Will ‘free stuff’ tempt Americans to try socialism?

They base their decision on genuine economic research, they will not.

Malcolm Forbes was an energetic supporter of free market capitalism. His private airplane, a DC-9, was emblazoned with the words “CAPITALIST TOOL.” The term had been used by the Soviets during the Cold War to describe his weekly business publication and it quickly became the magazine’s motto, and his.

Technically, capitalism and socialism are economic terms, not political terms, but each described forms of economic organization that quickly became rivals…and politicized. In the process, “capitalist” and “socialist” took on a second life as pejoratives.

Karl Marx was not the first socialist, but his ideas were ultimately the most successful in capturing a political following. His idea that capitalists prospered by exploiting labor seemed to track with the miserable workplace conditions in the 19th century capitalist economies — especially in Germany and Great Britain which he analyzed and wrote about most specifically. Most of today’s socialist arguments are still focused on workplace conditions, allegations of exploitation and income inequality.

Marx was born in 1818, and perhaps coincidentally, the 200th anniversary of his birth has seen socialism, “…making a comeback in American political discourse.” This observation marks the beginning of a recent report by the Council of Economic Advisers (CEA) which advises the president on economic policy.

The CEA report is entitled, “The Opportunity Costs of Socialism,” and it provides a valuable picture of the historical development and current status of socialism in our world today. Anyone wanting a jargon-free, math-free and even gluten-free “read-in” into the development, track record and potential of socialism could profit greatly by reading at least the report’s two-page executive summary. It couldn’t have come at a better time for, as its authors note, “Detailed proposals from self-declared socialists are gaining support in Congress and among much of the electorate.”

In the report, the CEA makes an important point that in today’s developed world there are not absolutely capitalist or socialist economies. They are all mixtures of both systems. Describing an economy as socialist or capitalist becomes a matter of degree — the proportions of the mix. We use terms like “moderately socialist” and “highly socialist,” for example, to describe economies that have some, or considerable amounts of free market forces within them.

The absolute socialist economies belong to the past — although North Korea and Cuba remain as ghosts. Today’s socialists do not want to talk about the now defunct Soviet Union or China under Mao Tse Tung. Each of these large-scale examples began with a bloodbath revolution and proceeded from that to mass extinctions, starvation, economic failure and widespread misery. None of this record is ideal as a marketing tool for the socialist idea.

There are, however, examples of partially socialized economies whose histories don’t involve dictatorships and bloodbaths. In Great Britain, for example, some industries were socialized while allowing the rest to function in the free market. The U.K. economy also provides an example of how a democracy can change its mind. Some industries like steel, for example, were socialized and then sold back to private capital when social control wasn’t working out.

The Nordic countries are often cited by today’s socialists as examples of successful socialist economies. They are certainly “largely socialist” economies but, as the CEA points out, this was not a cost-free exchange of economic structures.

The CEA report estimated what the opportunity cost would be, for example, if the U.S. economy were reshaped to resemble the Nordic model. It concluded that, “American families earning the average wage would be taxed $2,000 to $5,000 more per year net of transfers if the United States had current Nordic policies. Living standards in the Nordic countries are at least 15 percent lower than in the United States.”

The biggest problem with socialism, even if it preserves democracy, is the loss of the price system. With all of its faults the free market price system is remarkably efficient in allocating resources, including capital — far more so than any known substitute.

The loss of that efficiency has its price, and it is in economic growth. The Nordic countries recognized that problem and years ago began bringing back private enterprise. The result is that the Nordic economics are generally less socialized than they had been in the 1970s.

Whether the public in America will consider the costs of socialism when its benefits — “free stuff” — are dangled in front of them is a political question that economists are not equipped to answer. There is a very real possibility that we will have to face that question soon, though, and that means that the pejoratives and smears will be flying.

In that kind of information environment reports based on genuine economic research and comparisons will be especially valuable to voters looking to decide whether socialism is worth its costs.

James McCusker is a Bothell economist, educator and consultant.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Business

Lily Lamoureux stacks Weebly Funko toys in preparation for Funko Friday at Funko Field in Everett on July 12, 2019.  Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Everett-based Funko ousts its CEO after 14 months

The company, known for its toy figures based on pop culture, named Michael Lunsford as its interim CEO.

The livery on a Boeing plane. (Christopher Pike / Bloomberg)
Former Lockheed Martin CFO joins Boeing as top financial officer

Boeing’s Chief Financial Officer is being replaced by a former CFO at… Continue reading

Izaac Escalante-Alvarez unpacks a new milling machine at the new Boeing machinists union’s apprentice training center on Friday, June 6, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Boeing Machinists union training center opens in Everett

The new center aims to give workers an inside track at Boeing jobs.

Some SnoCo stores see shortages after cyberattack on grocery supplier

Some stores, such as Whole Foods and US Foods CHEF’STORE, informed customers that some items may be temporarily unavailable.

People take photos and videos as the first Frontier Arlines flight arrives at Paine Field Airport under a water cannon salute on Monday, June 2, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Water cannons salute Frontier on its first day at Paine Field

Frontier Airlines joins Alaska Airlines in offering service Snohomish County passengers.

Amit B. Singh, president of Edmonds Community College. 201008
Edmonds College and schools continue diversity programs

Educational diversity programs are alive and well in Snohomish County.

A standard jet fuel, left, burns with extensive smoke output while a 50 percent SAF drop-in jet fuel, right, puts off less smoke during a demonstration of the difference in fuel emissions on Tuesday, March 28, 2023 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Sustainable aviation fuel center gets funding boost

A planned research and development center focused on sustainable aviation… Continue reading

Helion's 6th fusion prototype, Trenta, on display on Tuesday, July 9, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Helion celebrates smoother path to fusion energy site approval

Helion CEO applauds legislation signed by Gov. Bob Ferguson expected to streamline site selection process.

Pharmacist John Sontra and other employees work on calling customers to get their prescriptions transferred to other stores from the Bartell Drugs Pharmacy on Hoyt Avenue on Wednesday, July 2, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Bartell Drugs location shutters doors in Everett

John Sontra, a pharmacist at the Hoyt Avenue address for 46 years, said Monday’s closure was emotional.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.