LANSING, Mich. — Americans for Prosperity, the conservative advocacy group supported by the Koch brothers, has launched an effort to torpedo a proposed settlement in the Detroit bankruptcy case, potentially complicating chances for completing the deal just as its prospects seemed to be improving.
The organization, formed to fight big government and spending, is contacting 90,000 conservatives in Michigan and encouraging them to rally against a plan to provide $195 million in state money to help settle Detroit pension holders’ claims in the case, a key element of the deal.
The group has threatened to run ads against members of the Republican-controlled Legislature who vote in favor of the appropriation before the state’s August primary. An initial legislative vote may come this week.
Using public money for Detroit’s case “is very toxic, especially to out-state and Republican, conservative-leaning individuals,” said Scott Hagerstrom, director of the Americans for Prosperity’s chapter in the state. “Even out-state Democrats, why send any more money to Detroit? Certainly other areas of the state have needs.”
The group’s move is a blow to Republican Gov. Rick Snyder, who proposed the state cash as a final ingredient to bring the 10-month-long bankruptcy case to a conclusion. Some creditors are fighting the “grand bargain,” but it recently drew support from major retiree groups and unions. The bankruptcy court trial on the city’s case will be held this summer.
“This is a settlement. This not a bailout,” Snyder said. “And I want to be very, very clear about that.”
Ten-year-old Americans for Prosperity, which plans to spend at least $125 million nationally helping conservatives in the midterm elections, is becoming more active in state politics. Its willingness to spend millions for advertising has made it a powerful player in political contests.
Dave Doyle, a political strategist and former chairman of the Michigan Republican Party, said the organization’s opposition could make a difference even though polling shows considerable public support for a settlement.
“What does have an impact is if they start spending a lot of money on TV and radio and doing mailings into people’s districts. The threat of that would get some people to pay attention,” he said.
Snyder, who took the lead in resolving Detroit’s fiscal crisis by appointing an emergency manager for the city’s operations, proposed the $195 million to match commitments from private foundations. The money would limit pension cuts for the approximately 30,000 retirees and city workers to no more than 4.5 percent and avert the need to liquidate the Detroit Institute of Art’s collection to raise money. Snyder and city leaders say the museum is important to rebuilding Detroit as a world-class city.
Despite the cost, “It would be more positive to get this behind us,” Snyder said. “How many of us have traveled somewhere in the country or the world and had to listen about this bankruptcy?”
But the question is a tough sell for many Republicans, who blame the Democratic-dominated city’s problems on corruption and overly powerful labor unions.
“I think every member of the Legislature wishes we weren’t in this situation where we even have to consider it,” said Rep. Robert VerHeulen, a Republican from conservative western Michigan.
VerHeulen said he worries about setting a bailout precedent if other cities fall into financial ruin but also sees the value in settling to keep pensioners from suing.
Snyder, a computer company CEO and venture capitalist before he became governor in 2011, has a mixed record in lobbying the Legislature’s more conservative Republicans. He persuaded just enough to support expanding Medicaid to more low-income adults yet failed to win legislative support for a state-run health insurance marketplace.
Republican House Speaker Jase Bolger has warned that the bills may not advance unless the city workers’ unions agree to kick in some cash toward the settlement. Snyder must also persuade Democrats despite their unhappiness with his use of his executive powers to take over control of Detroit’s finances.
Americans for Prosperity intends to turn up the heat on the Republicans, who hold 26 of the 38 seats in the Senate and 59 of 110 House districts.
“Tell Lansing politicians that Detroit has gotten enough of our tax dollars,” the group says on a website created to oppose the aid. “More money can’t fix Detroit.”
[—][—][—]
Follow David Eggert at http://twitter.com/DavidEggert00
Talk to us
> Give us your news tips.
> Send us a letter to the editor.
> More Herald contact information.
