Essays miss mark on economics, but offer food for thought

They’re both wrong about economics’ role in our current dysfunction.

Is economics to blame for the mess in Washington, D.C.? Is it the reason why we can’t seem to get along with one another anymore? Does economics have any value now, or has it been done in by its own unrealistic assumptions?

Two writers recently raised these questions. One pointed to an economic event that should have been controlled but wasn’t; and the other believes that economics has been blindsided by reality and rendered obsolete by other behavioral sciences.

The first writer, Michael Tomasky, recently published an essay on “The Real Legacy of the 1970s.” In it, he claims that the severe inflation that capped the economic expansion of the 1960s changed America in very fundamental ways.

To demonstrate just how fundamental the changes were he makes a comparison to the Great Depression of the 1930s. At that time, he writes, the economic losses brought people closer together. Friends, relatives and neighbors formed tighter bonds in adversity and helped each other cope with job losses and other economic setbacks. By contrast, in his view, the inflation of the 1970s drove us apart as inflation destroyed our savings and to avoid being left behind we had to become competitors in a heartless market.

It is a logical idea, and attractive for that reason, even though it paints an unappealing portrait of our society. A closer look, though, reveals some questionable assumptions.

One of the assumptions is that economic adversity promotes social ties. The images of Depression-era rent parties, neighbors donating money, food and household goods to laid-off workers owe more to Hollywood movies than reality. Closer to the reality of economic adversity was and is its portrayal in the blues song “Nobody Knows You When You’re Down And Out,” and in a line from Woody Guthrie’s folk song, “If You Ain’t Got The Do Re Mi.”

Another important but questionable assumption is that it was the inflation of the 1970s that drove people to a “casino mentality.” In fact, the road to this mentality had been paved in the 1920s and its stock market millionaires. It persists today not only with our tech millionaires and billionaires but also state-sponsored lotteries, sports gambling and online gambling knocking at the door.

There is no doubt that inflation, even at modest levels, erodes savings and sends people in search of safe places to earn more than traditional bank savings accounts.

It seems more likely that the restructuring of savings was due to a very old human nature issue: the tendency to allow greed to obscure risk. And, in this case, increased numbers of people searching for higher savings returns created a self-fulfilling prophecy by kicking the demand for stocks upward. The stock price increases, of course, only reinforced the greed and further obscured the risk.

The second writer, Fareed Zakaria, also poses an interesting question. His recent essay published in “Foreign Policy” magazine posed this question: “The End of Economics?” in which he argues that, “Human beings are rarely rational— so it’s time we all stopped pretending they are.”

The assumptions of economic theory have been a punching bag for critics and humorists for well over a hundred years. Thorstein Veblen mocked the “economic man” concept in economics, for example, as a “lightning-fast calculator of pleasure and pain.”

Zakaria is a critic of economics, certainly, but it is not clear what his principal reason is. He believes, for example, that economics was dealt a devastating blow by its failure to predict the financial crash of 2008. As the only proof of this, though, he cites only writings that appeared right after the crash itself — when people were still reeling and hardly in a position to put things into perspective.

More significantly, he fails to reveal any information that would support his point about rationality. As far as we know, people didn’t act irrationally and create the financial crisis. Instead, investors were encouraged to let their greed obscure the risks. Part of that encouragement, in fact, came from government agencies and large banks which would normally act as anchors for risk-evaluation decisions. But that is a very different thing from acting irrationally.

Zakaria’s essay offers behavioral economics as a replacement for current economic theory, citing the excellent work of Nobel laureate Daniel Kahneman and others in that area, to demonstrate that individuals do not always make rational decisions.

Behavioral economics is still in its infancy, though, and is no position to take on the responsibilities of guiding today’s economies through today’s hazards.

At bottom, both essays miss their targets. Inflation didn’t cause today’s polarized society, and economics is not collapsing because individuals sometimes, or even often, act irrationally. But both essayists gave us some things to think seriously about. That can’t hurt.

Talk to us

More in Herald Business Journal

Small business relief effort inundated with 850 applications

The economy in and around Everett has struggled amid fallen revenues and uncertainty about the future.

Marysville drivers wait overnight for Chick-fil-A opening

The popular chicken restaurant began serving at 6:30 a.m. Thursday. Police plan to guide traffic for days.

‘Hundreds of millions’ in bogus jobless benefits paid out

Washington state has been reported as the top target of a Nigerian fraud ring.

Tulalip Resort Casino and Quil Ceda Creek to open Tuesday

Guests must wear a mask and occupancy is limited, the Tulalip Tribes announced Wednesday.

As Arlington gym closes, a Snohomish barber continues to cut

PA Fitness closed after the state attorney general filed a lawsuit. “We would lose,” a co-owner conceded.

FAA says it will let Boeing employees vouch for plane safety

The agency defended the current system but identified areas for improvement. Some lawmakers disagree.

Fraudsters using local identities for phony jobless claims

The Everett School District, for example, saw about 310 false claims using employees’ personal information.

State sues an Arlington gym for violating stay-home order

“It is my constitutional right to be open,” says a co-owner of PA Fitness. He plans to countersue.

Heavy traffic expected when Chick-fil-A opens in Marysville

The city warns there will likely be delays for days along 88th Street NE. near the new restaurant.

Somers announces $14 million in relief for small businesses

One program will target aerospace companies. The other will focus on service and retail industries.

Paine Field terminal to close for 71 days of ramp repairs

Alaska is down to one departure per day due to the coronavirus outbreak’s effect on travel.

Quarantini time! New state rule allows cocktails to-go

Enjoy a margarita or a Manhattan with lunch or dinner to go. At Buck’s in Everett, you keep the mason jar.