reading

Second Amendment didn’t anticipate today’s arms

We have been looking the issues regarding gun control and assault weapons… Continue reading

GOP tax bill won’t serve majority of Americans

As the Republicans work furiously to prepare their Christmas present for Mr.… Continue reading

Most Read