Niners resigned to leave controversial calls behind

  • By Jerry McDonald The Oakland Tribune
  • Monday, January 20, 2014 7:21pm
  • SportsSports

SANTA CLARA, Calif. — As they packed their belongings Monday, the 49ers weren’t inclined to throw a flag on the officials.

Officiating was a hot-button issue among 49ers fans after a 23-17 loss to the Seattle Seahawks in the NFC Championship game Sunday at CenturyLink Field, but an afterthought in the day-after locker room.

“In games like that, you’re always going to think about the what-ifs, especially on questionable calls,” 49ers center Jonathan Goodwin said. “I could play it over in my head for the whole offseason but it’s not going to change anything, unfortunately.”

Three plays in particular went the way of the Seahawks:

—A running into the kicker penalty against Seattle’s Chris Maragos against the 49ers’ Andy Lee on a fourth-and-10 punt from the 20-yard line in the third quarter.

On the Fox broadcast, analyst and former director of officiating Mike Pereira said since Maragos hit Lee’s plant leg, it should have been roughing the kicker—which carries with it a 15-yard penalty and a first down instead of a 5-yard penalty.

The 49ers declined the penalty, and the Seahawks’ ensuing possessions resulted in the drive which ended in Russell Wilson’s 35-yard fourth-and-7 touchdown strike to Jermaine Kearse.

—A fumble by Kearse which replay showed appeared to be recovered by NaVorro Bowman. Replay, however, is not used in fumble recovery situations. Marshawn Lynch was credited with the recovery.

One play later, a bad exchange between Wilson and Lynch resulted in a 49ers fumble recovery at the 15-yard line, rendering the play moot and giving the 49ers significantly better field position.

—An unnecessary roughness call on 49ers safety Donte Whitner, who broke up a pass intended for tight end Luke Willson. Whitner’s shoulder—not his head—struck Willson’s head. The Seahawks ended up punting on the drive.

Lee, the victim of the call that had the most significant impact, said he wasn’t sure if the play was a penalty or not and didn’t know the interpretation of the rule.

When asked if it should have been a roughing penalty, with the additional 10 yards, Lee said, “From what I understand,” but wasn’t interested in elaborating, not wanting to use it as an excuse.

Tight end Vernon Davis has seen calls go both ways and considers it an unsolved mystery.

“A lot of people will say the officials were on their side,” Davis said. “Maybe they were. Maybe they weren’t. We will never know. Sometimes you have games where (you think) the officials are favoring the opposing team, sometimes they’re on your side. You never know. It’s a tight window to really figure it out.”

Whitner said he made the same play he has made all season and “wasn’t fined one dollar, so we’ve got to do something about this.”

Outside linebacker Aldon Smith felt the responsibility for the end result rested with the 49ers.

“I played in the game so I saw some of the officiating, but I’m not going to blame anybody for how the game turned out,” Smith said. “(The officials) couldn’t play the game. We played the game, so we put on us and the coaches, no blame. Two good teams played and there was a winner.”

More in Sports

Kindopp ‘getting the job done’ for Silvertips

The Everett winger has been quietly contributing to the team’s recent success.

Seahawks sticking behind kicker Walsh despite struggles

Coach Pete Carroll says ‘He’s our guy,’ and the former Viking says he’s still as confident as ever.

A look at how the Huskies built their strength at linebacker

Tevis Bartlett, Keishawn Bierria and Ben Burr-Kirven all took different paths to starting roles with UW.

UW men’s basketball to retire Tacoma native Thomas’ No. 2 jersey

The NBA All-Star will be honored in Seattle during the Huskies’ Feb. 15 game against Utah.

Thursday’s prep results, with links to recaps

Here are Thursday’s prep sports results, with links to recaps: BOYS BASKETBALL… Continue reading

Three Storm players included in national team pool

Four-time Olympic gold medalist Sue Bird headlines the group

Thiel: Since his arrival, Brown has solidified Hawks’ O-line

Seattle’s O-line has gone from disaster to competent in just a few short weeks, thanks to their new LT.

M’s bolster bullpen, add Nicasio, two others

Seattle adds Juan Nicasio in free agency and trades for Shawn Armstrong and Anthony Misiewicz.

Five high schools are leaving the Cascade sports conference

Archbishop Murphy and Cedarcrest will have to find a new conference as the others form their own.

Most Read