‘Agora’: Rachel Weisz shines in peculiar historical drama

  • By Robert Horton Herald Movie Critic
  • Thursday, July 22, 2010 10:26pm
  • LifeGo-See-Do

There are a couple of sequences in “Agora” where the pursuit of a scientific idea becomes as suspenseful as a car chase along a cliff: Where acting and camera angle and lighting conspire to make a revelation about the solar system and its planetary orbits into a true Hitchcock moment.

For that alone, “Agora” merits extra praise — but it deserves some attention, too, for its no-punches-pulled social comment and its stirring lead performance by Oscar-winner Rachel Weisz.

Plus, the movie is just odd.

It’s set in the fourth century, in Alexandria, home to a famous library and a community of different religious groups: pagans, Jews and the growing minority of Roman Christians.

Weisz plays Apatia, a historical figure much celebrated in the lore that followed her life and death. The film’s Apatia is notable for her intellectual prowess (there don’t seem to be a lot of women teaching in the local gymnasium) and her lack of interest in romance.

While tracking the various political quarrels in Alexandria, which lead to a violent conclusion, the movie also follows Apatia’s dogged inquiry into the behavior of the planets. The religious leaders of the day are insistent that Earth is at the center of the universe, with everything else revolving around it, but Apatia is starting to doubt.

Hundreds of years before Galileo, she seems to be getting the jump on figuring out the whole solar-system thing. That kind of blasphemy can get you killed, which is where some of the suspense in “Agora” comes from.

In depicting a world in which reason and rational thought are constantly bedeviled by ignorance and superstition, “Agora,” of course, is completely unrelated to the world we live in today.

Yeah, right. Actually, the parallels with present-day fundamentalism are so strong that it’s not hard to see why director Alejandro Amenabar (“The Others”) pursued this project right now. And he doesn’t disguise his complete identification with Apatia’s humanist heroine.

Weisz is quietly spellbinding in the role, and although she dominates the film, the key supporting parts are smartly cast as well. The intriguing Oscar Isaac (recently being nasty in “Robin Hood”) plays a suitor and a well-connected Alexandrian; Max Minghella a slave vulnerable to radical ideas; and the eerie Ashraf Barhom (a scene-stealer in “The Kingdom” and “Clash of the Titans”) a street agitator.

This is a peculiar film, with its strangely set-bound, sealed-off look and its earnest approach. Its sincerity is corny at times, yet its argument is potent. And its conclusion does not bode well for the rationalists.


A story based on the historical figure Apatia (a stirring performance by Rachel Weisz), who pursued new intellectual ideas about the universe in fourth-century Alexandria while religious fundamentalists got the upper hand. Director Alejandro Amenabar clearly intends parallels with our current times, and he succeeds, even if the movie feels earnestly cornball at times.

Rated: Not rated; probably R for nudity, violence.

Showing: Guild 45th.

Talk to us

More in Life

Brian Geppert holds a birdhouse made of skis at his home in Lynnwood, Washington on Saturday, March 11, 2023. Geppert started a recycling program for the greater Seattle area, which has saved hundreds of skis from their demise. He turns the skis into functional art for the home, such as coat racks, bottle openers, bookends, shelves, candle sconces, toilet plungers, beer flights, and more. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Boeing engineer turns old ski gear into household essentials

If Lynnwood’s Brian Geppert isn’t on the slopes, then he’s turning skis into coat racks and bottle openers.

Give your home some extra love with a deep clean this spring. (Jennifer Bardsley)
Roll up your sleeves and tackle these 15 spring cleaning steps

A lot of work? Sure. But it beats paying $800 for a cleaning service to do all this stuff.

What to do when a co-worker makes you miserable

It’s counterintuitive, but you need to get to know that person better. You don’t need to be friends — just understand them better.

Positano, the jewel of Italy's Amalfi Coast, hugs the rugged shoreline.
Rick Steves’ Europe: Glitzy Positano: Not just a pretty facade

It’s one of the most romantic and chic stops on Italy’s Amalfi Coast, a place of beaches, sunshine and picturesque towns.

Lyft charged her $150 for mud stains in a car. But she didn’t do it!

Debbie Kim is shocked to find a $150 charge from Lyft on her credit card. What did she do — and is there a way to undo it?

Hurtado works in a tattoo style called “fine line.” (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Tattoo artist draws a fine line

Ernesto ‘Nesto’ Hurtado of Wicked Boy Tattoo in Lynnwood specializes in a minimalist style that draws praise and criticism.

Caption: Three years after the pandemic began, simple items like masks, disinfecting wipes and toilet paper stir up deep memories.
Psychological impact of pandemic lingers three years later

When the words “two-item limit” in supermarkets still strike fear, it’s hard to toss pandemic relics like cloth masks.

Is every day Groundhog Day — and the same old bad habits?

How can we embrace change without waking up every morning to the same day?

Christian pilgrims and tourists are drawn to the dramatically situated Mont St-Michel, a soaring island abbey in Normandy that is completely surrounded by the sea at high tide.
Rick Steves on Mont St-Michel, Normandy’s magnificent island abbey

Solitude drew monks to this rock outpost long, long ago. Today, it’s crowded with tourists.

Most Read