Workers can make the transition

There have been many letters, both pro and con, about the machinists’ contract in recent weeks. I’m not a Boeing employee, and I claim no right to judge their decision, but an excerpt from the letter “Shifting burden hurts everyone” caught my attention.

With regard to the shifting of retirement planning risk from Boeing to the employees (i.e., defined benefit = pension vs. defined contribution = 401(k)), the writer says: “Is this a good thing? In my opinion, no. Why? this shift in plan design makes a group of employees responsible for their own outcomes. For many this is going to be an impossible task given that many are spenders not savers.”

Only about 26 percent of workers in this country now have access to a pension, with most of those being in the government sector where over 80 percent of employees still have access to a pension. The 401(k) was developed in the 1980s to encourage more workers to save and invest for their own retirement rather than rely completely on Social Security. I’m not arguing whether this seismic shift from pensions to 401(k)s is good or bad but it is reality. The point is that most people in this country are already “responsible for their own outcomes” when it comes to preparing for their retirement.

The writer then correctly hits on the key issue for retirement planning in this country: “This is going to be an impossible task given than many are spenders, not savers.” While we all long to be spenders and not savers, the reality is that we each have to plan for our own future. I, for one, have complete faith in the ability of Boeing workers to make this transition and plan responsibly for their own retirement, even with a changing set of retirement benefits. The writer is worried they will fail and be a burden on the rest of us. Let’s not underestimate them.

Tom Johnson


More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Tuesday, Dec. 12

A sketchy look at the day in politics.… Continue reading

Robinson: Black reporter of civil rights era an inspiration

If Simeon Booker could brave lynch mobs, today’s reporters can withstand Trump’s tweets.

Saunders: Nothing sacred in a year-old designation of monument

Why shouldn’t Trump be able to undo what Obama created just a year ago by executive order?

Harrop: Give president credit for good economy; thanks, Obama

The economy’s gains during Trump’s first year have benefited mostly from the inertia of Obama’s terms.

Other voices: Let states lower Medicaid prescription drug prices

If Congress won’t take action to lower prescription drug prices, allow the states to take the lead.

Welcome home to the sailors of Kidd and Shoup

What a beautiful and inspiring picture on the front page of the… Continue reading

How can sexual harassment fund in Congress be kept secret?

How can Congress justify making secret payments to settle claims of sexual… Continue reading

Editorial cartoons for Monday, Dec. 11

A sketchy look at the day in politics.… Continue reading

Editorial: Yet another owner for The Everett Clinic

After its brief time with DaVita, uncertainty returns for the clinic with its sale to an insurer.

Most Read