Denzel Washington makes his point with debate flick

  • By Robert Horton Herald Movie Critic
  • Wednesday, December 26, 2007 3:10pm
  • LifeGo-See-Do

Denzel Washington directs movies like a man with a goal: to present stories of uplift and inspiration. Fair enough, but when the results are as well-scrubbed and wholesome as “Antwone Fisher,” the film can be pretty dull.

Washington’s new one, “The Great Debaters,” is better. Set in 1935, the film tells a fictionalized version of a true story about a debate team from a small black Texas college that went up against some formidable foes.

We watch the four members of the Wiley College team prepare under the stern tutelage of professor Melvin Tolson (that’s Washington). They slay the local competition. As his team begins to get noticed, Tolson wangles a national showdown: debating Harvard.

In the meantime, Tolson secretly works as a union organizer, which doesn’t make him popular with local landowners or the local sheriff (John Heard).

Notable among the debaters is a 14-year-old prodigy (Denzel Whitaker), the son of a distinguished scholar (Forest Whitaker). The young actor is not related to other people in the cast named Denzel or Whitaker, by the way.

There’s also a bit of romance between two debaters, played by the engaging Jurnee Smollett and Nate Parker. There’s nothing too earth-shattering in any of this, since Washington’s interest is not so much in the people as the issues.

The film looks handsome, and the debates are intelligently written. The tone wobbles a bit during the debates, as the Wiley College squad seems to violate the careful instructions of its own coach, but perhaps director Washington was aware that a movie about a debate team might need a little extra juice at times.

As Tolson, Washington works a slightly rumpled variation on his usual forceful persona, and he gives up center stage to his younger players. The one female member of the team catches fire most often. Smollett, who has an unpredictable quality — she seems to go from cool to saucy within the space of a few seconds — looks like a star in the brewing.

So this is a nicely managed story with a sturdy underdog angle. It isn’t really interesting beyond that, but “The Great Debaters” seems destined to have a long life being shown in schools and family living rooms.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Life

Artemidorus, Flight Patterns, a Sherlock Holmes mystery and more

Music, arts and more coming to Snohomish County

Brandon Tepley does a signature Butch pose while holding a vintage Butch head outside of his job at Mukilteo Elementary where he is dean of students on Thursday, Jan. 22, 2026 in Mukilteo, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
The secret life of Butch T. Cougar, WSU mascot

Mukilteo school dean Brandon Tepley and other mascots talk about life inside — and after — the WSU suit.

Cherry Sweetheart. (Dave Wilson Nursery)
The Golfing Gardener: Cheerful Cherries

As we continue to work through the home orchard, sweet and delicious… Continue reading

The 2026 Subaru Crosstrek Hybrid compact SUV.
2026 Subaru Crosstrek Hybrid has a new powertrain

A series-parallel system replaces the former plug-in hybrid setup.

‘A story worth telling’: Snohomish County did it before Woodstock

Local author J.D. Howard reminds readers of The Sky River Rock Festival, a forgotten music milestone.

Stanley is an Italian-type variety of plum. (Dave Wilson)
The Golfing Gardener: Precocious Plums

As promised, I will continue to delve into the wonderful world of… Continue reading

Curtis Salgado will perform at the Historic Everett Theatre on Friday. (Dena Flows)
Curtis Salgado, Flight Patterns, 9 to 5 and more

Music, arts and more coming to Snohomish County

Freshened design for the 2026 Kia Sportage compact SUV includes new front and rear bumpers.
2026 Kia Sportage loads up on new tech features

Changes revolve around the infotainment and driver assistance systems.

A peach tree branch with buds. (Sunnyside Nursery)
The Golfing Gardener: What a Peach!

One of the true pleasures in the world of gardening has always… Continue reading

Jana Clark picks out a selection of dress that could be used for prom on Wednesday, May 14, 2025 in Snohomish, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
A basement closet in Snohomish is helping people dress for life’s biggest moments — for free

Call her a modern fairy godmother: Jana Clark runs a free formalwear closet from her home, offering gowns, tuxes and sparkle.

Rotary Club of Everett honors Students of the Month for the fall semester

Each month during the school year, the Rotary Club of Everett recognizes… Continue reading

Sarcococca blooming early. (Sunnyside Nursery)
The Golfing Gardener: The dilemma of dormancy

Winter may have just begun, but it has been a strange one… Continue reading

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.