Overturn Citizens United

Gangster Al Capone authored the negative-campaign credo. (Think of it as the reverse-raincoat version of the Golden Rule.) “Do it to them, before they do it to you,” Capone said. For now, the “them” is all Northwest consumers of news and entertainment, braced to watch sepia-toned political profiles while a disembodied voice intones about candidate X who apparently spent his 20s water-boarding widows and orphans. The tone evokes something primal, like the voice that warns you never to smoke. Be careful, the brakes tend to stick, the voice says. And watch out for the incumbent who enjoys tearing the wings off of flies.

Around the Northwest, the cavalcade of negative political ads wears down the television blab-off, just as it diminishes faith in the electoral process. Ideas are the foundation of a campaign, but defining the opponent — however embellished or out of context — is the scaffolding. Is there a constitutional way to make political speech more civil? No. The difference is the scale of mass communication and one key variable — financing.

After the U.S. Supreme Court’s 1976 Buckley v. Valeo decision, hemorrhaging money to influence elections became a form of constitutionally protected free speech. The hitching of money and politics culminated in the Court’s 2010 decision in Citizens United vs. the Federal Elections Commission, a ruling that ensured unions and corporations have zero restrictions on independent political expenditures. Cry “no restrictions” and let loose the dogs of the ad wars.

The primary value of Citizens United is its galvanizing effect. Republicans and Democrats both get slammed, and the public weathers the airwave fallout. Montana, which once had strict guidelines on independent expenditures, is catching the brunt. (Billings alone got hit with 31,241 ads, according to the New York Times.) In July, the Snohomish County Council passed a resolution advocating a constitutional amendment to overturn the Citizens United decision. It was one of several regional and national efforts to stir a groundswell to advance an amendment.

Plugging part of the money spigot by overturning the Citizens United decision (an inspired idea, we believe) still won’t compel candidates to be civil. One antidote is a candidate code of conduct, voluntary signed, swearing off negative ads (including darkened pics that resemble hangover-style mug shots.) In 1998, Rep. Jack Metcalf and challenger Grethe Cammermeyer agreed in principle to a conduct code, and it made for a mostly histrionics-free campaign. The problem? Third parties still weigh in, permitting candidates to feign ignorance as well as responsibility.

As Washingtonians mark their ballots, we begin to look critically at negative ads, teasing out the details of who is underwriting what and how this informs a candidate’s judgment and character. It’s OK to vote against the mean campaigner, especially if she or he claims it’s only politics. As Yeats wrote, “How can we tell the dancer from the dance?”

More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Tuesday, Jan. 16

A sketchy look at the day in politics.… Continue reading

Commentary: What’s love got to do with MLK Jr.’s dream?

For King, love was not sentimental; it’s a key part of creating communities that work for everyone.

Wilkinson: Trump may want to rethink his invite to Norwegians

If they come here they’ll just bring their socialized health care, Teslas and stunning good looks.

Harrop: Democrats need to learn how to strike up the band

Modesty is a fine character trait, but it’s sapping Democrats of a message that shows their success.

Saunders: Ethanol fuel mandate no longer makes sense

Intended to reduce reliance on foreign oil, it now only results in higher food and fuel costs.

Housing projects depend on capital budget passage by Jan. 17

Communities throughout Snohomish County and around the state are struggling with an… Continue reading

Where did man who shot, killed deputy get his gun?

Excuse me if you heard this before: “The only way to stop… Continue reading

Rep. DelBene is too rich to represent our district

We need to make Congress normal again. Right now, that’s just not… Continue reading

AG’s proposed assault weapon ban violates state Constitution

Once again Bob Ferguson is insisting on punishing law abiding Washingtonians by… Continue reading

Most Read