Free speech, hidden cameras don’t mix

USC lecturer Darry Sragow dismissed California Republicans as “really stupid,” “racist” and “angry old white people” before his political science class last fall. Those remarks wouldn’t be news — except that student Tyler Talgo secretly videotaped Sragow, and the bias-watchdog group Campus Reform posted 15 minutes of excerpts from the 2 1/2-hour class, which the Drudge Report picked up. That turned Sragow into a chew toy for cable news pundits.

As a Republican, I found his remarks offensive and inaccurate. Angry, old and white — those words apply to Sragow, too. I’ve known him for years as a Democratic operative, an attorney and a friend, when he’s not teaching this one course, designed to give students real-world perspective. No doubt Sragow would tell his clients that anything they say can be taped and used against them. So it’s ironic that he is caught up in the same trap that ensnared Mitt Romney when the candidate made his infamous 47 percent gaffe.

Sragow won’t talk on the record, but he released a statement, in which he said he stands by his remarks but regrets his “choice of words.”

As offended as I am by those words, I also am offended that Talgo secretly videotaped the class. Yes, Sragow was speaking in a public classroom, but he was not addressing the world. Secret tapings can only have a chilling effect on the classroom. As USC provost Elizabeth Garrett noted in a statement, “one of the most important principles of an academic community has been that academic inquiry and discussion be free from censorship or undue outside control.”

Most of my best professors were highly opinionated — two favorites were unapologetic socialists — and I would hate to see the fear of ridicule by cable news gag lively academics.

Alas, ever since James O’Keefe aired his infamous faux-pimp videos to ridicule ACORN by tricking low-level staffers into saying stupid things, some young conservatives have fallen for the romance of the self-styled journalist who, festering with grievances, strikes back by exposing liberal stupidity with the help of hidden recording devices and edited videotape.

Talgo eschewed O’Keefe’s bluster when we spoke over the phone Monday. I trust that when he is older, he will understand that it is wrong to take injudicious comments made for limited consumption and spread them across the Internet. Talgo told me he thought that if he had told Sragow he was taping the class, Sragow would have changed his tune, so he hid his camera.

Why didn’t Talgo confront Sragow instead? The sophomore told me he worked hard to get into USC. The tuition isn’t cheap. He said he felt slandered being called a stupid racist and “deserved better.”

Talgo also said he was afraid that if he confronted Sragow, Sragow might retaliate by giving him a real-world poor grade. As it is, he aced the class.

Fellow conservative and Sragow course alumna Emily Schrader did not appreciate Sragow’s GOP-bashing and agrees that academia is hostile to conservatives. Liberal professors have been known to grade conservatives unfairly, she told me, but she stood up to Sragow and found that he welcomed debate.

“Why didn’t (Talgo) say anything?” asked Schrader. “This was his opportunity to be a conservative activist.” As she wrote to the Daily Trojan, “we don’t need to silence the opinions of Liberal professors, we need to debate and engage.”

Debra J. Saunders is a San Francisco Chronicle columnist. Her email address is dsaunders@sfchronicle.com

More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Sunday, Feb. 18

A sketchy look at the day in politics.… Continue reading

Editorial: Capital gains tax could offer property tax relief

A bill would use tax revenue to keep seniors in their homes and lower the state’s property tax rate.

Viewpoints: Does ‘target-hardening’ schools make things worse?

Emphasizing security has the potential to change how teachers, students and staff see one another.

Commentary: Fight opioid crisis through health, recovery

When the problems are mental illness and addiction, chasing crisis calls is costly and doesn’t work.

Commentary: Amazon not using its leverage to help LGTBQ cause

The retail giant was key to LGTBQ causes in Washington state, but it can do more in other states.

Parker: We’re the adults, but this kid is one making sense

David Hogg, 17, was one of those locked down during the school shooting. Listen to a future leader.

Robinson: This isn’t about mental health; it’s about the guns

There were warning signs about Nikolas Cruz, yet he was able to purchase a military-style weapon.

Harrop: Trump’s budget sows bitterness among U.S. farmers

The blueprint does several things that would hit farmers hard including a loss of crop insurance.

Ignatius: How U.S. can ‘get to yes’ with Turkey on Syria

Syria is riven by “converging forces with diverging interests,” warns a senior Pentagon official.

Most Read