Is the Alex Smith trade good or bad news for the Seahawks?

As you’ve probably heard by now, the San Francisco 49ers have agreed to a trade that will send their backup quarterback, Alex Smith, to Kansas City in exchange for the Chiefs’ second-round pick this year, and a mid-round pick in 2014.

So what does this have to do with the Seahawks? Well for starters, the 49ers are Seattle’s biggest obstacle in the way of an NFC West title, so if San Francisco makes good use of those picks, that’s bad news for the Seahawks, right? The 49ers are loaded with picks now, so they could find an impact player or two that makes them better, or as many have speculated, they’re in a great position to package picks together for a trade if an impact player was available (Darrelle Revis or Percy Harvin, perhaps?). If the ‘Niners turn this trade into a player of that caliber, that’s obviously not good for the Seahawks.

Yet in a way this can be good news for the Seahawks. Like San Francisco, Seattle has a backup quarterback who could be a starter on a lot of quarterback-needy teams in the NFL. Pete Carroll and John Schneider have made it clear that they are happy to keep Matt Flynn and have a very good backup to Russell Wilson, but Schneider has also admitted on multiple occasions that he would listen to offers. And this is where the Smith deal comes in. Flynn was never going to command as high a price in a trade as Smith, who has been a starter and who led the 49ers to the NFC Championship game two seasons ago, but the 49ers got more for Smith than most anyone figured they would. So if Smith is worth a pick at the top of the second round and a mid-rounder next year, what does that make Flynn worth? Perhaps a third round pick plus a mid-to-late rounder? That’s better than a lot of people have been predicting for Flynn’s value, and now if a team tries to lowball the Seahawks in trade talks, they can point to the Smith trade as a starting point in negotiations. It’s no secret that this draft class isn’t strong at quarterback; that’s evident in what Kansas City gave up, and it should help the Seahawks get decent value if they should choose to move Flynn.

Of course, then the argument comes up of whether the Seahawks should trade a quality backup for something along the lines of a third-round pick. Should Wilson get hurt, Flynn would become one of the team’s most important players, but is it worth paying an insurance policy more than $5 million? And before you say that the Seahawks are fine on the salary cap this year, so Flynn’s salary doesn’t matter, remember that cap space rolls over, so replacing Flynn wouldn’t just mean saving money this year, it would mean having more cap space in the future, which will be important as many of Seattle’s key players have their rookie contracts coming up in the next two of years.

Is a good backup quarterback valuable? Absolutely. Is it more valuable than re-signing Kam Chancellor, who is a free agent after this year? Unless you’re assuming Wilson is going to miss a good chunk of next season, the answer is no. And if they can get some value for Flynn, I’m of the opinion that Schneider and Carroll would like to give him a chance to be a starter somewhere. They’ll only do so if they think they can help the team in the process, and after seeing the 49ers get real value for their backup, albeit a more accomplished backup, it appears Seattle will be able to get a decent return if they do trade Flynn.

More in Sports

Everett’s Patrick Bajkov eyes the puck with Tri-City’s Nolan Yaremko (left) closing at Angel of the Winds Arena Friday night in Everett on April 20, 2018. (Kevin Clark / The Daily Herald)
Tips edge Americans to take 1-0 lead in conference finals

Garrett Pilon scores twice as Everett wins 3-2 to hand Tri-City its 1st loss of the postseason.

Many later-round pass-catchers could be options for Seahawks

With all the attention on the Seahawks losses on defense this offseason… Continue reading

Friday’s prep results

Friday’s prep results, with links: BASEBALL Wesco 4A Cascade 11, Mariner 3… Continue reading

Three observations from the Tips’ 3-2 victory in Game 1

The Sutter line has a tough task; Everett needs to stay out of the box; how will fatigue factor?

Snohomish tops E-W in battle of 3A boys soccer contenders

The Panthers score twice off set pieces and beat the Warriors 2-1 to move into 2nd place in Wesco 3A.

Friday’s prep stars of the night

Here are Friday’s prep stars of the night: Iyanla Pennington, P, Jackson… Continue reading

Hannah Ganashamoorthy practices on the hurdles Wednesday afternoon at Monroe High School in Monroe on April 18, 2018. (Kevin Clark / The Daily Herald)
Monroe freshman phenom is a ‘once-in-a-lifetime’ athlete

Hannah Ganashamoorthy, 15, is already one of the top-ranked track-and-field athletes in the state.

Petersen’s philosophy guides UW despite success

The Huskies will still recruit players that fit the coach’s framework despite their national stature.

Tips’ hometown hero Wylie surges up NHL prospect rankings

The defenseman was recently No. 71 among North American skaters in the final pre-draft rankings.

Most Read