Let’s debate with decency, respect

A letter critical of Charles Krauthammer appeared in The Herald on Dec. 20. (“Columnist lost without Obama.”) In a Dec. 27 response to the letter, “Smart columnist challenges readers,” the writer was somehow led to conclude the following: 1) that the previous criticism was “symptomatic of one of the failings of the public school system.” 2) That “if left-leaning columnists used words like Mr. Krauthammer they would lose their readers, since most of them wouldn’t understand a word they said let alone the thoughts behind them.”

My unfortunate observation has been that there is a growing tendency in this forum to attack the intellect of those with whom we disagree. I doubt that this pattern is symptomatic of failings of yesteryear’s public school system but some people are still clearly struggling to grasp the basic concepts of decency and respect. It seems a reasonable guess that most of us would prefer to be spared the childish squabbling. Other than enabling us to vent our anger, offend fellow readers and make fools of ourselves, it serves little constructive purpose. (Granted, one positive aspect may be an increased appreciation for the many writers who attempt to persuade people to their points of view through reasoned discussion rather than insults and meaningless rhetoric.)

But back now to Charles: his credentials prove that he is indeed an extremely intelligent and capable man. He was also a strong advocate for the Iraq war. In light of that, I do find it remarkable that he is so willing to confidently condemn any opinion he doesn’t share.

Dan Postema

Everett

More in Opinion

Daydream is over; GOP must work with Democrats on ACA fix

Editorial: The Senate should end its latest ACA repeal effort and continue bipartisan talks.

Editorial cartoons for Sunday, Sept. 24

A sketchy look at the day in politics.… Continue reading

Viewpoints: Who’s going to clean up Equifax’s mess?

You are, for starters. But there are things that credit agencies could do to secure your data.

Commentary: Include employee profit-sharing in tax reform

Tying corporate tax reform to profit-sharing would provide a fairer share for the middle class.

Commentary: Give retail marijuana balanced consideration

Retail sale of cannabis is up to Snohomish voters, and there are reasons to support it.

Robinson: The GOP’s health care proposals keep getting worse

It’s hard to find anyone who knows anything about health insurance who likes this monstrous creation.

Will: America’s engine is being slowed by complacency

The Great Enrichment is being superseded by the Great Flinch, a recoil against friction and change.

Parker: 25 years later, woman’s disappearance fresh in mind

Over the years, the work to find Dail Dinwiddie evolved into efforts to find and protect others.

Keillor: Voices in unison sing out our desire for common good

When you stand in a crowd and sing, it does pull people together.

Most Read