Medicaid flaw is a ticking time bomb

Those states that are the poorest receive the highest Medicaid matching rates, as high as 73 cents on the dollar in Mississippi, while states with the highest incomes — like Washington — receive 50 cents on the dollar. The fatal flaw in this income-based formula is it ignores the fact that a few states, like Washington, have no income-based taxation.

Enter provider assessments. With one, our state established a daily average payment rate for nursing homes of $171.43 per patient for the current fiscal year. That Medicaid payment would otherwise average $160.93. Reducing it that much would take roughly $1 million a year from Everett patients alone. Additionally, federal Medicare cuts already loom as a threat — with or without the 2 percent cuts sequestration alone brings if we fall off the fiscal cliff.

A past 2003 assessment provided resources to help block proposed nursing home cuts of $72 million in successive legislative sessions — and instead afforded 5.6 percent in rate increases from 2003-2005. It’s no exaggeration to report this gambit kept care facilities solvent. Furthermore, Medicaid underfunding is a hidden “tax” upon private-paying patients of an extent greater than the pass-through costs of provider assessments.

In contrast, a hospital assessment enacted in 2010 has not met proponents’ hopes. Initially restoring cuts made in 2009, and intended to improve payments significantly, its revenue was diverted by a cash-strapped state to an extent where the mechanism simply reduced the scale of hospital cuts. Hospitals sued over the diversion. The assessment, which expires July 1, 2013, was expected to generate $419.6 million this biennium. Hospital advocates may debate whether its continuation’s benefits outweigh its costs — in a world of imperfect choices I think they do.

Moreover, they should retain the option to have that debate. President Obama has proposed reducing the ability of states to use provider assessments — saving $21.8 billion over 10 years — while Republican Tennessee Sen. Bob Corker has proposed eliminating them altogether over 10 years — saving $50 billion.

Neither plan works for Washington. Short of increasing, at the likely expense of some other state, Washington’s lousy federal medical assistance percentage, our congressional delegation must fight to preserve all tools available to return as much federal money as possible to our state.

Government austerity inexorably rolls downhill, leaving someone stuck with the bill, as we saw with Tacoma’s recent decision to end a tax exemption for nonprofit hospitals — picking up $5.5 million for 2013-14. A state budget already deeply in the hole for the coming fiscal biennium hardly needs misplaced federal austerity to make things worse, especially for those in medical need.

Olympia attorney and former state representative Brendan Williams is a long-term care advocate.

More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Monday, Oct. 23

A sketchy look at the day in politics.… Continue reading

Editorial: Can we please keep a civil tongue?

A recent EdCC forum asked panelists: Are you alarmed at the tone and tenor of civic discourse today?

Simoneaux: Our better angels have them outnumbered

You wouldn’t know it listening to some in news and politics, but there are good people out there.

Parker: What we needed to hear from a Republican president

It’s just too bad it wasn’t Trump speaking. Instead, he was being spoken to.

Everett mayoral race: Franklin best on homelessness issue

Regarding the Oct. 8, 2017 letter concerning the Everett mayoral election, I… Continue reading

Some limits would stem nation’s bloodshed from guns

Words can’t quantify or describe the horror of what unfolded in Las… Continue reading

Changes in culture explain recent shootings

Why? Why did he do it? They all ask about the Las… Continue reading

Editorial cartoons for Sunday, Oct. 22

A sketchy look at the day in politics.… Continue reading

Viewpoints: Gun control and the Founding Fathers

Laws regarding gun registration, public carry and more were around long before the Second Amendment.

Most Read