No blame, just help people

I keep hearing people on the news calling for someone to be held responsible for the mudslide in Oso. Consider for a moment, had the state told the landowners above the slide area that they couldn’t log (Oso/Darrington are logging communities supported by logging) that area because at some point in the future the clear cut areas could set up a situation where there could be a mudslide in the future. Do you think the landowners in that area would have been respectful of that decision by state geologists, or would the furor have been so loud that everyone would have heard it? I think the latter.

What about the people in the valley that bought property? What if the county had told them that they would not grant permits for people to build their homes in that valley because of the possible threat of slide in the future? Again, do you think landowners would have just said “OK well that is fine, I bought this land that is completely worthless, but I get your point about the slide thing?” Hardly. People should stop calling for someone to be held accountable for this. It’s a terrible thing that happened, but should someone be blamed, no. We decided we need logs and we decided that we want to use our land the way we want to use our land and because of that, sometimes bad things happen. Now start concentrating on the people that need help, and forget trying to blame someone.

Cary Cleland

Lake Stevens

More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Sunday, Jan. 21

A sketchy look at the day in politics.… Continue reading

Editorial: Don’t break the link between tests and graduation

Ending the testing requirement for a high school diploma would be a disservice to all students.

Viewpoints: Living with a force of nature we can’t control

California’s landslides — and Oso before it — show the need to map hazards and get out of the way.

Commentary: Flu presents a moving target for yearly vaccine

While the vaccine’s effectiveness can vary year to year, it’s still the best way to avoid influenza.

Commentary: A tip-credit would be more fair than wage hikes

The state’s minimum wage increase is working against many in restaurants. Here’s a better idea.

Will: Our past immigration criteria does not instill pride

By what criteria should we decide who is worthy to come amongst us? Consider our history, first.

Robinson: With no credible president, we are without a leader

It is unwise and impossible to take literally or seriously anything President Trump says.

Rampell: GOP’s tax law leaves states with deficits, headaches

Reform provisions will not only blow up federal deficits; they can also blow up state deficits.

River channel must be cleared before Index-Galena Road fixed

It is almost facetious to say that celebrating the rebirth of access… Continue reading

Most Read