Recovery more complex than one man

Regarding the letter, “Accurate history is instructive” The writer is wrong to say that Roosevelt ended the Great Depression in 1940. It is true that some of the “New Deal” programs helped many thousands of people with make-work projects, such as the Works Progress Administration or WPA, usually referred to many as “We poke along”; and the Civilian Conservation Corps did a lot of long-lasting infrastructure building.

The only thing that ended the Depression, which by the way was pretty much worldwide, was the outbreak of World War II, in September 1939. In 1938, there were still some 11 million unemployed in the U. S. Great Britain began a small build-up just before Germany invaded Poland on Sept. 1, 1939, triggering the greatest increase in industrial production the world has ever known, thus ending the Depression.

I was a child then, but remember that for farmers, like my father, 1940 was the first profitable year since 1930. Like it or not, presidents actually have very little effect on employment or production. The causes of the Depression are complicated, and will always be subject to disagreements on which causes were most to blame. Much too complicated to cover here, but not the president’s fault; at best, or worst, Hoover had a minuscule part in what happened. It is always to easy to blame someone, or praise someone without understanding all the parts to whatever has happened.

F. L. “Pat” Jacobs


More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Friday, Jan. 19

A sketchy look at the day in politics.… Continue reading

Editorial: Help community colleges meet job training needs

Lost in the focus on K-12 school funding, have been the needs of community and technical colleges.

Ignatius: How military trains to let others do the fighting

The struggle for the U.S. military has been to accept letting other nations fight their own battles.

Milbank: Trump’s fine, but his Trumpism may be contagious

Trump may be in ‘excellent’ health, but has the White House doctor contracted his hyperbolic style.

Harrop: Immigration won’t get a fix because GOP doesn’t want it

Trump and Republicans in Congress prefer the status quo and their ability to use it politically.

County needs to plan better to prevent sprawl

Thank you for printing the commentary by Tom Campbell (“Time is now… Continue reading

This is how a stable president acts?

While claiming mental stability along with intellectual “genius” status, President Trump shows… Continue reading

Even a ‘limited’ nuclear war would be devastating

I wish to second the thoughts in the Jan. 12 letter to… Continue reading

Editorial cartoons for Thursday, Jan. 18

A sketchy look at the day in politics.… Continue reading

Most Read