Fund ratings can mislead investors

  • Saturday, September 15, 2001 9:00pm
  • Business

Associated Press

NEW YORK — In a nation ruled by its consumers, ratings are counted on to tout and criticize everything from sports-utility vehicles to hotels, from restaurants to, yes, even mutual funds.

But when it comes to fund ratings, experts in the field advise investors not to put too much stock into them.

"You’ve got to be really careful," said Eric Tyson, author of "Mutual Funds for Dummies." "I have seen ratings be significantly misused by many investors."

He explained that often by the time a mutual fund snags certain kudos, its heyday is nearly over. In other words, ratings are a lagging indicator, not an adequate predictor of future performance.

"Ratings can cause people to put their money in overheated sectors and to shun sectors that offer bigger value," Tyson said. "Maybe they have five stars because they are in hot sectors, and hot sectors eventually cool off."

But consumers naturally look to ratings to determine how to spend much of their money and their time, and that means ratings are here to stay.

In fact, Morningstar, the Chicago firm that has been ranking funds since 1986 and is known for its much-coveted five stars, last week announced it was expanding its ratings to include 500 stocks.

According to The Hulbert Financial Digest, ratings can mean much more if investors consider how the rankings themselves stack up.

"We believe that track records are what you look at. The real question is how have the ratings systems done, and that’s how you figure out which ratings systems to follow," said Mark Hulbert, publisher of the digest, which is sold to investors.

Since 1991 when the digest began tracking Morningstar ratings, Hulbert said that the firm’s five-star funds have underperformed the market.

However, financial pros admit that ratings are a good starting point for investors researching funds they might want to buy or sell.

"Sure it is a good signal of, ‘My gosh, you don’t want to have a fund that is two stars year after year.’ That signals that something is wrong," said Peter H. Calfee, a certified financial planner in Cleveland.

The important thing is to understand the rating system itself and the fact that each one works differently, Tyson said.

He said Morningstar is among the best fund rankers because it adjusts its ratings for risk. That means Morningstar takes into consideration how much risk funds undertake, instead of ranking them solely by total return.

While rankings are just the first step in investigating a fund, there’s plenty more investors should consider.

Calfee, the financial planner, recommended mutual fund investors analyze the fund manager’s performance and look up how the fund has done for at least the last five years.

Also, investors should look to see how the fund has performed relative to its benchmark. If a fund, for example, is benchmarked to the Standard &Poor’s 500 index, its performance should ideally surpass the S&P’s performance or at least mirror it.

"If you are going to pay a manager to manage, one would think, ‘Wouldn’t it be nice if they outperformed the benchmark? And, isn’t that why I am paying them?’ "

And don’t take just one ranking to heart. Get second opinions, so to speak.

"I would begin to match up all the various (fund) surveys — for Kiplinger’s, Barron’s, New York Times," Calfee said. "It’s a lot of work."

Copyright ©2001 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Talk to us

More in Business

Gillian Montgomery weighs a bag of bird seed at Wild Birds Unlimited on Monday, Oct. 23, 2023 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Bird and cat lovers flock to this Everett bird supply store

Bring on the birds! Locally owned Wild Birds Unlimited store can help turn your backyard into a “seedy” restaurant.

Brielle Holmes, 3, points to a stuffed animal that she likes at Wishes toy store on Monday, Oct. 23, 2023 in Alderwood, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Local toy store chain got its start as kiosk at Everett Mall

Wishes now operates eight stores, including three in Snohomish County. Its Alderwood mall store is a roomy 7,000 square feet.

Manager Rika Rafael, left, visual merchandiser April Votolato, center, and assistant manager and events coordinator Jaidhara Sleighter stand at the entrance of East West Books & Gifts’ new location Friday, Oct. 27, 2023, in downtown Edmonds, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
‘We were meant to be here’: East West Books Gifts reopens in Edmonds

Located in Seattle before the pandemic, the new store offers books and other resources on meditation, spirituality and yoga.

Members and supporters of the Snohomish and Island County Labor Council gather on Oct. 10 at the Edward D. Hansen Conference Center in Everett. The the Affiliate Labor Champion Award was given to the International Association of Machinists 751. Wes Heard, center, accepted the award on behalf of IAM 751. Photo credit: Snohomish and Island County Labor Council.
Snohomish & Island County Labor Council honors labor leaders

The labor council’s annual Champions Dinner recognized two local labor leaders and a machinists union last month.

Two students walk along a path through campus Thursday, Aug. 4, 2022, at Everett Community College in Everett, Washington. The college’s youth-reengagement program has lost its funding, and around 150 students are now without the money they need to attend classes. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Fewer students enroll at state’s public colleges, study says

Enrollment has picked up since the pandemic, but the lag threatens the state’s quest for education equity.

Michelle Roth is a registered nurse in the Providence Emergency Department on Sunday, January 23, 2022. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Health career job fair to be held Thursday in Everett

More than 14 health care related employers will attend the Snohomish County/Workforce Snohomish event.

Logo for news use, for stories regarding Washington state government — Olympia, the Legislature and state agencies. No caption necessary. 20220331
State gets $1 million grant to boost small-business exports

Washington’s Department of Commerce will use the federal grant to help small companies increase their export business.

NO CAPTION. Logo to accompany news of education.
Grant to help fund health care program at Edmonds College

  1. The $220,000 grant from Career Connect Washington aims to improve the college’s patient care technician program.

Trader Joe’s customers walk in and out of the store on Monday, Nov. 20, 2023 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Trader Joe’s to move store to Everett Mall, application says

Trader Joe’s could move from its current address — with a tight squeeze of a parking lot — to the former Sears location at Everett Mall.

Starbucks workers and allies participate in a strike and picket organized by Starbucks Workers United during the company's Red Cup Day Thursday, Nov. 16, 2023, at a location near Pike Place Market in Seattle. (AP Photo/Lindsey Wasson)
Starbucks workers in Everett, Marysville join national strike

Hundreds of Starbucks union workers at 15 locations across Washington joined the one-day strike.

Summit Everett, a rock climbing gym, in Everett, Washington on Wednesday, Nov. 15, 2023. Summit will move into the former Grand Avenue Marketplace space, a retail location that has been vacant for five years. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Everett climbing gym to close, move to new downtown site

Summit Everett, a Rucker Avenue anchor, will open a new facility next year one block west on Grand Avenue.

A whiteboard inside Richie del Puerto's auto tech classroom at Sno-Isle Technical Skills Center on Tuesday, Nov. 2, 2021 in Everett, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Explore apprenticeship programs at free Everett job fair Nov. 16

The Sno-Tech Skills Center job fair features 30 apprenticeship programs from construction to health care.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.