SAN JOSE, Calif. – In war, politics and sports, it’s often said that the best defense is a strong offense. But the foot soldiers of computer security work differently: They scramble to build virtual walls that can blunt the impact of attacks.
Now, a Texas company wants to bring vigilante justice to cyberspace.
Symbiot Security Inc. says its new Intelligent Security Infrastructure Management Systems not only defends networks but lets them fight back, too. Symbiot says the product is already in use in some corporate, government and military networks.
Though the notion of striking back against bad guys may satisfy primal urges, most security experts question whether retaliation will actually halt cyberattacks. Instead the skeptics worry that fighting back could trigger lawsuits, Internet traffic jams and more digital onslaughts.
Ideas about going on the offensive against Internet attackers “have been bounced around for a while,” said senior analyst Jesse Dougherty of the security firm Sophos Inc. “But I don’t think anyone has been foolhardy enough to actually to form a company around the concept.”
Until now, that is.
The offering, known as iSIMS, comes amid growing frustration over computer intruders. The U.S.-government funded CERT Coordination Center handled 137,529 computer security incidents in 2003, up from 82,094 last year and 52,658 in 2001.
Hackers, worms and data attacks are costing companies dearly, and open the door to identity theft and the loss of intellectual property.
“Make no mistake,” reads a document on Symbiot’s Web site, “we are in the midst of an information warfare conflict which we have not been fighting.”
Symbiot’s iSIMS consists of hardware, software and support services. Much of it is focused on traditional defensive measures, like blocking unwanted traffic or deflecting it to where it can do no harm. But it can also escalate the response and return fire.
In documents on the Austin, Texas, company’s Web site, Symbiot advocates a gradual escalation of action based on the best information available and the customer’s preference.
However, privately held Symbiot won’t reveal what shape the most aggressive attacks might take. It also won’t say whether any iSIMS clients, whom it will not name, have taken aggressive offensive measures. It did say, however, that iSIMS has been deployed on “several enterprise, government and military networks.”
“When we’re talking about this, the technical details become extremely important,” said Tim Mullen, chief software architect of the secure accounting program maker AnchorIS.
Mullen, who has no relationship with Symbiot, says he supports striking back in certain situations.
A position paper attributed to Symbiot’s executives and posted on its Web site broadly outlines the counter-strike philosophy. “On the Rules of Engagement for Information Warfare” says computer intrusions deserve a response in kind – including “asymmetric” countermeasures that can include flooding the attacking computers with data, rendering them Internet-blind, and other measures to neutralize the problem.
Associated Press
From left, Symbiot Inc. founders Mike Erwin, Paco Nathan, Frank Milano, Jamie Pugh and William Hurley designed their computer security systems to defend and fight back against cyber- attacks.
Talk to us
> Give us your news tips.
> Send us a letter to the editor.
> More Herald contact information.
