Weir description is misleading

The Thursday letter, “Objections to dam misleading” is itself misleading. Describing the dam as an inflatable floating weir makes it sound like some oversized pool toy. In fact, plans call for a 7-foot high, 132-foot long steel crest gate attached to a 260-foot concrete foundation. Inflating rubber bladders between the two raises the crest gate to divert the river through a ½ mile tunnel into the turbines. Nothing will be floating.

Spawning salmon have had access to the habitat above Sunset Falls ever since the existing trap-and-haul facility was opened in 1958. SnoPUD has resisted describing planned improvements to the facility. In 2009, a record 124,248 fish were hauled above the falls. Fish numbers in most years were much less, averaging only 25,604 over 1958-2011, well below maximum capacity. The major factor determining the number of fish trapped and hauled is likely the number of fish successfully returning from the ocean.

Downstream migrating fish will be screened from the turbines, but must then survive two waterfalls with little water to cushion their fall, because up to 90 percent of the water will be diverted through the turbines. We don’t know what the resulting fish loss from injury and abrasion will be, but that loss will result in an equal loss of fish returning in later years. Even a few percent loss of fish is unlikely to be compensated by improving efficiency in the trap-and-haul. which usually uses less than 25 percent of present capacity.

I agree that energy conservation is the best solution.

Petrie Rainey, MD, PhD

Gold Bar

More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Sunday, Dec. 17

A sketchy look at the day in politics.… Continue reading

Viewpoints: Moving from grief to good 5 years after shooting

The determination of Sandy Hook families to turn unfathomable tragedy into good must be honored.

Commentary: Region has to consider options for U.S. 2 trestle

Waiting for lawmakers to pass another gas tax isn’t an option. We have to move forward now.

Commentary: Tighter rein needed on opioid makers, distrbutors

Doctors are working to better control prescriptions, but that won’t be enough to stem the epidemic.

Parker: When ‘credibly accused’ replaces due process

Giving more weight to accusations may feel justified at some level, but this should give us pause.

Robinson: Trump was right — Alabama did the right thing

‘The people of Alabama will do the right thing,’ tweeted Trump. Sadly for him, they did just that.

Petri: Ending net neutrality means innovation of bad options

With net neutrality’s end, consumers can choose to get worse service unless they pay more. Hooray!

Will: Whirlpool has Washington in a protectionist spin cycle

The appliance maker wants a U.S. trade panel to impose a 50 percent tariff on imported machines.

Most Read